After decades of setbacks, gene therapy (GT) is experiencing major breakthroughs. Five GTs have received US regulatory approval since 2017, and over 900 others are currently in development. Many of ...these GTs target rare pediatric diseases that are severely life-limiting, given a lack of effective treatments. As these GTs enter early-phase clinical trials, specific ethical challenges remain unresolved in three domains: evaluating risks and potential benefits, selecting participants fairly, and engaging with patient communities. Drawing on our experience as clinical investigators, basic scientists, and bioethicists involved in a first-in-human GT trial for an ultrarare pediatric disease, we analyze these ethical challenges and offer points to consider for future GT trials.
Giant axonal neuropathy (GAN) is an ultra-rare autosomal recessive, progressive neurodegenerative disease with early childhood onset that presents as a prominent sensorimotor neuropathy and commonly ...progresses to affect both the PNS and CNS. The disease is caused by biallelic mutations in the GAN gene located on 16q23.2, leading to loss of functional gigaxonin, a substrate specific ubiquitin ligase adapter protein necessary for the regulation of intermediate filament turnover. Here, we report on cross-sectional data from the first study visit of a prospectively collected natural history study of 45 individuals, age range 3-21 years with genetically confirmed GAN to describe and cross-correlate baseline clinical and functional cohort characteristics. We review causative variants distributed throughout the GAN gene in this cohort and identify a recurrent founder mutation in individuals with GAN of Mexican descent as well as cases of recurrent uniparental isodisomy. Through cross-correlational analysis of measures of strength, motor function and electrophysiological markers of disease severity, we identified the Motor Function Measure 32 to have the strongest correlation across measures and age in individuals with GAN. We analysed the Motor Function Measure 32 scores as they correspond to age and ambulatory status. Importantly, we identified and characterized a subcohort of individuals with a milder form of GAN and with a presentation similar to Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease. Such a clinical presentation is distinct from the classic presentation of GAN, and we demonstrate how the two groups diverge in performance on the Motor Function Measure 32 and other functional motor scales. We further present data on the first systematic clinical analysis of autonomic impairment in GAN as performed on a subset of the natural history cohort. Our cohort of individuals with genetically confirmed GAN is the largest reported to date and highlights the clinical heterogeneity and the unique phenotypic and functional characteristics of GAN in relation to disease state. The present work is designed to serve as a foundation for a prospective natural history study and functions in concert with the ongoing gene therapy trial for children with GAN.
OBJECTIVETo identify the rate of change of clinical outcome measures in children with 2 types of congenital muscular dystrophy (CMD), COL6-related dystrophies (COL6-RDs) and LAMA2-related dystrophies ...(LAMA2-RDs).
METHODSOver the course of 4 years, 47 individuals (23 with COL6-RD and 24 with LAMA2-RD) 4 to 22 years of age were evaluated. Assessments included the Motor Function Measure 32 (MFM32), myometry (knee flexors and extensors, elbow flexors and extensors), goniometry (knee and elbow extension), pulmonary function tests, and quality-of-life measures. Separate linear mixed-effects models were fitted for each outcome measurement, with subject-specific random intercepts.
RESULTSTotal MFM32 scores for COL6-RDs and LAMA2-RDs decreased at a rate of 4.01 and 2.60 points, respectively, each year (p < 0.01). All muscle groups except elbow flexors for individuals with COL6-RDs decreased in strength between 1.70% (p < 0.05) and 2.55% (p < 0.01). Range-of-motion measurements decreased by 3.21° (p < 0.05) at the left elbow each year in individuals with LAMA2-RDs and 2.35° (p < 0.01) in right knee extension each year in individuals with COL6-RDs. Pulmonary function demonstrated a yearly decline in sitting forced vital capacity percent predicted of 3.03% (p < 0.01) in individuals with COL6-RDs. There was no significant change in quality-of-life measures analyzed.
CONCLUSIONResults of this study describe the rate of change of motor function as measured by the MFM32, muscle strength, range of motion, and pulmonary function in individuals with COL6-RDs and LAMA2-RDs.
Omigapil is a small molecule which inhibits the GAPDH-Siah1-mediated apoptosis pathway. Apoptosis is a pathomechanism underlying the congenital muscular dystrophy subtypes LAMA2-related dystrophy ...(LAMA2-RD) and COL6-related dystrophy (COL6-RD). Studies of omigapil in the (dyw/dyw) LAMA2-RD mouse model demonstrated improved survival, and studies in the (dy2J/dy2J) LAMA2-RD mouse model and the (Col6a1-/-) COL6-RD mouse model demonstrated decreased apoptosis.Background and ObjectivesOmigapil is a small molecule which inhibits the GAPDH-Siah1-mediated apoptosis pathway. Apoptosis is a pathomechanism underlying the congenital muscular dystrophy subtypes LAMA2-related dystrophy (LAMA2-RD) and COL6-related dystrophy (COL6-RD). Studies of omigapil in the (dyw/dyw) LAMA2-RD mouse model demonstrated improved survival, and studies in the (dy2J/dy2J) LAMA2-RD mouse model and the (Col6a1-/-) COL6-RD mouse model demonstrated decreased apoptosis.A phase 1 open-label, sequential group, ascending oral dose, cohort study of omigapil in patients with LAMA2-RD or COL6-RD ages 5-16 years was performed (1) to establish the pharmacokinetic (PK) profile of omigapil at a range of doses, (2) to evaluate the safety and tolerability of omigapil at a range of doses, and (3) to establish the feasibility of conducting disease-relevant clinical assessments. Patients were enrolled in cohorts of size 4, with each patient receiving 4 weeks of vehicle run-in and 12 weeks of study drug (at daily doses ranging from 0.02 to 0.08 mg/kg). PK data from each cohort were analyzed before each subsequent dosing cohort was enrolled. A novel, adaptive dose-finding method (stochastic approximation with virtual observation recursion) was used to allow for dose escalation/reduction between cohorts based on PK data.MethodsA phase 1 open-label, sequential group, ascending oral dose, cohort study of omigapil in patients with LAMA2-RD or COL6-RD ages 5-16 years was performed (1) to establish the pharmacokinetic (PK) profile of omigapil at a range of doses, (2) to evaluate the safety and tolerability of omigapil at a range of doses, and (3) to establish the feasibility of conducting disease-relevant clinical assessments. Patients were enrolled in cohorts of size 4, with each patient receiving 4 weeks of vehicle run-in and 12 weeks of study drug (at daily doses ranging from 0.02 to 0.08 mg/kg). PK data from each cohort were analyzed before each subsequent dosing cohort was enrolled. A novel, adaptive dose-finding method (stochastic approximation with virtual observation recursion) was used to allow for dose escalation/reduction between cohorts based on PK data.Twenty patients were enrolled at the NIH (LAMA2-RD: N = 10; COL6-RD: N = 10). Slightly greater than dose-proportional increases in systemic exposure to omigapil were seen at doses 0.02-0.08 mg/kg/d. The dose which achieved patient exposure within the pre-established target area under the plasma concentration-vs-time curve (AUC0-24h) range was 0.06 mg/kg/d. In general, omigapil was safe and well tolerated. No consistent changes were seen in the disease-relevant clinical assessments during the duration of the study.ResultsTwenty patients were enrolled at the NIH (LAMA2-RD: N = 10; COL6-RD: N = 10). Slightly greater than dose-proportional increases in systemic exposure to omigapil were seen at doses 0.02-0.08 mg/kg/d. The dose which achieved patient exposure within the pre-established target area under the plasma concentration-vs-time curve (AUC0-24h) range was 0.06 mg/kg/d. In general, omigapil was safe and well tolerated. No consistent changes were seen in the disease-relevant clinical assessments during the duration of the study.This study represents the thus far only clinical trial of a therapeutic small molecule for LAMA2-RD and COL6-RD, completed with an adaptive trial design to arrive at dose adjustments. The trial met its primary end point and established that the PK profile of omigapil is suitable for further development in pediatric patients with LAMA2-RD or COL6-RD, the most common forms of congenital muscular dystrophy. While within the short duration of the study disease-relevant clinical assessments did not demonstrate significant changes, this study establishes the feasibility of performing interventional clinical trials in these rare disease patient populations.DiscussionThis study represents the thus far only clinical trial of a therapeutic small molecule for LAMA2-RD and COL6-RD, completed with an adaptive trial design to arrive at dose adjustments. The trial met its primary end point and established that the PK profile of omigapil is suitable for further development in pediatric patients with LAMA2-RD or COL6-RD, the most common forms of congenital muscular dystrophy. While within the short duration of the study disease-relevant clinical assessments did not demonstrate significant changes, this study establishes the feasibility of performing interventional clinical trials in these rare disease patient populations.This study provides Class IV evidence of omigapil in a dose-finding phase 1 study.Classification of EvidenceThis study provides Class IV evidence of omigapil in a dose-finding phase 1 study.Clinical Trials NCT01805024.Trial Registration InformationClinical Trials NCT01805024.
Giant axonal neuropathy (GAN) is a rare autosomal recessive neurodegenerative disorder caused by mutations in the GAN gene, which encodes for gigaxonin, a protein involved in intermediate filament ...processing in neural cells and fibroblasts. We report on 14 GAN patients who underwent 77 anesthetics during the conduct of an intrathecal gene transfer clinical trial from April 2015 to August 2020. We observed only a few nonsignificant perianesthetic complications. Our data expand the knowledge regarding safety of anesthesia for patients with this rare and potentially fatal disease and highlights the tolerability of shorter procedural sedation and anesthesia.
Orphan drug designation (ODD) is an important program intended to facilitate the development of orphan drugs in the United States. An orphan drug benefiting pediatric patients can qualify as a drug ...for a Rare Pediatric Disease Designation (RPDD) as well. The ODD and RPDD programs provide financial incentives for development of diagnostic drugs, preventive measures, and treatment of diseases affecting small patient populations (adult and pediatric) for which commercial development would otherwise be very challenging. In 2019, a multidisciplinary group of collaborators at National Institutes of Health (NIH) embarked upon a gene therapy platform program called Platform Vector Gene Therapy (PaVe-GT) intended to develop gene therapies for four such rare disorders. An important part of PaVe-GT is to publicly share scientific and regulatory experience gained at different stages during the implementation of the PaVe-GT platform utilizing illustrative examples. The PaVe-GT team recently obtained ODD and RPDD for an adeno-associated virus gene therapy to treat propionic acidemia. Given an increasing interest in obtaining ODD for gene therapy, especially by small companies, research investigators, and patient groups, we overview the submission process and subsequently provide examples of our ODD and RPDD applications. Our ODD and RPDD applications and templates can also be found on the PaVe-GT website. Shared reference documents will have great utility to assist parties who may have limited experience with the preparation of similar applications for their orphan product.
PDF
