Prenatal detection of critical congenital heart disease (CCHD) optimises perinatal decision-making and neonatal outcomes. The objective of this study was to determine the prenatal screening ...performance, care pathways and perinatal outcomes for prenatally and postnatally diagnosed cases of CCHD over a four-year period.
This retrospective cohort study in a tertiary centre and its two affiliated secondary sites examined all cases of CCHD, including cases of pregnancy termination and in-utero fetal death, neonatal death and liveborn babies that underwent cardiac catheterization or surgery in the first six weeks of life. Prenatal and postnatal data were ascertained from the first trimester assessment for all patients diagnosed prenatally. Cases requiring intervention that were first identified in the postnatal period were included to determine prenatal detection rates. Follow-up for all cases of CCHD continued to one year of age.
In a consecutive cohort of 49,950 pregnancies in a 4-year period 01/2019 to 12/2022, a prenatal diagnosis of CCHD was made in 96 cases, yielding a prevalence of 1.9 per 1000 births. The prenatal detection for right duct-dependant heart pathology and congenital heart block was 100%, 85% for left duct-dependant pathology and 93% for transposition of the great arteries (TGA). In the prenatally diagnosed group, 37% of cases were complicated by extracardiac structural abnormalities, a genetic diagnosis or both. All cases of prenatal detection were identified in the context of routine anatomy screening rather than specialist Fetal Cardiac screening services. Almost half of all pregnancies complicated by CCHD did not undergo neonatal cardiac intervention, by virtue of parental choice determined either prenatally or after birth. An additional eight babies were diagnosed with CCHD in the neonatal period, such that the prenatal detection rate for CCHD was 92% (96/104, 95% CI = 84%-96%). Survival at 1-year for infants deemed suitable for CCHD surgery was 85%.
In a large unselected population, optimal rates of prenatal detection of critical congenital heart disease can be achieved by a protocolised approach to mid-trimester fetal anatomy ultrasound, underpinned by a programme of sonographer education and training. The cardiac abnormalities most likely to evade prenatal detection are left-sided obstructive lesions.
The RECIPE study aims to validate a risk prediction model for intrapartum caesarean delivery which has been developed by our group. The Genesis study was a prospective observational study carried out ...by the Perinatal Ireland Research Consortium across 7 clinical centres in Ireland between October 2012 and June 2015. Genesis investigated a range of maternal and fetal parameters in a prospective blinded study of 2336 singleton pregnancies between 39 + 0-41 + 0 weeks' gestational age. This resulted in the development of a risk prediction model for Caesarean Delivery in nulliparous women at term. The RECIPE study now proposes to provide external validation of this risk prediction tool.
In order to externally validate the model, we aim to include a centre which was not involved in the original study. We propose a trial of risk-assignment for intrapartum caesarean amongst nulliparous women with a singleton pregnancy between 38 + 0 and 40 + 6 weeks' gestational age who are planning a vaginal birth. Results of the risk prediction tool will be concealed from participants and from midwives and doctors providing labour care.. Participants will be invited for an ultrasound scan and delivery details will be collated postnatally. The principal aim of this study is to externally validate the risk prediction model. This prediction model holds the potential to accurately identify nulliparous women who are likely to achieve an uncomplicated vaginal birth and those at high prospect of requiring an unplanned caesarean delivery.
Validation of the Genesis prediction model would enable more accurate counselling for women in the antenatal setting regarding their own likelihood of requiring an intrapartum Caesarean section. It would also provide valuable personalised information to women about the anticipated course of their own labour. We believe that this is an issue of national relevance that will impact positively on obstetric practice, and will positively empower women to make considered, personalised choices surrounding labour and delivery.
In contemporary practice many nulliparous women require intervention during childbirth such as operative vaginal delivery or cesarean delivery (CD). Despite the knowledge that the increasing rate of ...CD is associated with increasing maternal age, obesity and larger infant birthweight, we lack a reliable method to predict the requirement for such potentially hazardous obstetric procedures during labor and delivery. This issue is important, as there are greater rates of morbidity and mortality associated with unplanned CD performed in labor compared with scheduled CDs. A prediction algorithm to identify women at risk of an unplanned CD could help reduced labor associated morbidity.
In this primary analysis of the Genesis study, our objective was to prospectively assess the use of prenatally determined, maternal and fetal, anthropomorphic, clinical, and ultrasound features to develop a predictive tool for unplanned CD in the term nulliparous woman, before the onset of labor.
The Genesis study recruited 2336 nulliparous women with a vertex presentation between 39+0 and 40+6 weeks’ gestation in a prospective multicenter national study to examine predictors of CD. At recruitment, a detailed clinical evaluation and ultrasound assessment were performed. To reduce bias from knowledge of these data potentially influencing mode of delivery, women, midwives, and obstetricians were blinded to the ultrasound data. All hypothetical prenatal risk factors for unplanned CD were assessed as a composite. Multiple logistic regression analysis and mathematical modeling was used to develop a risk evaluation tool for CD in nulliparous women. Continuous predictors were standardized using z scores.
From a total enrolled cohort of 2336 nulliparous participants, 491 (21%) had an unplanned CD. Five parameters were determined to be the best combined predictors of CD. These were advancing maternal age (odds ratio OR, 1.21; 95% confidence interval CI, 1.09 to 1.34), shorter maternal height (OR, 1.72; 95% CI, 1.52 to 1.93), increasing body mass index (OR, 1.29; 95% CI, 1.17 to 1.43), larger fetal abdominal circumference (OR, 1.23; 95% CI, 1.1 to 1.38), and larger fetal head circumference (OR, 1.27; 95% CI, 1.14 to 1.42). A nomogram was developed to provide an individualized risk assessment to predict CD in clinical practice, with excellent calibration and discriminative ability (Kolmogorov–Smirnov, D statistic, 0.29; 95% CI, 0.28 to 0.30) with a misclassification rate of 0.21 (95% CI, 0.19 to 0.25).
Five parameters (maternal age, body mass index, height, fetal abdominal circumference, and fetal head circumference) can, in combination, be used to better determine the overall risk of CD in nulliparous women at term. A risk score can be used to inform women of their individualized probability of CD. This risk tool may be useful for reassuring most women regarding their likely success at achieving an uncomplicated vaginal delivery as well as selecting those patients with such a high risk for CD that they should avoid a trial of labor. Such a risk tool has the potential to greatly improve planning hospital service needs and minimizing patient risk.
Objective
To describe the growth dynamics of fetuses with initial fetal growth restriction (FGR) later outgrowing the 10th centile for estimated fetal weight with respect to perinatal outcomes and ...maternal factors.
Methods
A multicenter prospective study recruited 1116 patients for ultrasound surveillance between 2010 and 2012. All pregnancies were growth‐restricted singleton gestations between 24 + 0 and 36 + 0 weeks. Biometry and Doppler analysis were carried out, and delivery and adverse perinatal outcomes were recorded.
Results
A total of 193 (17%) fetuses outgrew their diagnosis of initial FGR (surpassed the 10th centile) on their last sonogram before delivery. These fetuses were termed “growers,” to compare with the true FGR group. The mothers of “growers” were less likely to be smokers (14% vs 25%, P = 0.0001) or affected by hypertensive pregnancy complications (5.2% vs 15%, P = 0.001). Of the growers, 49 (25%) had an abnormal umbilical artery Doppler; however, in most cases (33/49, 67%), this was a single episode of raised umbilical artery pulsatility index, which subsequently normalized.
Conclusion
There were dynamic growth changes in FGR fetuses, with 17% outgrowing their original diagnosis. Positive growth spurts more commonly occurred in healthy mothers. Once a fetus had outgrown the 10th centile, antenatal surveillance could be decreased.
Synopsis
There are dynamic growth changes in fetuses with growth restriction, with recovery from growth restriction occurring most commonly in healthy mothers.
Fetal growth restriction is being defined as either "early" or "late" depending on age of onset. A recent investigation using individualized assessment has identified five different growth ...restriction patterns. No previous study has related these patterns to cardiovascular abnormalities.
To determine growth patterns in small fetuses (BW < 10th percentile) using Individualized Growth Assessment (IGA) and to relate cardiovascular abnormalities found with Doppler ultrasound to these patterns.
A secondary analysis was carried out in 126 fetuses from the PORTO data set having both estimated weights and birth weights below the 10th percentile. Only fetuses with 2nd and 3rd trimester biometry scans appropriate for IGA and cardiovascular assessments were studied. There was one-to-one matching of biometry and Doppler evaluations in the 3rd trimester. Composite growth parameters were used to quantify growth pathology at individual time points (individual composite Prenatal Growth Assessment Score (icPGAS)) and during the 3rd trimester (Fetal Growth Pathology Score {FGPS1}). Normal and growth restriction patterns were identified using plots of FGPS1 values. Doppler measurements were classified as normal or abnormal based on published cross-sectional standards. Outcome variables were birth weight and birth age.
In these SGA cases, 38.2% showed normal fetal growth and 61.8% had growth restriction. In the latter, seven different patterns were observed. Pattern 1 was most common (43.5%), followed by Patterns 5 (16.7%), 2 (15.4%) and 3 (14.1%). The characteristics of Pattern 1 indicated progressive growth restriction while Pattern 5 demonstrated recovery from an initial growth abnormality. Cardiovascular abnormalities were quite variable, with those in the umbilical artery being most frequent in Patterns 1 and 3. Pattern 2 had the highest incidence of middle cerebral artery abnormalities. Umbilical artery abnormalities were similar in the Normal and Pattern 5 groups as were those for the middle cerebral artery. Other cardiovascular abnormalities had low frequencies except in Pattern 2 where the ductus venosus incidence was high. Abnormally small neonates, as identified with IGA, were seen primarily in Patterns 1, 3 and 6 (80-88%). Premature deliveries occurred most frequently in Pattern 1 (56%), followed by Pattern 2 (33%).
Growth in this SGA Group was very heterogeneous with a significant proportion of these small fetuses growing normally. Growth restriction did not appear to be a single process but was manifest as seven different FGPS1 patterns. Both growth pathology and cardiovascular abnormalities differed among patterns. Further investigation will be required to determine how specific growth abnormalities are related to fetal cardiovascular changes over time.
To characterize abnormal growth processes and their associated cardiovascular abnormalities in SGA fetuses using Individualized Growth Assessment (IGA).
This longitudinal investigation utilized a SGA ...cohort EFW and BW <10th percentile derived from the PORTO study. Fetuses categorized by their Fetal Growth Pathology Score FGPS1 patterns Pattern 2 {n = 12}, Pattern 3 {n = 11}, Pattern 5 {n = 13} were evaluated. Growth pathology was measured using the -FGPS1 and the individual composite Prenatal Growth Assessment Score {-icPGAS. Paired cardiovascular assessments utilized measurements of the Pulsatility Index umbilical artery {UA}, middle cerebral artery {MCA}, ductus venosus {DV} and the myocardial performance index MPI; heart. Outcome variables were birth age preterm or, term and birth weight small or normal (IGA criteria).
Pattern 2 was usually characterized by a single, growth abnormality (67% of cases) of variable magnitude that occurred within two weeks of delivery {median onset age: 37.6 weeks}. The incidence of UA abnormalities was low (25%) while those of MCA and DV/MPI were high {60%, 42%}. Most neonates were of normal size (67%) and delivered at term (67%).
Pattern 3 had an initial progressive growth restriction phase, followed by constant but abnormally low growth. Growth pathology had an early onset (median age: 31.6 weeks), was moderate but persistently abnormal. The incidences of cardiovascular abnormalities were moderate 30-50%. Most neonates were abnormally small (80%) but delivered at term (90%).
Pattern 5 had an initial progressive phase with an early onset onset age {median}: 31.6 weeks. However, this process was arrested and returned toward normal. Growth pathology magnitudes were minor as were the incidences of cardiovascular abnormalities. Neonatal size was usually normal and all fetuses delivered at term.
Characteristics of SGA Growth Restricted, Patterns 2, 3 and 5 are clearly different from those found in SGA Normal or SGA Growth Restricted Pattern 1 groups. They also differed from one another, indicating that growth restriction can manifest itself in several different ways. Pattern 2 is similar to "late" growth restriction reported previously. Patterns 3 and 5 are novel and have been designated as "adaptive" and "recovering" types of growth restriction.
To characterize growth processes and their associated cardiovascular abnormalities in SGA fetuses with normal growth and progressive growth restriction patterns as defined by Individualized Growth ...Assessment (IGA).
A SGA cohort (EFW and BW < 10th percentile) was derived from the PORTO study that included 47 fetuses with normal growth outcome (SGA Normal) and 34 fetuses with progressive growth restriction (SGA Growth Restricted, Pattern 1). Composite fetal size parameters were used to quantify growth pathology at individual third trimester time points (individual composite Prenatal Growth Assessment Score {icPGAS}) and calculated cumulatively during the third trimester (Fetal Growth Pathology Score 1{FGPS1}). Paired Doppler evaluations of the umbilical artery (UA), middle cerebral artery (MCA), ductus venosus (DV) and myocardial performance index (MPI) were used to detect cardiovascular anomalies. Outcome variables were birth age and birth weight.
Ranking fetuses with respect to the severity of the 3rd trimester growth pathology (-FGPS1) revealed three subgroups in each of these two groups. In SGA Normal, no (51%), minimal (19%) or minor (30%) growth abnormalities were present. Although vascular flow abnormalities occurred without growth abnormalities (UA: 38%; MCA: 35%), they increased with minor growth disturbances (UA: 64%; MCA: 50%). All fetuses delivered at term and in only 7 cases (minor growth abnormalities subgroup) were the neonates abnormally small based on IGA criteria. In SGA Growth Restricted, Pattern 1, the progression of growth restriction was slow (47%), moderate (21%) and rapid (32%). Corresponding median -FGPS1 values were −1.34%, −2.67% and −4.88%, respectively. The median age of onset was 33.6, 29.7 and 29.7 weeks in these three subgroups. UA abnormalities occurred infrequently in the first two subgroups but were found in all cases of rapidly progressing pathology. Similar results were found for the MCA and DV + MPI Doppler parameters (rapid progression: MCA = 50%; DV + MPI = 50%). Premature delivery occurred less frequently with slow progression but was nearly 100% in the moderately and rapidly progressive subgroups.
Negative FGPS1 growth restriction patterns can be used to classify SGA fetuses. Subgroups, based on ranked -FGPS1 values in both SGA Normal and SGA Growth Restricted Pattern 1 groups had marked differences in cardiovascular abnormalities and neonatal outcomes. The characteristics of these two groups are consistent with small, normally growing fetuses and fetuses with "early" growth restriction, respectively.