Heavy metal contamination in drinking water is a global health concern. Anthropogenic and geogenic activities exacerbate the concentrations of these metals in surface and groundwater. In this study, we sampled drinking water sourced from surface and groundwater resources at the environs of Mrima Hill and the Kwale heavy minerals sand deposit, Kwale County, Kenya. The concentrations of Cr, Ni, Cu, As, Cd, Pb, and U were measured using the inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometer. The water quality indices were evaluated using the weighted arithmetic index method, while the human health risks due to exposure to these heavy metals through the ingestion pathway were assessed using deterministic and probabilistic techniques. The concentrations of Cr and Cd in samples from both study areas exceeded the national and international maximum contaminant levels in drinking water. The concentration levels of Ni, Cu, As, and U in all samples from both study areas were within the recommended values in drinking water. Therefore, the quality of water from both study areas was unsuitable for human consumption due to Cd and Cr contamination. The non-carcinogenic risk assessment also showed that the hazard indices (HI) evaluated for both children and adults at the study areas were higher than unity. In addition, the estimated carcinogenic risks of both population groups were more than the recommended value of 10 –4 . This study shows that the residents near Mrima Hill and the Kwale heavy minerals sand deposit remain susceptible to carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic health risks emanating from exposure to these heavy metals in drinking water.