•There is a clear trade-off between the provisioning and other ecosystem services.•Shorter rotations provide better opportunities for timber, C and water production.•Longer rotations create better ...condition for cultural values, biodiversity and soil protection.•Short rotations lead to higher harvest rate and a more regulated forest structure.•Better combination of management interventions with a better suited tool is needed for an optimal rotation.
Addressing the spatio-temporal dynamics of forest development under different management scenarios with varying rotation lengths is a challenge in forest management planning. This research aims to forecast forest development and assess the relative consequences of varying rotation lengths on several ecosystem services such as wood production, habitat for biodiversity, carbon sequestration, water provision, soil protection and cultural values. Forest development is simulated with the ETCAP model to examine the long-term effects of various rotation lengths with silvicultural prescriptions on the ecosystem services. Bürücek forest planning unit is used as a case study area with 10,711 ha forests in upper Mediterranean region of Turkey. Shorter rotation lengths are considered one of the main mitigation measures to climate changes in forestry; however, lead to the increased harvest level, net present value, ground water and soil loss, and reductions in the largest stand volume, understory, basal area, carbon storage and the cultural values with less regulated forest structure. The management scenarios with longer rotation lengths, however, have highlighted improvements in the carbon storage, larger standing volume, mean stand age, basal area and cultural values, and reductions in the mean harvest volume, net present value, ground water and soil loss due to larger-even distribution of tree sizes and stand development stages. An aspiration for a higher level of provisioning services for economic motivations may need to be discarded for the sake of enhancing the capacity of forest ecosystems to sequester more carbon and provide better habitat condition for biodiversity conservation with a careful design and selection of rotation lengths. Overall, the choice of optimal rotation length is highly dependent on a desired set of management objectives and target forest structure driven mostly by management interventions with the appropriate type and level of ecosystem services, provided that a thorough understanding of forest dynamics is achieved by considering both risks and uncertainties associated with natural disturbances and socio-economic conditions.
•Some 1.1 billion ha are covered by all of the SFM tools investigated in FRA 2015.•Policies, laws and regulations supporting SFM cover 98% of permanent forest land.•Forest inventories have recently ...been conducted in 112 countries.•Some 52% of the total forest area was under Forest Management Plan (FMP) in 2010.•International forest certification was most extensive in high income countries.•There are positive increases in most SFM indicators globally.
Sustainable forest management (SFM) is many things to many people – yet a common thread is the production of forest goods and services for the present and future generations. The promise of sustainability is rooted in the two premises; first that ecosystems have the potential to renew themselves and second that economic activities and social perceptions or values that define human interaction with the environment are choices that can be modified to ensure the long term productivity and health of the ecosystem. SFM addresses a great challenge in matching the increasing demands of a growing human population while maintaining ecological functions of healthy forest ecosystems. This paper does not seek to define SFM, but rather provides analyses of key indicators for the national-scale enabling environment to gain a global insight into progress in implementing enabling and implementing SFM at the national and operational levels. Analyses of the Global Forest Resources Assessment 2015 (FRA) country report data are used to provide insights into the current state of progress in implementing the enabling conditions for SFM. Over 2.17 billion ha of the world’s forest area are predicted by governments to remain in permanent forest land use, of which some 1.1 billion ha are covered by all of the SFM tools investigated in FRA 2015. At the global scale, SFM-related policies and regulations are reported to be in place on 97% of global forest area. While the number of countries with national forest inventories has increased over that past ten years from 48 to 112, only 37% of forests in low income countries are covered by forest inventories. Forest management planning and monitoring of plans has increased substantially as has forest management certification, which exceeded a total of over 430 million ha in 2014. However, 90% of internationally verified certification is in the boreal and temperate climatic domains – only 6% of permanent forests in the tropical domain have been certified as of 2014. Results show that more work is needed to expand the extent and depth of work on establishing the enabling conditions that support SFM over the long term and suggests where those needs are greatest.
•Management intensities impact on the provision of all ecosystem services.•High rate of tending and afforestation provide better opportunities for timber, C and soil.•Extensive management creates ...better condition for biodiversity, water, recreation.•Rotation length has marginal impact on the provision of ecosystem services.•None of the planning alternatives can optimize all ecosystem services simultaneously.
Understanding forest dynamics under varying management intensification is a crucial step for designing and implementing sustainable forest management scenarios. One way to assess the sustainability is to evaluate the long-term supply of ecosystem services (ES) with some performance indicators. This research focuses on exploring the effects of management intensification on several ESs such as habitat for biodiversity conservation, wood production, carbon stock, cultural values, water provision and soil protection. Forest development was simulated over time with the ETCAP forest management decision support system (DSS) to investigate the effects of intensified forest management activities, representing different treatment rates, rotation periods and afforestation levels, on the selected ecosystem services. Hamidiye forest planning unit was used as a case study area with 19,009 ha forests in southeastern Turkey.
The management scenarios with intensified forest interventions such as high rate of thinning and afforestation areas with medium rotation ages led to increased harvest level, carbon storage, soil protection, deadwood and forest area, and reductions in largest stand volume, understory, basal area, ground water and cultural values. The same intensified scenarios with short rotation ages, however, resulted in again higher harvest levels, yet a more regulated forest structure due mainly to the increasing afforestation areas and productivity. Extension of rotation periods, however, appear to have marginal impact on carbon storage, positive effect on soil protection and significant effect on harvest level. Scenarios with low intensified interventions only resulted in high values of biodiversity conservation and cultural values. Intensive treatments and larger afforestation areas had significant impact on the overall results. Overall, the analysis of the modeling approach with varying management scenarios led to better and wider understanding of forest development over time by allowing the assessment of the impacts of management interventions on the sustainable supply of the ecosystem services that highly depend on the afforestation level, thinning rate and rotation period.
Against a background of intensifying climate-induced disturbances, the need to enhance the resilience of forests and forest management is gaining urgency. In forest management, multiple trade-offs ...exist between different demands as well as across and within temporal and spatial scales. However, methods to assess resilience that consider these trade-offs are presently lacking. Here we propose a hierarchical framework of principles, criteria, and indicators to assess the resilience of a social-ecological system by focusing on the mechanisms behind resilience. This hierarchical framework balances trade-offs between mechanisms, different parts of the social-ecological system, ecosystem services, and spatial as well as temporal scales. The framework was developed to be used in a participatory manner in forest management planning. It accounts for the major parts of the forest-related social-ecological system and considers the multiple trade-offs involved. We demonstrate the utility of the framework by applying it to a landscape dominated by Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) Karst.) in Central Europe, managed for three different management goals. The framework highlights how forest resilience varies with the pursued management goals and related management strategies. The framework is flexible and can be applied to various forest management contexts as part of a participatory process with stakeholders. It thus is an important step towards operationalizing social-ecological resilience in forest management systems.
•Forest management goals determine the desired level of resilience.•Participatory stakeholder engagement is crucial in operational resilience assessment.•Our resilience framework allows projecting future scenarios for indicator analysis.•Multiple trade-offs should be balanced to achieve resilience.
Management planning for forests in Turkey has undergone gradual evolution over the last century. Developing and implementing a comprehensive management planning framework present significant ...challenges. This paper evaluates the effectiveness of various forest management planning approaches implemented across the country over different time periods, with overarching planning principles. It formulates a robust planning framework and proposes improvements grounded in scientific advancements and international standards. The assessment indicated that the management plans were developed using reputable scientific methods and principles aimed at ensuring the sustainable management of forest resources with certain strengths and opportunities presented by SWOT analysis. All management plans shared a common planning concept primarily focused on maximizing wood production through the area-control harvest scheduling method (except for continuous cover forest, which employed the single tree selection method). Each management plan established its unique vision, targets, policies, objectives, and planning guidelines. Forest inventory data were gathered through a combination of ground surveys and remotely sensed data to characterize and stratify the landscape. A robust in-house management authority and governance system with appropriate technical capacity and guidelines were developed and implemented, fostering a sound common working culture and tools. However, some notable drawbacks were identified, including political pressure, biomass/carbon accounting, growth-yield modelling, economic analysis, limited characterization of the full range of ecosystem services, risk and uncertainty analysis, food security and, particularly, long-term sustainability and scenario analysis with the appropriate decision-making tools and methods. Despite a few strengths, these limitations may raise concerns about the far-sighted design and application, potentially jeopardizing the sustainable management of forest ecosystems. Proposed improvement strategies for an efficient forest ecosystem management planning system include characterization of ecosystem services, modelling their productivity, scenario analysis with a decision support system, stakeholder involvement, balancing utilization and conservation targets, conducting risk and uncertainty analysis and economic analysis of management actions.
Characterizing and managing multiple ecosystem services is vital for decision-making in sustainable forest management. This study focuses on characterizing and assessing the biophysical and spatial ...distribution of ecosystem services such as wood production, biodiversity and carbon sequestration in the Kumluca state forest (Turkey). The key ecosystem services were thematically characterized, economically valued, spatially mapped and mobilized as a knowledge-base for ecosystem based planning. Average wood production is higher (135.06 m3/ha) than the overall average (72 m3/ha) in Turkey. The average carbon stock is 119 tC/ha, indicating a medium capacity. The habitat potential for biodiversity is low to medium, based on the 15 target species. Total economic value of the key ecosystem services is estimated at US$624,748,191 (US$6132/ha). The composition and spatial distribution of vegetation determines the extent and potential of ecosystem services. This study emphasizes that comprehensive quantification as well as valuation of ecosystem services can facilitate underpinnings for efficient communication and good decision making in sustainable resource management for multiple values. The orchestrated vision of conservation and sustainable use of ecosystem services based on a comprehensive characterization, modeling, valuing and participatory approach is a strategy for sustainable forest management.
•Primary forest ecosystem services in Kumluca were characterized and assessed.•Economic valuation facilitates communication of relative importance to the policy makers.•Mapping ecosystem services are useful for identifying and visualizing priority areas•The capacity of Kumluca is moderate to high for provisioning ecosystem services•Trade-offs and synergies between different ecosystem services were realized.
Forest management planning and management agencies in Canada have been moving towards an ecosystem-based management (EBM) approach that honours whole ecosystem dynamics over all time and space ...scales. As part of this evolution, provincial, national, and international agencies have added coarse filter indicators to represent pre-industrial, or ‘natural’ range of variation (NRV) ecosystem conditions as ecologically defendable baselines. The intent was to balance the more traditional species specific (i.e., fine filter) approach to sustainability with a more holistic (i.e., coarse scale) model of ecosystem dynamics. The development and acceptance of coarse filter indicators has been neither linear nor straightforward. One of the more important assumptions inherent in an NRV strategy is that it captures relevant, meaningful patterns at the most appropriate scales in a practical way. To test this assumption, I used a spatially explicit simulation model to compare landscapes created under pre-industrial conditions with those created using four different thresholds of disturbance size commonly used today in boreal Canada. The results suggest that even a 10,000 ha upper size limit create significantly higher levels of homogeneity and fragmentation at intermediate spatial scales relative to pre-industrial landscape patterns. Towards developing a new, more robust coarse filter indicator, the net area burned at four grid sizes over 10 and 20 years was calculated for natural wildfire data from northern Saskatchewan. The results suggest that wildfire tends to cluster at all scales due largely to the influence of large infrequent wildfires. In contrast, data from two forest management areas in Alberta summarized at the same scales confirm that harvesting activity tends to spread out evenly across the landscape. Based on these findings, the NRV data was then refined to capture; 1) the percentage of grid cells where high disturbance levels occur (WHEREs – or WHERE you are) and the proportion where no disturbance occurs (WYNs – or Where You are Not). The WHERE-WYN indicator is unique in that it specifically integrates time as a dimension of landscape dynamics. It is also easily understood and calculated, corresponds directly to management activities, has NRV equivalents, and applicable to most of boreal Canada. Augmenting the current suite of coarse filter indicator with the WHERE-WYN combination addresses a critical gap in our NRV toolkit and will ultimately help create more sustainable landscapes.
•Fire size indicators in boreal Canadahave a limited ability to reflect healthier landscape conditions.•Natural wildfire on boreal landscapes cluster over time and space while human activity tends to be more ubiquitous.•Disturbance event clustering can be captured by a new, simple two-part metric.•Landscape metrics must include undeveloped spaces.
In Japan, the number of plantation forests that must be harvested is increasing. Therefore, it is desirable to establish an operational system with a high efficiency. When using efficient forestry ...machinery, it is necessary to secure a sufficient amount of operation commensurate with the cost of machines, while simultaneously considering the feasibility of the labor force. However, no previous research has presented a quantitative forestry operation management method from the viewpoint of optimizing the amount of operation on a regional forestry scale. First, a basic model that mathematically quantifies the amount of operation and changes in forest biomass by applying system dynamics (SD) was developed, and a regional forestry scenario with the labor force as a constraint was optimized. As a result of the optimization, it is suggested that the scenario will be sustainable if regional forests are managed in an area of approximately 800 ha for 10 workers. The amount of operation in the scenario was generally feasible with a limited labor force during the simulation period and was also validated against reported domestic forestry data. We conclude that the SD model can contribute to the development of a regional forest management plan tailored to local conditions. In addition, it will greatly contribute to the assessment of carbon reduction in the national forestry sector through sustainable management of local forest biomass resources.
Display omitted
•Sustainable forest biomass production requires a cycle of harvesting and planting.•System dynamics modeling enables a design for regional forest management.•It is necessary to manage about 800 ha for 10 workers in the case of regional forestry in Japan.•The operation contents of each year for sustainable forestry are quantified.•Quantification of forest carbon offset is possible by adding sub-models.
Forest management inventories (FMIs) provide critical information, usually at the stand level, for forest management planning. A typical FMI includes (i) the delineation of the inventory area to ...stands by applying auxiliary information; (ii) the classification of the stands according to categorical attributes such as age, site fertility, main tree species, and stand development; and (iii) measurement, modelling, and prediction of stand attributes of interest. The emergence of wall-towall remote-sensing data has enabled a paradigm change in FMIs from highly subjective, visual assessments to objective, model-based inferences. Previously, optical remote-sensing data were used to complement visual assessments, especially in stand delineation and height measurements. The evolution of airborne laser scanning (ALS) has made objective estimation of forest characteristics with known accuracy possible. New optical and Lidar-based sensors and platforms will allow further improvements of accuracy. However, there are still bottlenecks related to species-specific stand attribute information in mixed stands and assessments of tree quality. Here, we concentrate on approaches and methods that have been applied in the Nordic countries in particular.
Display omitted
•Alpine study sites with a long close-to-nature forestry (CNF) history were studied.•Alternative climate change and CNF management scenarios were simulated.•CNF performs well in ...ensuring multiple forest ecosystem services and biodiversity.•Climate change requires adaptation of CNF by fostering climate-adapted tree species.•High multifunctionality, including biodiversity, needs diversified management.
Close-to-nature forestry (CNF) has a long tradition in European Alpine forest management, playing a crucial role in ensuring the continuous provision of biodiversity and forest ecosystem services, including protection against natural hazards. However, climate change is causing huge uncertainties about the future applicability of CNF in the Alpine region. The question arises as to whether current CNF practices are still suitable for adapting forests to climate change impacts while also meeting the increasing societal demands regarding Alpine forests, including their potential contribution to climate change mitigation. To answer this question, we simulated forest development using the ForClim forest model at two Alpine study sites, together representing a large biogeographic gradient from high-elevation inner Alpine forests (Switzerland) to lower-elevation south-eastern Alpine forests (Slovenia). The simulations considered three climate scenarios (historical climate, SSP2-4.5 and SSP5-8.5) and six alternative management strategies, including both current CNF management practices and climate-adapted versions. Using an indicator based multi-criteria decision analysis framework, we assessed the joint impacts of climate and management on biodiversity and key ecosystem services of the investigated regions, including carbon sequestration (CS) inside and outside the forest ecosystem boundary. The joint effects of climate change and CNF varied, both among and within the study sites along the biogeographical gradient. While CS was more resistant to climate change under current CNF at the south-eastern Alpine site, it was more sensitive at the inner Alpine site, where CS potentials decreased at lower elevations. This adverse effect could be partly mitigated by fostering the use of climate-adapted tree species. However, current CNF and adaptations of it did not meet multiple management objectives equally well: while protection from gravitation hazards and timber production also benefited from this silvicultural practice, biodiversity benefited from CNF variants with low-intensity or no management. In conclusion, CNF has a high potential to continue fulfilling its crucial role in European Alpine forests. A differentiated approach will be needed in the future, however, to identify forest stands where adaptive measures are required, especially at sites particularly vulnerable to climate change. In combination with less intensively managed or unmanaged areas, CNF provides a management portfolio that will help European Alpine forests to meet the demands of future society.
PDF
