Understanding the origins of potential source rocks and unraveling the intricate connections between reservoir oils and their source formations in the Siwa Basin (Western Desert, Egypt) necessitate a thorough oil-source correlation investigation. This objective is achieved through a meticulous analysis of well-log responses, Rock-Eval pyrolysis, and biomarker data. The analysis of Total Organic Carbon across 31 samples representing Paleozoic formations in the Siwa A-1X well reveals a spectrum of organic richness ranging from 0.17 wt% to 2.04 wt%, thereby highlighting diverse levels of organic content and the presence of both Type II and Type III kerogen. Examination of the fingerprint characteristics of eight samples from the well suggests that the Dhiffah Formation comprises a blend of terrestrial and marine organic matter. Notably, a significant contribution from more oxidized residual organic matter and gas-prone Type III kerogen is observed. Contrarily, the Desouky and Zeitoun formations exhibit mixed organic matter indicative of a transitional environment, and thus featuring a pronounced marine influence within a more reducing setting, which is associated with Type II kerogen. Through analysis of five oil samples from different wells—SIWA L-1X, SIWA R-3X, SIWA D-1X, PTAH 5X, and PTAH 6X, it is evident that terrestrial organic matter, augmented by considerable marine input, was deposited in an oxidizing environment, and contains Type III kerogen. Geochemical scrutiny confirms the coexistence of mixed terrestrial organic matter within varying redox environments. Noteworthy is the uniformity of identified kerogen Types II and III across all samples, known to have potential for hydrocarbon generation. The discovery presented in this paper unveils captivating prospects concerning the genesis of oil in the Jurassic Safa reservoir, suggesting potential links to Paleozoic sources or even originating from the Safa Member itself. These revelations mark a substantial advancement in understanding source rock dynamics and their intricate relationship with reservoir oils within the Siwa Basin. By illuminating the processes of hydrocarbon genesis in the region, this study significantly enriches our knowledge base. Display omitted •Analysis of well-log responses, Rock-Eval pyrolysis, and biomarker data.•Diverse levels of organic content and the presence of both Type II and III kerogen.•Dhiffah Formation comprises a blend of terrestrial and marine organic matter.•Desouky and Zeitoun exhibit mixed organic matter with Type II oil-prone kerogen.•Jurassic Safa reservoir oil comes from Paleozoic or Safa sources.