Lunar mare regolith is traditionally thought to have formed by impact bombardment of newly emplaced coherent solidified basaltic lava. We use new models for initial emplacement of basalt magma to predict and map out thicknesses, surface topographies and internal structures of the fresh lava flows, and pyroclastic deposits that form the lunar mare regolith parent rock, or protolith. The range of basaltic eruption types produce widely varying initial conditions for regolith protolith, including (1) autoregolith, a fragmental meter‐thick surface deposit that forms upon eruption and mimics impact‐generated regolith in physical properties, (2) lava flows with significant near‐surface vesicularity and macroporosity, (3) magmatic foams, and (4) dense, vesicle‐poor flows. Each protolith has important implications for the subsequent growth, maturation, and regional variability of regolith deposits, suggesting wide spatial variations in the properties and thickness of regolith of similar age. Regolith may thus provide key insights into mare basalt protolith and its mode of emplacement. Plain Language Summary Following recent studies of how lava eruptions are emplaced on the lunar surface, we show that solid basalt is only one of a wide range of starting conditions in the process of forming lunar soil (regolith). Gas present in the lavas during eruption also produced bubbles, foams, and explosive products, disrupting the lava and forming other starting conditions for mare soil parent material. Key Points New basalt magma emplacement models explore fresh lava flows that form the lunar mare regolith parent rock, or protolith Some conditions predict immediate formation of a fragmental meter‐thick “autoregolith” that mimics impact‐generated regolith Lava flows with significant near‐surface vesicularity, macroporosity, and magmatic foams will create nontraditional regolith growth rates