We report a case involving a 31-year-old male without any known precipitating injuries presenting with involuntary finger movements and rare seizures. There was a noted family history of tremulous movements. Yet the characteristics of his finger movements were irregular and not typical of essential tremor (ET). Electrophysiological examinations, including video EEG, showed no epileptic discharges, and brain MRI results were normal. However, somatosensory evoked potentials (SEP) revealed the presence of giant SEP, and a positive cortical (C)-reflex was observed, leading to a clinical diagnosis of benign adult familial myoclonus epilepsy (BAFME). Management with valproic acid and perampanel resulted in a significant reduction of symptoms. This case highlights the necessity of considering BAFME in the differential diagnosis for atypical tremorous finger movements, especially with a relevant family history, and the critical role of electrophysiological findings indicative of cortical hyperexcitability.