Laser interstitial thermal therapy (LITT) is a minimally invasive surgical option for the treatment of brain tumors introduced in 1983. The innovative technique was welcomed for its ability to access deep-seated supratentorial and posterior cranial fossa lesions. Surgical approaches to pineal region tumors are challenging and require a high degree of precision since the critical vasculature, such as the vein of Galen and precentral vein, in the area pose significant anatomical challenges to operating surgeons. To minimize the risk of damaging this key venous anatomy, an infratentorial approach may be more advantageous. We present a case where LITT was utilized through an infratentorial approach to a pineal region tumor. A 62-year-old male with no significant past medical history presented to his primary care physician complaining of ataxia and headaches for the past four weeks. An MRI was concerning for multicentric glioma within the cerebellar hemispheres, brainstem extending to the middle cerebellar peduncle, upper cervical spinal cord, and pineal region. An enhancing lesion of the midbrain tectum was concerning for a high-grade tumor. We decided to proceed with stereotactic biopsy and magnetic resonance-guided LITT via an infratentorial approach. Supratentorial trajectory planning did not allow for a safe corridor due to the venous anatomy; thus, it was decided to proceed with an infratentorial approach. The patient was positioned prone, had his bone fiducial CT fused with MRI, and the tumor was targeted using robotic guidance (ROSA, Zimmer Biomet, Warsaw, Indiana). Postoperatively, he suffered from transient diplopia due to cranial nerve VI palsy. Additionally, the postoperative MRI revealed a decrease in the size of the enhancing lesion and the hyperintense T2 signal within the brainstem. Open surgical approaches to tumors within the pineal region often pose an anatomic and neurovascular challenge. We describe the safe utilization of a novel, previously unreported infratentorial approach utilizing LITT with promising treatment, morbidity, and efficacy outcomes. A larger series will be necessary to ensure the safety and efficacy of this approach.