Pathobiology of Modic changes Dudli, Stefan; Fields, Aaron J.; Samartzis, Dino ...
European Spine Journal,
11/2016, Letnik:
25, Številka:
11
Journal Article, Book Review
Recenzirano
Odprti dostop
Purpose
Low back pain (LBP) is the most disabling condition worldwide. Although LBP relates to different spinal pathologies, vertebral bone marrow lesions visualized as Modic changes on MRI have a ...high specificity for discogenic LBP. This review summarizes the pathobiology of Modic changes and suggests a disease model.
Methods
Non-systematic literature review.
Results
Chemical and mechanical stimulation of nociceptors adjacent to damaged endplates are likely a source of pain. Modic changes are adjacent to a degenerated intervertebral disc and have three generally interconvertible types suggesting that the different Modic change types represent different stages of the same pathological process, which is characterized by inflammation, high bone turnover, and fibrosis. A disease model is suggested where disc/endplate damage and the persistence of an inflammatory stimulus (i.e., occult discitis or autoimmune response against disc material) create predisposing conditions. The risk to develop Modic changes likely depends on the inflammatory potential of the disc and the capacity of the bone marrow to respond to it. Bone marrow lesions in osteoarthritic knee joints share many characteristics with Modic changes adjacent to degenerated discs and suggest that damage-associated molecular patterns and marrow fat metabolism are important pathogenetic factors. There is no consensus on the ideal therapy. Non-surgical treatment approaches including intradiscal steroid injections, anti-TNF-α antibody, antibiotics, and bisphosphonates have some demonstrated efficacy in mostly non-replicated clinical studies in reducing Modic changes in the short term, but with unknown long-term benefits. New diagnostic tools and animal models are required to improve painful Modic change identification and classification, and to clarify the pathogenesis.
Conclusion
Modic changes are likely to be more than just a coincidental imaging finding in LBP patients and rather represent an underlying pathology that should be a target for therapy.
Abstract Background context Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has limited diagnostic value for chronic low back pain because of the unclear relationship between any anatomic abnormalities on MRI and ...pain reported by the patient. Assessing the innervation of end plate and disc pathologies—and determining the relationship between these pathologies and any abnormalities seen on MRI—could clarify the sources of back pain and help identify abnormalities with enhanced diagnostic value. Purpose To quantify innervation in the vertebral end plate and intervertebral disc and to relate variation in innervation to the presence of pathologic features observed by histology and conventional MRI. Study design/setting A cross-sectional histology and imaging study of vertebral end plates and intervertebral discs harvested from human cadaver spines. Methods We collected 92 end plates and 46 intervertebral discs from seven cadaver spines (ages 51–67 years). Before dissection, the spines were scanned with MRI to grade for Modic changes and high-intensity zones (HIZ). Standard immunohistochemical techniques were used to localize the general nerve marker protein gene product 9.5. We quantified innervation in the following pathologies: fibrovascular end-plate marrow, fatty end-plate marrow, end-plate defects, and annular tears. Results Nerves were present in the majority of end plates with fibrovascular marrow, fatty marrow, and defects. Nerve density was significantly higher in fibrovascular end-plate marrow than in normal end-plate marrow (p<.001). Of the end plates with fibrovascular and fatty marrow, less than 40% were Modic on MRI. Innervated marrow pathologies collocated with more than 75% of the end plate defects; hence, innervation was significantly higher in end plate defects than in normal end plates (p<.0001). In the disc, nerves were observed in only 35% of the annular tears; in particular, innervation in radial tears tended to be higher than in normal discs (p=.07). Of the discs with radial tears, less than 13% had HIZ on T2 MRI. Innervation was significantly less in radial tears than in fibrovascular end-plate marrow (p=.05) and end-plate defects (p=.02). Conclusions These findings indicate that vertebral end-plate pathologies are more innervated than intervertebral disc pathologies and that many innervated end-plate pathologies are not detectable on MRI. Taken together, these findings suggest that improved visualization of end-plate pathologies could enhance the diagnostic value of MRI for chronic low back pain.
Modic changes (MCs) are magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) evidence of inflammatory and fibrotic vertebral bone marrow lesions that associate with adjacent disc degeneration and end plate damage. ...Although MC etiology is uncertain, historical data suggest a linkage to an autoimmune response of bone marrow triggered by the nucleus pulposus (NP).
The aim of this study was to test whether bone marrow has an autoimmune response to NP cells that is amplified by an inflammatory milieu and ultimately leads to MC development in vivo. We hypothesized that an inflammatory co-stimulus is required for bone marrow/NP crosstalk to stimulate MC.
This is an in-vitro cell co-culture study plus in-vivo experiments in rat caudal vertebrae.
In in-vitro study, bone marrow mononuclear cells (BMNCs) and NP cells (NPCs) from rats were co-cultured with and without interleukin (IL)-1α stimulation. Cell viability (n=3) of BMNCs and NPCs and gene expression (n=7) were analyzed. In in-vivo study, proinflammatory lipopolysaccharide (LPS) and control disc nucleus surrogates (NP micromass pellets) were generated in vitro from rat NPCs and implanted into rat tail vertebrae, and the response was compared with sham surgery (n=12 each). Tissue changes were investigated with T1w and T2w MRI (7T), histology, and immunohistochemistry (tumor necrosis factor, CD3) 1 (n=6) and 2 weeks (n=6) after implantation.
BMNC/NPC co-culture significantly increased lymphocyte viability (42%–69%, p<.05) and reduced NPC viability (96%–88%, p<.001), indicating immunogenicity of NPC. However, IL-1α was required to cause significant transcriptional upregulation of IL-1, IL-6, IL-10, and tropomyosin receptor kinase A. Therefore, an inflammatory activation is required to amplify the immune response. Immunogenicity of the NP was corroborated in vivo by CD3 cell accumulation around LPS and control disc surrogates at Day 7. However, only the LPS disc surrogate group demonstrated infiltration of CD3 cells at Day 14. Furthermore, end plate defects (p<.05, LPS: n=4/6, Ctrl: n=0/6, sham: n=0/6) and MC1-like MRI changes (T2w hyperintensity, p<.05) were only seen with LPS disc surrogates.
NPCs are immunogenic but cannot trigger MC without an additional proinflammatory stimulus. Our data suggest that MC requires end plate defects that allow marrow/NPC co-mingling plus an adjacent inflammatory “MC disc” that can amplify the immune response.
A literature review of intervertebral disc degeneration animal models.
Focus is placed on those models that suggest degeneration mechanisms relevant to human.
Medical knowledge from observational ...epidemiology and intervention studies suggest many etiologic causal factors in humans. Animal models can provide basic science data that support biologic plausibility as well as temporality, specificity, and dose-response relationships.
Studies are classified as either experimentally induced or spontaneous, where experimentally induced models are subdivided as mechanical (alteration of the magnitude or distribution of forces on the normal joint) or structural (injury or chemical alteration). Spontaneous models include those animals that naturally develop degenerative disc disease.
Mechanobiologic relationships are apparent as stress redistribution secondary to nuclear depressurization (by injury or chemical means) can cause cellular metaplasia, tissue remodeling, and pro-inflammatory factor production. Moderate perturbations can be compensated for by cell proliferation and matrix synthesis, whereas severe perturbations cause architectural changes consistent with human disc degeneration.
These models suggest that two stages of architectural remodeling exist in humans: early adaptation to gravity loading, followed by healing meant to reestablish biomechanical stability that is slowed by tissue avascularity. Current animal models are limited by an incomplete set of initiators and outcomes that are only indirectly related to important clinical factors (pain and disability).
Poor solute transport through the cartilage endplate (CEP) impairs disc nutrition and could be a key factor that limits the success of intradiscal biologic therapies. Here we demonstrate that ...treating the CEP with matrix metalloproteinase-8 (MMP-8) reduces the matrix constituents that impede solute uptake and thereby improves nutrient diffusion. Human CEP tissues harvested from four fresh cadaveric lumbar spines (age range: 38-66 years old) were treated with MMP-8. Treatment caused a dose-dependent reduction in sGAG, localized reductions to the amount of collagen, and alterations to collagen structure. These matrix modifications corresponded with 16-24% increases in the uptake of a small solute (376 Da). Interestingly, the effects of MMP-8 treatment depended on the extent of non-enzymatic glycation: treated CEPs with high concentrations of advanced glycation end products (AGEs) exhibited the lowest uptake compared to treated CEPs with low concentrations of AGEs. Moreover, AGE concentrations were donor-specific, and the donor tissues with the highest AGE concentrations appeared to have lower uptake than would be expected based on the initial amounts of collagen and sGAG. Finally, increasing solute uptake in the CEP improved cell viability inside diffusion chambers, which supports the nutritional relevance of enhancing the transport properties of the CEP. Taken together, our results provide new insights and in vitro proof-of-concept for a treatment approach that could improve disc nutrition for biologic therapy: specifically, matrix reduction by MMP-8 can enhance solute uptake and nutrient diffusion through the CEP, and AGE concentration appears to be an important, patient-specific factor that influences the efficacy of this approach.
Prolonged microgravity exposure is associated with localized low back pain and an elevated risk of post-flight disc herniation. Although the mechanisms by which microgravity impairs the spine are ...unclear, they should be foundational for developing in-flight countermeasures for maintaining astronaut spine health. Because human spine anatomy has adapted to upright posture on Earth, observations of how spaceflight affects the spine should also provide new and potentially important information on spine biomechanics that benefit the general population.
This study compares quantitative measures of lumbar spine anatomy, health, and biomechanics in astronauts before and after 6 months of microgravity exposure on board the International Space Station (ISS).
This is a prospective longitudinal study.
Six astronaut crewmember volunteers from the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) with 6-month missions aboard the ISS comprised our study sample.
For multifidus and erector spinae at L3–L4, measures include cross-sectional area (CSA), functional cross-sectional area (FCSA), and FCSA/CSA. Other measures include supine lumbar lordosis (L1–S1), active (standing) and passive (lying) flexion-extension range of motion (FE ROM) for each lumbar disc segment, disc water content from T2-weighted intensity, Pfirrmann grade, vertebral end plate pathology, and subject-reported incidence of chronic low back pain or disc injuries at 1-year follow-up.
3T magnetic resonance imaging and dynamic fluoroscopy of the lumbar spine were collected for each subject at two time points: approximately 30 days before launch (pre-flight) and 1 day following 6 months spaceflight on the ISS (post-flight). Outcome measures were compared between time points using paired t tests and regression analyses.
Supine lumbar lordosis decreased (flattened) by an average of 11% (p=.019). Active FE ROM decreased for the middle three lumbar discs (L2–L3: −22.1%, p=.049; L3–L4: −17.3%, p=.016; L4–L5: −30.3%, p=.004). By contrast, no significant passive FE ROM changes in these discs were observed (p>.05). Disc water content did not differ systematically from pre- to post-flight. Multifidus and erector spinae changed variably between subjects, with five of six subjects experiencing an average decrease 20% for FCSA and 8%–9% for CSA in both muscles. For all subjects, changes in multifidus FCSA strongly correlated with changes in lordosis (r2=0.86, p=.008) and active FE ROM at L4–L5 (r2=0.94, p=.007). Additionally, changes in multifidus FCSA/CSA correlated with changes in lordosis (r2=0.69, p=.03). Although multifidus-associated changes in lordosis and ROM were present among all subjects, only those with severe, pre-flight end plate irregularities (two of six subjects) had post-flight lumbar symptoms (including chronic low back pain or disc herniation).
We observed that multifidus atrophy, rather than intervertebral disc swelling, associated strongly with lumbar flattening and increased stiffness. Because these changes have been previously linked with detrimental spine biomechanics and pain in terrestrial populations, when combined with evidence of pre-flight vertebral end plate insufficiency, they may elevate injury risk for astronauts upon return to gravity loading. Our results also have implications for deconditioned spines on Earth. We anticipate that our results will inform new astronaut countermeasures that target the multifidus muscles, and research on the role of muscular stability in relation to chronic low back pain and disc injury.
Extracellular matrix (ECM) remodeling is important during bone development and repair. Because matrix metalloproteinase 13 (MMP13, collagenase-3) plays a role in long bone development, we have ...examined its role during adult skeletal repair. In this study we find that MMP13 is expressed by hypertrophic chondrocytes and osteoblasts in the fracture callus. We demonstrate that MMP13 is required for proper resorption of hypertrophic cartilage and for normal bone remodeling during non-stabilized fracture healing, which occurs via endochondral ossification. However, no difference in callus strength was detected in the absence of MMP13. Transplant of wild-type bone marrow, which reconstitutes cells only of the hematopoietic lineage, did not rescue the endochondral repair defect, indicating that impaired healing in Mmp13-/- mice is intrinsic to cartilage and bone. Mmp13-/- mice also exhibited altered bone remodeling during healing of stabilized fractures and cortical defects via intramembranous ossification. This indicates that the bone phenotype occurs independently from the cartilage phenotype. Taken together, our findings demonstrate that MMP13 is involved in normal remodeling of bone and cartilage during adult skeletal repair, and that MMP13 may act directly in the initial stages of ECM degradation in these tissues prior to invasion of blood vessels and osteoclasts.
Cross-sectional cohort study of chronic low back pain (CLBP) patients and matched controls.
To explore the interplay between vertebral endplate damage and adjacent paraspinal muscle (PSM) quality, ...and to test their association in a cohort of patients with CLBP and matched controls.
Nonspecific CLBP is challenging to diagnose, in part, due to uncertainty regarding the source of pain. Delineating interactions among potential CLBP mechanisms may enhance diagnosis and treatment customization.
We collected advanced MRI imaging on 52 adult subjects, including 38 CLBP patients and 14 age- and sex-matched asymptomatic control subjects. Mean multifidus and erector spinae fat fraction (FF) was measured throughout the spine using an IDEAL MRI sequence. Presence of cartilage endplate (CEP) defects was determined at each disc level using UTE MRI. Logistic regression was used to test association of PSM FF, CEP defects, modic changes (MC), disc degeneration, and their interplay.
We observed that CEP defects were the strongest predictor of nonspecific CLBP (OR: 14.1, P < 0.01) even after adjusting for MC and disc degeneration (OR: 26.1, P = 0.04). PSM quality did not independently distinguish patient and control groups, except for patients with high self-reported disability.At specifically L4L5, CEP damage was most prevalent and CEP damage was significantly associated with CLBP (OR: 3.7, 95% CI: 1.2-21.5, P = 0.03). CEP damage at L4L5 was predictive of CLBP when adjacent to PSMs with greater FF (MF, OR 14.7, P = 0.04; ES, OR: 17.3, P = 0.03), but not when PSM FF was lower and comparable to values in control, asymptomatic subjects.
These results demonstrate the clinically important reciprocity between passive and dynamic spinal stabilizers, and support the notion that therapies targeting the PSMs may provide clinical benefit even in the presence of other spinal pathologies.
4.
To measure the T2* of the human cartilaginous end plate by using magnetic resonance (MR) imaging with very short echo times and to determine the effect of the orientation of the end plate on T2* and ...on relationships between T2* and biochemical composition.
This study was exempt from institutional review board approval, and informed consent was not required. Thirty-four samples of three cadaveric lumbar spines (from subjects who died at ages 51, 57, and 66 years) containing cartilaginous end plates and subchondral bone were prepared. Samples were imaged with a 3-T imager for T2* quantification by using a three-dimensional very short echo time sequence (repetition time msec/echo times msec, 30/0.075, 2, 5, 12, 18). Samples were imaged with the end plate at three orientations with respect to the constant magnetic induction field: 0°, 54.7°, and 90°. After imaging, the cartilage was assayed for its water, glycosaminoglycan, and collagen content. Pearson correlations were used to investigate the effect of orientation on the relationships between T2* and biochemical composition.
T2* was significantly longer when measured at an orientation of 54.7° (21.8 msec ± 2.8 ± standard error of the mean) than at 0° (10.0 msec ± 0.7, P < .001) or 90° (9.9 msec ± 0.4, P < .001). At 54.7°, T2* was highly correlated with glycosaminoglycan content (r = 0.85, P < .001), the collagen-to-glycosaminoglycan ratio (r = -0.79, P < .001), and water content (r = 0.62, P = .02); at 0° and 90°, there were no significant differences in these relationships, with a minimum P value of .19.
T2* evaluation can allow noninvasive estimation of the degeneration of the cartilaginous end plate; however, the accuracy of T2*-based estimates of biochemical composition depends on the orientation of the end plate.