•Sexual dimorphism is observed in genetic parameters and environmental sensitivity.•The inclusion of sex in defining the environmental descriptor introduces bias.•However, sex-specific analysis is appropriate for estimating genetic parameters. This study investigates the environmental sensitivity and sexual dimorphism in the genetic parameters of weaning weight (WW) in Nelore beef cattle. Five reaction norms models were employed to analyze the 148,131 WW records, considering different definitions of the environmental descriptor (ED). (Co)variance components and genetic parameters were separately estimated for males and females. Results reveal substantial sexual dimorphism in various parameters. Significant divergence across sexes was observed for environmental sensitivity, with males showing an increased response to favorable environments while females genetically responded better to more challenging environments. Including sex in defining the ED can inflate the estimated breeding values of sires with a higher number of male progeny records, highlighting the importance of choosing a reliable ED in analyses of traits influenced by sexual dimorphism and genotype-by-environment interaction (G × E). The observed sexual dimorphism and environmental sensitivity underscore the complexity of genetic evaluation of WW in beef cattle populations, with implications for selection strategies. The findings suggest that a sex-separated trait analysis considering G × E effects is most appropriate for genetic evaluations of WW. However, a simpler single-trait model excluding sex from the ED definition yielded a higher coincidence of selected sires with the sex-separated analysis. In conclusion, understanding sexual dimorphism and environmental sensitivity is crucial for genetic evaluations and selection decisions in beef cattle breeding programs, emphasizing the need for careful model selection and ED definition.