The dentate gyrus is hypothesized to function as a “gate,” limiting the flow of excitation through the hippocampus. During epileptogenesis, adult-generated granule cells (DGCs) form aberrant neuronal connections with neighboring DGCs, disrupting the dentate gate. Hyperactivation of the mTOR signaling pathway is implicated in driving this aberrant circuit formation. While the presence of abnormal DGCs in epilepsy has been known for decades, direct evidence linking abnormal DGCs to seizures has been lacking. Here, we isolate the effects of abnormal DGCs using a transgenic mouse model to selectively delete PTEN from postnatally generated DGCs. PTEN deletion led to hyperactivation of the mTOR pathway, producing abnormal DGCs morphologically similar to those in epilepsy. Strikingly, animals in which PTEN was deleted from ≥9% of the DGC population developed spontaneous seizures in about 4 weeks, confirming that abnormal DGCs, which are present in both animals and humans with epilepsy, are capable of causing the disease. ► Direct evidence that selective disruption of the dentate gyrus causes epilepsy ► PTEN deletion from as few as 9% of granule cells is sufficient to cause epilepsy ► Findings suggest a plausible mechanism of epileptogenesis Abnormal hippocampal granule cells are hypothesized to be critical for temporal lobe epileptogenesis, but direct supporting evidence has been limited. Here, Pun and colleagues demonstrate that selective disruption of granule cells by PTEN deletion is sufficient to cause the disease.