Coronary artery vasospasm is the sudden narrowing of an artery caused by rapid prolonged contraction. It reduces blood supply to the heart and can present with typical cardiac chest pain symptoms. Vasospasm can lead to fatal arrhythmic complications such as ventricular fibrillation. Our case report describes an example of this occurring in a 53-year-old female, and the management plan that ensued. We look at the importance of accurate and prompt diagnosis of vasospasm and how this can have implications for treatment options. One of the available treatments for vasospasm is placement of an implantable cardioverter defibrillator (ICD). This delivers a shock in the event of future life-threatening arrhythmia, with the aim of preventing cardiac arrest. ICD placement, however, is not always a suitable option. This case report discusses the various challenges that arose while making the decision for ICD placement and gives insight into the best available treatment options for coronary artery vasospasm. We also highlight early warning signs that predict life-threatening vasospastic events and how this can be diagnosed and treated appropriately.