Despite increasing wildfires, few studies have investigated seasonal water quality responses to wildfire characteristics (e.g., burn severity) across a large number of lakes. We monitored 30 total lakes (15 burned, 15 control) monthly following the Greenwood Fire in Minnesota, USA, a lake‐rich region with historically prevalent wildfire. We found increases in median concentrations of total nitrogen (68%), total phosphorus (70%), dissolved organic carbon (127%), total suspended solids (71%), and reduced water clarity (48%) and pH (0.45) in burned lakes. Post‐wildfire responses in drainage lakes were often persistent or cumulative throughout the open‐water season, compared to isolated lakes. Total phosphorus (TP) increased linearly with watershed high‐severity burns, and shoreline high‐severity burns explained more variation in TP than lake morphometry and watershed variables. Post‐wildfire chlorophyll‐a responses were nonsignificant and inconsistent, possibly due to light limitation. Our results suggest that increasing wildfires have significant potential to affect water quality of inland lakes. Plain Language Summary Despite increasing wildfire activity, there has been limited research on wildfire effects on lakes. We monitored lake water quality throughout summer 2022 following the 2021 Greenwood Fire in Minnesota, USA, a lake‐rich region where wildfire was historically common. We found that lakes with burned watersheds were more nutrient‐ and carbon‐rich and more acidic and murky. Responses often increased throughout the summer, particularly for lakes with tributaries from burned areas. However, murkier water may have prevented increased nutrients from increasing algae abundance. Water quality responses were greater following burns near lake shorelines and of greater severity, reflecting damage to vegetation and soil. Our results suggest that increasing wildfire under climate change may degrade lake water quality. Key Points We observed post‐wildfire increases in nutrients, dissolved organic carbon, sediments, and acidity and reduced water clarity in lakes Water quality responses were often persistent or cumulative throughout the summer, especially for lakes with tributaries from burned areas High‐severity and shoreline burns resulted in a nearly two‐fold increase in total phosphorus concentration compared to control lakes