The aim of this study was to examine the challenges confronting surgeons performing basic science research in today's academic surgery environment.
Multiple studies have identified challenges ...confronting surgeon-scientists and impacting their ability to be successful. Although these threats have been known for decades, the downward trend in the number of successful surgeon-scientists continues. Clinical demands, funding challenges, and other factors play important roles, but a rigorous analysis of academic surgeons and their experiences regarding these issues has not previously been performed.
An online survey was distributed to 2504 members of the Association for Academic Surgery and Society of University Surgeons to determine factors impacting success. Survey results were subjected to statistical analyses. We also reviewed publicly available data regarding funding from the National Institutes of Health (NIH).
NIH data revealed a 27% decline in the proportion of NIH funding to surgical departments relative to total NIH funding from 2007 to 2014. A total of 1033 (41%) members responded to our survey, making this the largest survey of academic surgeons to date. Surgeons most often cited the following factors as major impediments to pursuing basic investigation: pressure to be clinically productive, excessive administrative responsibilities, difficulty obtaining extramural funding, and desire for work-life balance. Surprisingly, a majority (68%) did not believe surgeons can be successful basic scientists in today's environment, including departmental leadership.
We have identified important barriers that confront academic surgeons pursuing basic research and a perception that success in basic science may no longer be achievable. These barriers need to be addressed to ensure the continued development of future surgeon-scientists.
Congenital lung malformations (CLMs) have a variable natural history. Larger lesions with CLM volume ratio (CVR) ≥ 1.6 are associated with hydrops and fetal mortality. The purpose of this study is to ...describe the management and outcomes of high-risk (CVR ≥ 1.6) CLM patients.
A retrospective cohort study was performed for all fetuses evaluated between May 2015 and May 2022. Demographics, prenatal imaging factors, prenatal and postnatal treatment, and outcomes were collected. Descriptive statistics were used to compare the cohorts.
Of 149 fetal CLM patients referred to our fetal center, 21/149 (14%) had CVR ≥ 1.6. One CLM patient had intrauterine fetal demise, and 2 patients were lost to follow-up. Of the remaining 18 patients, 11/18 (67%) received maternal steroids. Seven out of 18 patients (39%) underwent resection at the time of delivery with 1/7 (14%) undergoing exutero intrapartum treatment (EXIT)-to-resection, 5/7 (71%) undergoing EXIT-to-exteriorization-to-resection, and 1/7 (14%) undergoing a coordinated delivery to resection; among those undergoing resection, there were 2 fatalities (28.5%). Seven out of 18 (39%) patients required urgent neonatal open lobectomies, and the remaining 4/18 (22%) patients underwent elective thoracoscopic lobectomies with no mortality.
The natural history and outcomes of severe CLM patients remain highly variable. The EXIT-to-exteriorization-to-resection procedure may be a safe and effective approach for a subset of CLM patients with persistent symptoms of mass effect and severe mediastinal shift due to the observed decreased operative time requiring placental support observed in our study.
Mid-gestation fetal cutaneous wounds heal scarlessly and this has been attributed in part to abundant hyaluronan (HA) in the extracellular matrix (ECM) and a unique fibroblast phenotype. We recently ...reported a novel role for interleukin 10 (IL-10) as a regulator of HA synthesis in the fetal ECM, as well as the ability of the fetal fibroblast to produce an HA-rich pericellular matrix (PCM). We hypothesized that IL-10-mediated HA synthesis was essential to the fetal fibroblast functional phenotype and, moreover, that this phenotype could be recapitulated in adult fibroblasts via supplementation with IL-10 via an HA dependent process.
To evaluate the differences in functional profile, we compared metabolism (MTS assay), apoptosis (caspase-3 staining), migration (scratch wound assay) and invasion (transwell assay) between C57Bl/6J murine fetal (E14.5) and adult (8 weeks) fibroblasts. We found that fetal fibroblasts have lower rates of metabolism and apoptosis, and an increased ability to migrate and invade compared to adult fibroblasts, and that these effects were dependent on IL-10 and HA synthase activity. Further, addition of IL-10 to adult fibroblasts resulted in increased fibroblast migration and invasion and recapitulated the fetal phenotype in an HA-dependent manner.
Our data demonstrates the functional differences between fetal and adult fibroblasts, and that IL-10 mediated HA synthesis is essential for the fetal fibroblasts' enhanced invasion and migration properties. Moreover, IL-10 via an HA-dependent mechanism can recapitulate this aspect of the fetal phenotype in adult fibroblasts, suggesting a novel mechanism of IL-10 in regenerative wound healing.
Congenital diaphragmatic hernia (CDH) is a life-threatening, prenatally diagnosed congenital anomaly. We aim to characterize care and outcomes of infants with CDH in Texas and the impact of treating ...facilities volume of care.
Retrospective cohort study using a state-wide Hospital Inpatient Discharge Public Use Data File was conducted (2013–2021). Neonates and infants <1 year of age were included using CDH ICD-9/ICD-10 codes. Neonates transferred to an outside hospital were excluded to avoid double-counting. Descriptive statistics, chi-square and logistic regression analysis were performed.
Of 1314 CDH patient encounters identified, 728 (55%) occurred at 5 higher volume centers (HVC, >75 cases), 326 (25%) at 9 mid-volume centers (MVC, 20–75 cases) and 268 (20%) at 79 low volume centers (LVC, <20 cases). HVC had lower mortality rates (18%, MVC 22% vs LVC 27%; p = 0.011) despite treating sicker patients (extreme illness severity: HVC 71%, MVC 62% vs LVC 50%; p < 0.001) with longer length-of-stay (p < 0.001). Extracorporeal membrane oxygenation was used in 136 (10%) and provided primarily at HVC. LVC treated proportionately more non-white Hispanic patients (p < 0.001) and patients from counties along the Mexican border (p < 0.001). The predicted probability of mortality in CDH patients decreases with higher treatment facility CDH case volume, with a 0.5% decrease in the odds of mortality for every additional CDH case treated (p < 0.001).
Patients treated in HVC have significantly lower mortality despite increased severity. Our data suggest minority populations may be disproportionately treated at LVC associated with worse outcomes.
Retrospective Prognosis Study.
Level II.
Career development awards are important sources of support for surgeons who aim to become independent investigators. However, many challenges and opportunities need to be considered when deciding ...whether an individual is an appropriate career development award candidate. A quintessential example of the mentor-based career development award to support scientific training is the National Institutes of Health K award. In this article, we focus on issues that face surgeons interested in applying for these K series National Institutes of Health–mentored career development awards. We discuss the different types of K awards and the challenges they may pose for surgeons and provide recommendations for how to determine if a career development award is an appropriate approach given one’s career track and institutional environment. Lastly, we discuss how to effectively manage K awards and how to increase the odds of achieving a K to R award transition. The career development award can be a highly effective mechanism to help develop the careers of the next generation of surgeon-scientists, but successfully obtaining these awards requires an assessment of whether the career development award is the appropriate mechanism for the applicant and how to optimize the probability for success.
Traditionally, gestational age <34 wk and weight <2 kg are considered relative contraindications to extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO). There is a paucity of information that explains the ...outcomes in this unique population of premature neonates. The purpose of this study is to examine outcomes of patients who undergo ECMO at <34 wk at a single institution.
A single-center retrospective review was performed for neonates managed with ECMO in the neonatal intensive care unit from January 2012 to April 2022. Characteristics and outcome data were collected. The primary outcome studied was survival at discharge. Secondary outcomes were intraventricular hemorrhage, ischemic brain injury, and thrombosis. Data were analyzed with descriptive statistics.
Following exclusion, 107 patients were included with eight having initiating ECMO at <34 wk. Three (38%) patients, who received ECMO at <34 wk, incurred intraventricular hemorrhages compared to 14 (14%) in the ≥34-wk cohort. Two (25%), who underwent ECMO at <34 wk, exhibited signs of brain ischemia on imaging compared to 9 (9%) in those ≥34 wk, and 3 (38%) patients <34 wk experienced thrombosis compared to 31 (31%) in the ≥34-wk cohort. Five (63%) of those in the <34-wk cohort survived to discharge, similar to 61 (61%) in the ≥34 wk cohort.
Our data suggest that EGA <34 wk may not be a contraindication for ECMO, with appropriate counseling of potential risks.
•ECMO at <34 wk cohort experienced IVH and thrombosis.•Survival after ECMO at <34 wk was similar to survival at >34 wk.•Gestational age of <34 wk may not be a contraindication to ECMO.
Career Development Awards, including K-series grants from the National Institutes of Health, are often the first external award that developing surgeon-scientists will receive, and can lead to higher ...success rates in obtaining later independent funding. However, just like learning a new surgical technique, learning to create a competitive Career Development Award application requires good instruction and dedicated practice. This article is geared to deliver practical instruction for how to approach an initial Career Development Award application, so that aspiring surgeon-scientists will be equipped to tackle this daunting task in practice. Based on insights gleaned from published sources and the authors’ own experiences as K awardees, the discussion will cover preapplication considerations, including when to apply and how to get started, as well as specific advice for crafting well-developed components of the Career Development Award application. The objective of this article is to provide potential applicants with information and strategies to produce the highest quality, cohesive Career Development Award application possible. In sum, the authors hope that this article provides helpful insights to guide applicants toward successfully securing Career Development Award funding and establishing a solid foundation for their academic research careers.
The mid-gestation fetus is capable of regenerative healing with wound healing indistinguishable from surrounding skin. This review aims to evaluate the current knowledge of how the mid-gestation ...fetus heals without scar and the implications of these findings in efforts to recapitulate the fetal regenerative phenotype in the postnatal environment.
It has been over 30 years since the empirical observation that the fetus heals without scar; yet, the underlying mechanisms of this phenomenon have not been elucidated. Fetal wound healing is characterized by a distinct growth factor profile, an attenuated inflammatory response with an anti-inflammatory cytokine profile, an extracellular matrix rich in type III collagen and hyaluronan, attenuated biomechanical stress, and a potential role for stem cells. Current therapies to minimize scarring in postnatal wounds have attempted to recapitulate singular aspects of the fetal regenerative phenotype and have met with varying degrees of clinical success. We now have the molecular tools to more completely comprehend the fundamental mechanisms of fetal regenerative wound repair, which has the potential to provide insights into the identification of therapeutic targets to minimize the scar formation.
Successful therapies that help minimize postnatal scar formation can be realized through understanding the cellular and molecular mechanisms of fetal regenerative wound healing. These insights will have implications not only for cutaneous wound healing, but also potentially for any disease process characterized by excessive fibroplasia.
Congenital lung malformations (CLMs) are readily identified early in pregnancy with a variable natural history. Monitoring for lesion size and mediastinal shift (MS) is recommended following ...diagnosis. The purpose of this study is to propose a risk-stratified clinical algorithm for prenatal monitoring of CLM.
After ethical approval, all fetuses with CLMs evaluated at our fetal center from January 2015 to June 2022 were retrospectively reviewed. Patient demographics, imaging characteristics, and fetal interventions were collected. Lesions were stratified by congenital lung malformation volume ratio (CVR) and the presence of MS. Descriptive statistics and receiver operating characteristic curves were employed in the analysis.
We analyzed 111 patients with a mean of 23.4 wk gestational age, a median CVR of 0.5 (interquartile range, 0.3-1.2), and MS in 76 of 111(68%) patients on initial evaluation. Among low-risk patients (CVR ≤1.1), 96% remained low-risk on final evaluation. No patients transitioned from low to high risk during the growth period. Patients with CVR >1.1 often had persistent MS (P < 0.001). Hydrops (5/111, 5%) and fetal intervention (4/111, 4%) only occurred in patients with CVR >1.1 (P < 0.001, P = 0.002) and MS (P = 0.144, P = 0.214). On receiver operating characteristic curve analysis, initial CVR >1.1 had 100% sensitivity and negative predictive value for hydrops and fetal intervention.
CLMs with initial CVR ≤1.1 are low risk for hydrops and fetal intervention. We propose a risk-stratified algorithm for the monitoring of CLM during the growth period based on CVR. While our experience suggests that patients with CLM and MS are at higher risk, the current subjective assessment of MS is not adequately predictive. Incorporating an MS grading system may further refine risk stratification in the management of CLM.