(UM)
-
Protipravno pridobljeni dokazi v slovenski sodni praksiDrnovšek, Katja, pravnica ; Kraljić, SuzanaSlovenska zakonodaja problematike dopustnosti protipravno pridobljenih dokazov v pravdnem postopku normativno ne ureja, zaradi česar se je ključno pravilo za presojo tovrstnih dokazov razvilo v ... ustavnosodni praksi. Odločba Ustavnega sodišča RS št. Up-472/02-12 z dne 7. 10. 2004, ki dopustnost protipravnih dokazov obravnava skozi prizmo ustavnih procesnih jamstev, še po 15 letih predstavlja temeljno pravno podlago za tehtanje pravic v koliziji. Skozi čas so se pokazale nekatere težave, povezane s tako uveljavljenim pristopom, ki so še posebej očitne ob pregledu dokaj neusklajene sodne prakse slovenskih sodišč. Slednjo namreč zaznamujejo precej nedodelane obrazložitve, pavšalne utemeljitve in zaostajanjem za siceršnjim razvojem sodne prakse s področja varovanja ustavnih pravic in svoboščin. Prispevek bo naslovil nekatere izmed najbolj očitnih težav, ki izhajajo že iz same odločbe št. Up-472/02-12, v sodni praksi pa so dosegle dodatne dimenzije. Pri tem se bo osredotočil na analizo sicer redkih primerov, v katerih so se sodišča soočala z odločanjem o dopustitvi dokazov, pridobljenih s kršitvijo človekovih pravic, njihova kritika pa se bo opirala tudi na dognanja slovenske pravne doktrine. Posebna pozornost bo namenjena ustreznosti metodološkega pristopa pri tehtanju pravic (načelo sorazmernosti ali praktična konkordanca), pomenu pravice do dokaza v postopku vrednotenja in tehtanja ter kakovosti obrazložitev sodnih odločb.Source: Zbornik radova VII. međunarodnog savjetovanja "Aktualnosti građanskog procesnog prava - nacionalna i usporedna pravnoteorijska i praktična dostignuća", 23. i 24. rujna 2021. godine (Str. 223-250)Type of material - conference contribution ; adult, seriousPublish date - 2021Language - slovenianCOBISS.SI-ID - 78837507
Author
Drnovšek, Katja, pravnica |
Kraljić, Suzana
Topics
pravica do dokaza |
tehtanje pravic |
načelo sorazmernosti |
praktična konkordanca |
dokazovanje v pravdnem postopku |
right to evidence |
balancing rights |
principle of proportionality |
practical concordance |
evidence taking in litigation
Shelf entry
Permalink
- URL:
Impact factor
Access to the JCR database is permitted only to users from Slovenia. Your current IP address is not on the list of IP addresses with access permission, and authentication with the relevant AAI accout is required.
Year | Impact factor | Edition | Category | Classification | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
JCR | SNIP | JCR | SNIP | JCR | SNIP | JCR | SNIP |
Select the library membership card:
If the library membership card is not in the list,
add a new one.
DRS, in which the journal is indexed
Database name | Field | Year |
---|
Links to authors' personal bibliographies | Links to information on researchers in the SICRIS system |
---|---|
Drnovšek, Katja, pravnica | 36801 |
Kraljić, Suzana | 15692 |
Source: Personal bibliographies
and: SICRIS
Select pickup location:
Material pickup by post
Delivery address:
Address is missing from the member's data.
The address retrieval service is currently unavailable, please try again.
By clicking the "OK" button, you will confirm the pickup location selected above and complete the reservation process.
By clicking the "OK" button, you will confirm the above pickup location and delivery address, and complete the reservation process.
By clicking the "OK" button, you will confirm the address selected above and complete the reservation process.
Notification
Automatic login and reservation service currently not available. You can reserve the material on the Biblos portal or try again here later.
Subject headings in COBISS General List of Subject Headings
Select pickup location
The material from the parent unit is free. If the material is delivered to the pickup location from another unit, the library may charge you for this service.
Pickup location | Material status | Reservation |
---|
Reservation in progress
Please wait a moment.
Reservation was successful.
Reservation failed.
Reservation...
Membership card:
Pickup location: