The effect of tempering temperature on surface hardened AISI H13 tool steel by laser remelting process using an Yb-fiber laser has been investigated. Single remelting tracks were produced in argon environment at different laser power and scan speed in the range of 400–600 W and 200–1600 mm/min respectively, maintaining the laser spot diameter fixed at 3 mm. Their effects on geometrical aspects, microstructure and microhardness were analyzed considering the thermal history of molten pool recorded using an IR pyrometer. Microstructure was found to be associated with cooling rate and melt pool lifetime, estimated from the temperature signal. Thereafter, remelted surface with 30% overlapping tracks was generated and subjected to 1 h tempering cycle at different temperatures in 500–900 °C range followed by hardness and wear tests. Hardness was retained fully up to 500 °C and significant softening occurred at 600 °C and 700 °C. At 800 °C and higher temperatures, effects of laser remelting were impaired completely, but substrate got hardened through martensite formation in a conventional manner. Wear resistance followed the trend of hardness. Changes in microstructure and formation of various phases were found to be the reasons behind the modifications in hardness. •Laser remelting of H13 and its hardness retention after subjecting to tempering is reported•Safe operating temperature for laser remelted H13 tool steel is reported.•Changes in microstructure and mechanical properties with tempering temperature are reported.•Process parameters, molten pool thermal history, geometrical aspects and microstructural evolution are correlated.