Supramolecular hydrogels derived from the self-assembly of organic molecules have been exploited for applications ranging from drug delivery to tissue engineering. The relationship between the structure of the assembly motif and the emergent properties of the resulting materials is often poorly understood, impeding rational approaches for the creation of next-generation materials. Aromatic π–π interactions play a significant role in the self-assembly of many supramolecular hydrogelators, but the exact nature of these interactions lacks definition. Conventional models that describe π–π interactions rely on quadrupolar electrostatic interactions between neighboring aryl groups in the π-system. However, recent experimental and computational studies reveal the potential importance of local dipolar interactions between elements of neighboring aromatic rings in stabilizing π–π interactions. Herein, we examine the nature of π–π interactions in the self- and coassembly of Fmoc-Phe-derived hydrogelators by systematically varying the electron-donating or electron-withdrawing nature of the side chain benzyl substituents and correlating these effects to the emergent assembly and gelation properties of the systems. These studies indicate a significant role for stabilizing dipolar interactions between neighboring benzyl groups in the assembled materials. Additional evidence for specific dipolar interactions is provided by high-resolution crystal structures obtained from dynamic transition of gel fibrils to crystals for several of the self-assembled/coassembled Fmoc-Phe derivatives. In addition to electronic effects, steric properties also have a significant effect on the interaction between neighboring benzyl groups in these assembled systems. These findings provide significant insight into the structure–function relationship for Fmoc-Phe-derived hydrogelators and give cues for the design of next-generation materials with desired emergent properties.