Nuclear pasta phases in the neutron stars mantle can affect the mechanical and transport properties of superdense matter, thus playing an important role in the dynamics and evolution of neutron stars. In this paper, we compare results obtained by the Extended Thomas–Fermi (ETF) method with the compressible liquid drop model (CLDM), based on the thermodynamically consistent description of the surface properties calculated for the two-phase plane interface and the same energy-density functional (for numerical illustration, we applied the Skyrme-type functional SLy4). Our ETF calculations found that pasta phases in cylindrical form cover a significant crustal region (both normal and inverse phases, aka spaghetti and bucatini are presented). Meanwhile, within the applied CLDM framework, which includes the thermodynamically required effect of neutron adsorption on the cluster’s surface but neglects curvature corrections, only the spaghetti phase was found to be energetically favorable in the small density range prior to crust–core transition. On the other hand, the recent CLDM of Dinh Thi et al., 2021, which, on the contrary, accounts for curvature term but neglects neutron adsorption, predicts pasta phase onset in better agreement with the ETF. This fact highlights the importance of the curvature effects and allows counting on the potential validity of the CLDMs as a convenient, transparent and accurate tool for investigation of the pasta-phase properties.