A young male patient presented with unilateral proptosis of the left eye. Laboratory tests and an initial computed tomography scan of the orbit were compatible with euthyroid orbitopathy. He subsequently underwent decompression surgery for unfavorable cosmesis and corneal exposure symptoms with good results, but returned 1 year later for recurrence of proptosis. There was a superomedial fatty density extraconal mass on computed tomography scan. A biopsy done a year later confirmed the diagnosis of well-differentiated liposarcoma from the previously noted mass and a dedifferentiated component in the newly appeared mass in the intraconal space. Orbital exenteration with radial forearm free flap was performed followed by orbital radiotherapy. No disease recurrence or metastasis was seen on follow-ups for 7 years since undergoing treatment.