Akademska digitalna zbirka SLovenije - logo
E-viri
Recenzirano Odprti dostop
  • Istup člana društva s ogran...
    Brnabić, Ratko; Brkić, Bojan

    Zbornik radova Pravnog fakulteta u Splitu, 09/2017, Letnik: 54, Številka: 3
    Journal Article

    Istup člana iz društva je pravno sredstvo koje je zakonodavac stavio na raspolaganje članovima društva s ograničenom odgovornošću, a riječ je o dobrovoljnom izlasku iz društva što za posljedicu ima prestanak članstva. Tim sredstvom oni se ne mogu koristiti bez ograničenja. Naime, istupom člana mijenjaju se članski odnosi u društvu, a društvo je članu dužno isplatiti i naknadu za njegov poslovni udio što može utjecati na sposobnost društva za podmirivanje svojih obveza. Stoga se istup može dopustiti samo pod pretpostavkama uređenima Zakonom, u suprotnom bi pravo na istup predstavljalo sredstvo zlouporabe prava. U tom smislu, posebnu pozornost pobuđuje pojam opravdanog razloga za istup člana i njegov sadržaj treba utvrditi i izvan okvira zakonske odredbe koja ga uređuje. Članovi mogu svojim pravima raspolagati i na drugi način pa tako mogu svoje poslovne udjele u društvu prenijeti na treće. U praksi se, međutim, pokazalo da se u društvene ugovore nerijetko unose odredbe o vinkulaciji poslovnih udjela pa je tada potrebno za prijenos dobiti odobrenje društva. Nadalje, kod poduzetničkih ugovora, kod priključenja kao i kod statusnih promjena član ima zakonom uređeno pravo na istup iz društva. Pored prava na istup, manjinski članovi zbog opravdanog razloga imaju pravo tužbom zahtijevati prestanak društva. U radu će biti više riječi o pretpostavkama za istup, postupku istupa kao i njegovim pravnim učincima. Na kraju se donose izvorni zaključci o pravnoj naravi tog instituta. It is indisputable that members of Limited Liability Companies have the right to step out from the company even when it is not specifically regulated in the social contract. It means that in principle they can do that as the act of their own will, sometimes contrary to the will of the other members. The right to step out from the company is an inalienable personal right of every member. That right stems from the general legal principle that any permanent legal relationship may end if there's a legitimate, justified reason. The above mentioned right cannot be excluded or limited, but can only be expanded. Although the member has the right to step out, it is his primary responsibility to take everything in his power to transfer his business share to the new holder and to use the right to step out from the company only as a subsidiary solution. When transferring shares of the company one should pay attention to several facts: first, there is no regulated market for the shares of the LLC such as is the case with stocks; secondly, the transfer of shares is often difficult because of the relationship between members of the company so the potential buyer sometimes steps into the unknown situation. Therefore, this "theoretical" possibility to dispose of the share is not always a just solution so the Lawmaker returns the balance with the provisions on the right of members to step out from the company. The process, which will end with the elimination of the member from the company, must meet three preconditions: first, there must be a legitimate reason when it is not reasonably to expect that the member will remain in the company, taking into account all the circumstances of the case; secondly, there should be no milder legal remedy whereby a member can achieve the goal and third, the company must have sufficient funds for this transaction, considering the principle of maintaining the company's capital.