Objective
Bilateral superior canal dehiscence (SCD) may warrant surgeries on both sides. With repairs of unilateral SCD as reference, we investigate the comparative effectiveness of first‐side and ...second‐side repairs, in hopes of establishing knowledge that can guide clinical decision‐making pertaining the appropriateness of second‐side surgeries.
Methods
Middle fossa SCD repairs at an institution between 2011 and 2022 were analyzed. Multivariable regression models assessed symptom resolution and audiometric improvement with surgery cohort (unilateral SCD repair vs. first‐side repair vs. second‐side repair) as the primary predictor. All models controlled for patient age, sex, surgery duration, prior ear surgery, and follow‐up.
Results
A total of 407 repairs (180 unilateral SCD, 172 first‐side, and 55 second‐side repairs) were analyzed. The rates of overall symptom improvement for auditory and vestibular symptoms were as follows: 81% and 67% for unilateral SCD repairs; 73% and 54% for first‐side repairs; and 43% and 51% for second‐side repairs, respectively. Compared with first‐side repairs, which resolved auditory symptoms at similar rates (aOR 95% C.I. 0.36–1.07) but resolved vestibular symptoms at significantly lower rates (aOR 95% C.I. 0.35–0.93) compared with unilateral SCD repairs, second‐side repairs resolved auditory symptoms at significantly lower rates (aOR 95% C.I. 0.10–0.51) but resolved vestibular symptoms at similar rates (aOR 95% C.I. 0.45–2.01).
Conclusions
Careful consideration of perioperative symptomatology may inform the appropriateness of second‐side surgeries. If auditory symptoms persisted following first‐side surgeries, second‐side surgeries are less likely to yield resolution. If vestibular symptoms persisted following first‐side repairs, second‐side repairs may lead to resolution at similar rates as first‐side repairs.
Level of Evidence
3 Laryngoscope, 134:1882–1888, 2024
Following first‐side repairs, careful consideration of perioperative symptomatology may inform the appropriateness of a second‐side repair. If auditory symptoms persisted following first‐side surgeries, second‐side surgeries are less likely to yield resolution. If vestibular symptoms persisted following first‐side repairs, second‐side repairs may lead to resolution at similar rates as first‐side repairs.
Objective
To investigate the independent and interactive effects of patient age and sex on superior canal dehiscence (SCD) repair outcomes.
Methods
This was a cohort study of consecutive SCD repairs ...via the middle fossa approach at an institution between 2011 and 2022. We constructed multivariable regression models assessing surgical outcomes with age and sex as the primary predictors. Models controlled for surgery duration, follow‐up duration, and relevant surgical and medical history. Subsequently, we repeated each model with the incorporation of an interaction term between patient age and sex.
Results
Among 402 repairs, average age was 50 years, and 63% of cases were females. There was a significant interaction between patient age and sex with respect to symptom resolution score (SRS) (adj. β 0.80, 95% C.I. 0.04–1.56). Older age was associated with lower SRS among females (−0.84, −1.29 to −0.39 point per year) but not significantly associated with SRS among males (0.04, −0.65 to 0.56 point per year). Furthermore, older age independently predicted a greater magnitude of increase in air conduction at 8000 Hz following surgery regardless of sex (adj. β 2.1, 0.2–4.0 dB per 10‐year increase).
Conclusions
This is the first study on the interactive effect between patient age and sex with respect to SCD repair outcomes. Older age predicted poorer symptomatic response among female patients but did not predict symptomatic response among male patients. Furthermore, older age predicted more severe high‐frequency hearing loss following SCD repairs among both female and male patients.
Level of Evidence
3 Laryngoscope, 134:3363–3370, 2024
In this cohort study of 402 SCD repairs, older age predicted poorer symptomatic response among females but not did not predict symptomatic response among males. Older age predicted more severe high‐frequency hearing loss following surgery regardless of sex.
Low-frequency air-bone gap (LABG) on pure tone audiometry is an expected clinical finding of superior canal dehiscence (SCD) syndrome. We investigate how narrowing of LABG following SCD repairs ...translates to symptom resolution.
Cohort study.
Tertiary Care Center.
We analyzed consecutive SCD repairs at an institution between 2012 and 2022. Pure tone audiometry and symptom questionnaires were administered pre- and post-operatively. The independent variable assessed whether the LABG narrowed (≥5 dB) following surgery. Outcome measures were rates of Overall Symptom Improvement (OSI, net resolution of ≥1 symptom) and Symptom Resolution Score (SRS, % symptoms resolved). We conducted multivariable regression analyses with LABG narrowing as the primary predictor. All models controlled for demographics, bilateral disease, prior ear surgery, and follow-up.
Among total of 217 repairs analyzed, 161 (74%) reached OSI, and mean SRS was 39 (out of 100). LABG narrowing at 250 Hz (65%), 500 Hz (52%), and 1000 Hz (47%) was associated with a 41-point (β 95% confidence interval CI 5-77) increase in auditory, 15-point (β 95% CI 1-30) increase in auditory, and 23-point (β 95% CI 2-45) increase in vestibular SRS, respectively. However, LABG narrowing was not significantly associated with the rates of auditory and vestibular OSI at all frequencies assessed.
Lack of LABG narrowing following repair was associated with the persistence of a greater proportion of preoperative symptoms but similar likelihood of OSI. This relationship was more prominent for auditory symptoms at 250 to 500 Hz and for vestibular symptoms at 1000 Hz. Additional research is warranted to elucidate the mechanism through which symptoms resolve despite LABG persistence.
•Larger dehiscences exhibit wider low-frequency air-bone gap.•Larger dehiscences more frequently present with autophony and amplification.•Dehiscence size appears to associate with severity of ...bone-conduction hyperacusis.•Dehiscence location was not associated with clinical presentation.
This study investigates the relationship of superior semicircular canal dehiscence (SSCD) size and location with patient symptomatology and audiometry.
We retrospectively reviewed SSCD cases presented to a tertiary institution between 2011 and 2022. Dehiscence length and width measured on high-resolution temporal bone computed tomography imaging were used to calculate an approximate dehiscence area (ADA). Dehiscence location was classified employing a six-grade system. Multivariable regression analyses were performed with symptomatology and audiogram metrics as outcome variables and ADA and dehiscence location as the primary covariates of interest.
A total of 402 SSCD were included in the analysis. Controlling for patient age, sex, dehiscence laterality, and location, greater ADA was independently associated higher rates of autophony (aOR 1.39; 95% C.I. 1.14–1.71; P = 0.004) and hyper-amplification (aOR 1.39; 1.14–1.70; P = 0.004). Additionally, dehiscences with greater ADA exhibited significantly lower bone conduction threshold at 500 Hz (adjusted β –1.75, P = 0.006) and 1000 Hz (adjusted β –1.61, P = 0.018) and significantly wider air-bone gap at 500 Hz (adjusted β 2.22, P < 0.001) and 1000 Hz (adjusted β 1.00, P = 0.039). Dehiscence location was not independently associated with any outcome variable examined when accounting for dehiscence size.
The size of dehiscence is more independently related to clinical presentations than the anatomical location of the dehiscence in the superior semicircular canal. Greater dehiscence size is associated with symptomatology and audiometry consistent with more severe bone conduction hyperacusis.
To compare treatment response from the middle cranial fossa repair of superior canal dehiscence (SCD) between cases with and cases without low-lying tegmen (LLT).
Cohort study.
Single tertiary care ...institution.
Two investigators independently reviewed preoperative high-resolution temporal bone computed tomography images and classified the ipsilateral tegmen as either "low-lying" or "control." Patients completed a symptom questionnaire and underwent audiometric testing pre- and post-operatively. Multivariable regression models assessed for symptomatic resolution and audiometric improvement following surgery with tegmen status as the primary predictor. Models controlled for patient age, sex, bilateral SCD disease, dehiscence location, prior ear surgery status, surgery duration, and follow-up duration.
Among a total of 410 cases included, we identified 121 (29.5%) LLT cases. Accounting for all control measures, patients with LLT were significantly less likely to experience overall symptom improvement (adjusted odds ratio: 0.32, 95% confidence interval CI: 0.18-0.57, p < .001) and reported a significantly lower proportion of preoperative symptoms that resolved following surgery (adjusted β: -25.6%, 95% CI: -37.0% to -14.3%, p < .001). However, audiometric outcomes following surgery did not differ significantly between patients with and patients without LLT.
This is the first investigation on the relationship between LLT and surgical outcomes following the middle fossa repair of SCD. Patients with LLT reported less favorable symptomatic response but exhibited a similar degree of audiometric improvement.
Objective
The present study investigates risk factors and clinical outcomes of postoperative pneumolabyrinth following the middle cranial fossa approach for superior semicircular canal dehiscence ...repair, a complication that has not been documented previously.
Study Design
Retrospective cohort study.
Setting
Tertiary/quaternary care referral center.
Methods
We conducted a retrospective review of 332 middle cranial fossa procedures from 2014 to 2020 at a tertiary/quaternary care institution. Upon identifying pneumolabyrinth cases from postoperative computed tomography temporal bone scans, we conducted multivariable logistic regression analysis to explore demographic and clinical factors that were independently linked to this complication. We also compared the rates of postoperative symptoms among patients with different grades of pneumolabyrinth.
Results
We identified 41 (12.3%) pneumolabyrinth cases. Patients with older age, higher preoperative pure tone average, and frank dehiscence were at higher risk for pneumolabyrinth. Furthermore, patients with pneumolabyrinth reported significantly higher rates of postoperative dizziness and exhibited significantly greater pure tone average and air‐bone gap postoperatively as compared with patients without pneumolabyrinth. Finally, higher‐grade pneumolabyrinth was associated with increased rates of postoperative hearing loss, and grade III pneumolabyrinth was associated with higher rates of postoperative tinnitus vs grade I and II cases.
Conclusion
Pneumolabyrinth following the middle cranial fossa approach was associated with poor clinical outcomes, including dizziness and auditory impairment. Old age, high preoperative pure tone average, and frank dehiscence were risk factors for this complication. The highlighted parameters may be important to note when considering this approach as a treatment option and while monitoring postoperative recovery.
Objective
Superior semicircular canal dehiscence (SSCD) causing conductive hearing loss with present reflexes is a known reason for stapes surgery failure. However, concomitant SSCD and otosclerosis ...occur rarely. We present a case series of SSCD diagnosed in positively identified otosclerosis patients.
Methods
Retrospective review of clinical case series in two tertiary‐referral neurotologic practices was performed. Clinical histories, operative findings, audiograms, and computed tomography (CT) images were reviewed for patients diagnosed with both SSCD and otosclerosis. Patients with present stapedial reflexes were excluded. Comprehensive literature review was performed.
Results
Four cases were identified. Three reported improved hearing with partial or complete closure of the air‐bone gap (ABG), including one patient with far‐advanced otosclerosis. One patient had no improvement in pure tone average or ABG. One patient reported worsening of preoperative autophony and pulsatile tinnitus, but none developed new postoperative third‐window symptoms. CTs demonstrated both SSCD and otosclerosis.
Conclusion
Failure to close the ABG in patients with positively identified otosclerosis intraoperatively may be due to SSCD as an occult concomitant diagnosis. SSCD should be considered as a possible cause of persistent conductive hearing loss after stapes surgery.
Level of Evidence
4 Laryngoscope, 130:1023–1027, 2020
Objective:
This study aims to identify clinical predictors of treatment response to Eustachian Tube Balloon Dilation (ETBD) as measured by changes in Eustachian Tube Dysfunction Questionnaire-7 ...(ETDQ-7) scores.
Methods:
One hundred thirteen patients who underwent ETBD at an institution from 2017 to 2021 completed ETDQ-7 pre- and post-operatively. We conducted multivariable regression analyses with ETDQ-7 normalization (<2.1 post-op), minimum clinically important difference (MCID) (>0.5 pre-op – post-op), and quantitative improvement in ETDQ-7 score as outcome variables. Pre-operative ETDQ-7 score, tympanogram type, chronic otitis media, chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS), inferior turbinate hypertrophy, deviated septum, allergic rhinitis, and rhinorrhea were included as covariates. Models controlled for age, sex, ethnicity, prior ear or sinus surgery, and follow-up duration.
Results:
The mean age was 49 years old. 51% were females, and all patients had pre-operative ETDQ-7 above 2.1. After a mean follow-up period of 13 months, 77% achieved MCID and 37% had normalized. Higher pre-operative ETDQ-7 score was associated with greater ETDQ-7 score improvement (B = 0.60, 95% CI = 0.37, 0.83) and greater odds of achieving MCID (aOR = 1.65; 95% CI = 1.06, 2.59). A history of CRS improved chances of achieving MCID (aOR = 4.53; 95% CI = 1.11, 18.55) and a history of chronic otitis media predicted increased odds of ETDQ-7 normalization (aOR = 2.88; 95% CI = 1.09, 7.58).
Conclusions:
Our findings suggest that ETBD was highly effective among patients with pre-operative ETDQ-7 above 2.1. Furthermore, higher pre-operative ETDQ-7 score, CRS, and chronic otitis media predicted more favorable symptomatic benefit from ETBD. These factors may be important to consider when counseling potential candidates for this procedure.
Abstract
The objective of this study was to evaluate the characteristic symptoms of and treatments for lateral semicircular canal dehiscence (LSCD) and posterior semicircular canal dehiscence (PSCD) ...and its proposed mechanism. A dehiscence acquired in any of the semicircular canals may evoke various auditory symptoms (autophony and inner ear conductive hearing loss) or vestibular symptoms (vertigo, the Tullio phenomenon, and Hennebert sign) by creating a “third mobile window” in the bone that enables aberrant communication between the inner ear and nearby structures. A PubMed search was performed using the keywords
lateral, posterior,
and
semicircular canal dehiscence
to identify all relevant cases. Our data suggest that PSCD, although clinically rare, is most likely associated with a high-riding jugular bulb and fibrous dysplasia. Patients may experience auditory manifestations that range from mild conductive to extensive sensorineural hearing loss. LSCD is usually associated with chronic otitis media with cholesteatoma.
PDF
