About half of people with trisomy 21 have a congenital heart defect (CHD), whereas the remainder have a structurally normal heart, demonstrating that trisomy 21 is a significant risk factor but is ...not causal for abnormal heart development. Atrioventricular septal defects (AVSD) are the most commonly occurring heart defects in Down syndrome (DS), and ∼65% of all AVSD is associated with DS. We used a candidate-gene approach among individuals with DS and complete AVSD (cases = 141) and DS with no CHD (controls = 141) to determine whether rare genetic variants in genes involved in atrioventricular valvuloseptal morphogenesis contribute to AVSD in this sensitized population. We found a significant excess (p < 0.0001) of variants predicted to be deleterious in cases compared to controls. At the most stringent level of filtering, we found potentially damaging variants in nearly 20% of cases but fewer than 3% of controls. The variants with the highest probability of being damaging in cases only were found in six genes: COL6A1, COL6A2, CRELD1, FBLN2, FRZB, and GATA5. Several of the case-specific variants were recurrent in unrelated individuals, occurring in 10% of cases studied. No variants with an equal probability of being damaging were found in controls, demonstrating a highly specific association with AVSD. Of note, all of these genes are in the VEGF-A pathway, even though the candidate genes analyzed in this study represented numerous biochemical and developmental pathways, suggesting that rare variants in the VEGF-A pathway might contribute to the genetic underpinnings of AVSD in humans.
About half of people with Down syndrome (DS) exhibit some form of congenital heart disease (CHD); however, trisomy for human chromosome 21 (Hsa21) alone is insufficient to cause CHD, as half of all ...people with DS have a normal heart, suggesting that genetic modifiers interact with dosage-sensitive gene(s) on Hsa21 to result in CHD. We hypothesize that a threshold exists in both DS and euploid populations for the number of genetic perturbations that can be tolerated before CHD results.
We ascertained a group of individuals with DS and complete atrioventricular septal defect and sequenced 2 candidate genes for CHD: CRELD1, which is associated with atrioventricular septal defect in people with or without DS, and HEY2, whose mouse ortholog (Hey2) produces septal defects when mutated. Several deleterious variants were identified, but the frequency of these potential modifiers was low. We crossed mice with mutant forms of these potential modifiers to the Ts65Dn mouse model of DS. Crossing loss-of-function alleles of either Creld1 or Hey2 onto the trisomic background caused a significant increase in the frequency of CHD, demonstrating an interaction between the modifiers and trisomic genes. We showed further that, although each of these mutant modifiers is benign by itself, they interact to affect heart development when inherited together.
Using mouse models of Down syndrome and of genes associated with congenital heart disease, we demonstrate a biological basis for an interaction that supports a threshold hypothesis for additive effects of genetic modifiers in the sensitized trisomic population.
Down's syndrome (DS), resulting from an additional copy of chromosome 21 (trisomy 21), is frequently associated with congenital heart defects (CHDs). Although the increased dosage of chromosome 21 ...sequences is likely to be part of the etiology of cardiac defects, only a proportion of DS patients exhibit a congenital heart defect (birth prevalence 40-60%). Through a large-candidate gene-sequencing screen in patients with atrioventricular septal defects, substitutions were identified in bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) type I receptor ALK2 and two other genes in a patient with DS and a primum-type atrial septal defect. Structural modeling of the cytoplasmic domain of the ALK2 receptor suggests that H286 is in close proximity to the nucleotide-binding site of the kinase domain. We investigated whether this p.His286Asp substitution altered ALK2 function by using both in vitro as well as in vivo assays. The p.His286Asp variant demonstrated impaired functional activity as measured by BMP-specific transcriptional response assays. Furthermore, mild dominant-interfering activity was observed in vivo compared with wild-type ALK2 as determined by RNA injection into zebrafish embryos. These data indicate that in the context of a DS background, ALK2-mediated reduction of BMP signaling may contribute to CHDs.
Abstract
Atrioventricular septal defects (AVSD) are highly heritable, clinically significant congenital heart malformations. Genetic and environmental modifiers of risk are thought to work in unknown ...combinations to cause AVSD. Approximately 5–10% of simplex AVSD cases carry a missense mutation in
CRELD1
. However,
CRELD1
mutations are not fully penetrant and require interactions with other risk factors to result in AVSD. Vascular endothelial growth factor-A (VEGFA) is a well-characterized modulator of heart valve development. A functional
VEGFA
polymorphism,
VEGFA
c.−634C, which causes constitutively increased VEGFA expression, has been associated with cardiac septal defects suggesting it may be a genetic risk factor. To determine if there is an allelic association with AVSD we genotyped the
VEGFA
c.−634 SNP in a simplex AVSD study cohort. Over-representation of the c.−634C allele in the AVSD group suggested that this genotype may increase risk. Correlation of
CRELD1
and
VEGFA
genotypes revealed that potentially pathogenic missense mutations in
CRELD1
were always accompanied by the
VEGFA
c.−634C allele in individuals with AVSD suggesting a potentially pathogenic allelic interaction. We used a
Creld1
knockout mouse model to determine the effect of deficiency of Creld1 combined with increased VEGFA on atrioventricular canal development. Morphogenic response to VEGFA was abnormal in Creld1-deficient embryonic hearts, indicating that interaction between CRELD1 and VEGFA has the potential to alter atrioventricular canal morphogenesis. This supports our hypothesis that an additive effect between missense mutations in
CRELD1
and a functional SNP in
VEGFA
contributes to the pathogenesis of AVSD.
Down syndrome, resulting from an additional copy of chromosome 21 (trisomy 21), is frequently associated with congenital heart defects. Although increased dosage of chromosome 21 sequences are likely ...to be part of the etiology of cardiac defects, only a proportion of Down syndrome patients exhibit a congenital heart defect (birth prevalence 40-60%). Through a large candidate gene sequencing screen in patients with atrioventricular septal defects, substitution were identified in bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) type I receptor ALK2 and two other genes in a patient with Down syndrome and a primum type atrial septal defect. Structural modeling of the cytoplasmic domain of the ALK2 receptor suggests that H286 is in close proximity to the nucleotide binding site of the kinase domain. We investigated whether this p.His286Asp substitution altered ALK2 function by using both in vitro as well as in vivo assays. The p.His286Asp variant demonstrated impaired functional activity as measured by BMP-specific transcriptional response assays. Furthermore, mild dominant-interfering activity was observed in vivo compared with wild type ALK2 as determined by RNA injection into zebrafish embryos. These data indicate that in the context of a Down syndrome background, ALK2 mediated reduction of BMP signalling may contribute to congenital heart defects.
Atrioventricular septal defects (AVSD) are highly heritable, clinically significant congenital heart malformations. Genetic and environmental modifiers of risk are thought to work in unknown ...combinations to cause AVSD. Approximately 5-10% of simplex AVSD cases carry a missense mutation in CRELD1. However, CRELD1 mutations are not fully penetrant and require interactions with other risk factors to result in AVSD. Vascular endothelial growth factor-A (VEGFA) is a well-characterized modulator of heart valve development. A functional VEGFA polymorphism, VEGFA c.-634C, which causes constitutively increased VEGFA expression, has been associated with cardiac septal defects suggesting it may be a genetic risk factor. To determine if there is an allelic association with AVSD we genotyped the VEGFA c.-634 SNP in a simplex AVSD study cohort. Over-representation of the c.-634C allele in the AVSD group suggested that this genotype may increase risk. Correlation of CRELD1 and VEGFA genotypes revealed that potentially pathogenic missense mutations in CRELD1 were always accompanied by the VEGFA c.-634C allele in individuals with AVSD suggesting a potentially pathogenic allelic interaction. We used a Creld1 knockout mouse model to determine the effect of deficiency of Creld1 combined with increased VEGFA on atrioventricular canal development. Morphogenic response to VEGFA was abnormal in Creld1-deficient embryonic hearts, indicating that interaction between CRELD1 and VEGFA has the potential to alter atrioventricular canal morphogenesis. This supports our hypothesis that an additive effect between missense mutations in CRELD1 and a functional SNP in VEGFA contributes to the pathogenesis of AVSD.Atrioventricular septal defects (AVSD) are highly heritable, clinically significant congenital heart malformations. Genetic and environmental modifiers of risk are thought to work in unknown combinations to cause AVSD. Approximately 5-10% of simplex AVSD cases carry a missense mutation in CRELD1. However, CRELD1 mutations are not fully penetrant and require interactions with other risk factors to result in AVSD. Vascular endothelial growth factor-A (VEGFA) is a well-characterized modulator of heart valve development. A functional VEGFA polymorphism, VEGFA c.-634C, which causes constitutively increased VEGFA expression, has been associated with cardiac septal defects suggesting it may be a genetic risk factor. To determine if there is an allelic association with AVSD we genotyped the VEGFA c.-634 SNP in a simplex AVSD study cohort. Over-representation of the c.-634C allele in the AVSD group suggested that this genotype may increase risk. Correlation of CRELD1 and VEGFA genotypes revealed that potentially pathogenic missense mutations in CRELD1 were always accompanied by the VEGFA c.-634C allele in individuals with AVSD suggesting a potentially pathogenic allelic interaction. We used a Creld1 knockout mouse model to determine the effect of deficiency of Creld1 combined with increased VEGFA on atrioventricular canal development. Morphogenic response to VEGFA was abnormal in Creld1-deficient embryonic hearts, indicating that interaction between CRELD1 and VEGFA has the potential to alter atrioventricular canal morphogenesis. This supports our hypothesis that an additive effect between missense mutations in CRELD1 and a functional SNP in VEGFA contributes to the pathogenesis of AVSD.
PDF
