Significance Mutations in titin are a major cause of heart failure, yet the functions of large parts of titin are not understood. Here we studied titin’s I-band/A-band junction that has been proposed to be crucial for thick filament length control. We made a mouse in which titin’s IA junction was deleted. Super-resolution microscopy (structured illumination microscopy) revealed that deleting the IA junction increases the strain on titin’s molecular spring elements without altering thick filament length. Single cell biomechanical measurements showed that this increases passive stiffness while functional studies at the whole animal level revealed diastolic dysfunction, exercise intolerance, and modest concentric cardiac hypertrophy—signature features of heart failure with preserved ejection fraction. Our studies support that titin is a promising therapeutic target for treating heart failure. Titin, the largest protein known, forms a giant filament in muscle where it spans the half sarcomere from Z disk to M band. Here we genetically targeted a stretch of 14 immunoglobulin-like and fibronectin type 3 domains that comprises the I-band/A-band (IA) junction and obtained a viable mouse model. Super-resolution optical microscopy (structured illumination microscopy, SIM) and electron microscopy were used to study the thick filament length and titin’s molecular elasticity. SIM showed that the IA junction functionally belongs to the relatively stiff A-band region of titin. The stiffness of A-band titin was found to be high, relative to that of I-band titin (∼40-fold higher) but low, relative to that of the myosin-based thick filament (∼70-fold lower). Sarcomere stretch therefore results in movement of A-band titin with respect to the thick filament backbone, and this might constitute a novel length-sensing mechanism. Findings disproved that titin at the IA junction is crucial for thick filament length control, settling a long-standing hypothesis. SIM also showed that deleting the IA junction moves the attachment point of titin’s spring region away from the Z disk, increasing the strain on titin’s molecular spring elements. Functional studies from the cellular to ex vivo and in vivo left ventricular chamber levels showed that this causes diastolic dysfunction and other symptoms of heart failure with preserved ejection fraction (HFpEF). Thus, our work supports titin’s important roles in diastolic function and disease of the heart.