Aunty Puanani Burgess is a poet, community development consultant, grassroots activist, and facilitator from the Wai‘anae Coast of O‘ahu. She has been involved in a number of sovereignty and ...‘āina-based struggles throughout Hawai‘i, including Kaho‘olawe, Sand Island, and the process to renegotiate taro farming leases in Waipi‘o Valley. Aunty Pua finds it difficult to discuss her role separately from that of her husband of forty years, Pōkā Laenui (Pōkā) Hayden Burgess, because he has always provided thoughtful and intellectual grounding for her work. His research to unearth the history of Hawai‘i’s illegal overthrow provides a foundation of many efforts for
Rights-based management approaches are being increasingly applied to global fisheries as an alternative to deficiencies associated with centralized or top-down management. In fisheries, these ...approaches may include a diversity of methods such as catch shares, territorial user rights for fishing, individual transferable quotas, fisheries concessions, cooperatives, and comanagement. Many of these approaches are being implemented in small-scale fisheries contexts, without full consideration of how the legacy of previous governing institutions or tenure arrangements may affect implementation. Likewise, few case studies examine whether rights-based management approaches are appropriate for given contexts, examine how they fit within a nested administrative hierarchy, or describe their shared property rights components in practice. These knowledge gaps may obscure key stewardship incentives, veil existing power relations, and constrain opportunities for different management models while also prolonging or preventing governance transformations. We illustrate the importance of these factors through a case study of institutional change in coral reef fisheries in Hawai‘i. We use institutional analysis to examine coral reef fisheries management across two time periods: historical marine tenure in the Hawaiian Kingdom (1810–1893) and under contemporary centralized management (1982–2018). We then compared these management regimes to emerging comanagement in Hawai‘i (1994–2018). Our analysis reveals that few rights are actually devolved to communities seeking to implement comanagement. We also highlight considerable administrative complexity and variability within historical marine tenure regimes. We conclude by considering several issues relevant to the performance of rights-based approaches such as comanagement, including devolution of property rights to the local level, matching administrative and social-ecological complexity, the importance of historical context and narratives in shaping solutions, and the perceived legitimacy of governance arrangements.
