Thyrotoxicosis can exhibit overlapping symptoms of psychosis in the general population. Each of these pathologies has well-established workups and management. Rare presentations of thyroiditis and psychosis in the postpartum state have been seen in case studies mostly, but data on the prevalence of postpartum psychosis in association with postpartum thyroiditis are not available. Here, we present a unique case of a patient with a history of bipolar disorder who originally presented with postpartum thyroiditis that was worked up and managed appropriately. However, on follow-up, the patient was found to have progressed into prominent psychosis. Both thyroiditis and psychosis were managed individually with full remission upon discharge and is doing well today. The co-occurrence of postpartum psychosis and thyroiditis presents a unique challenge for timely diagnosis and management. We present a case of a young woman initially diagnosed with postpartum thyroiditis needing further management of postpartum psychosis due to persistent symptoms. Clinical presentation supported with a prior history of mood disorder increases the likelihood of these diagnoses together.