Background Lynch syndrome (LS) is a hereditary condition characterized by a high risk of colorectal cancer, endometrial cancer, and other neoplasia associated with germline alterations in DNA mismatch repair genes. The classical genetic diagnostic strategy for LS consists of the Sanger sequencing of genes associated with the suspected syndrome. Next‐generation sequencing (NGS) enables the simultaneous sequencing of a large number of hereditary cancer genes. Here, we aimed to study whether other germline pathogenic variants of hereditary cancer genes are present in patients with LS. Methods A cohort of 84 probands with a previous genetic diagnosis of LS by Sanger sequencing was reanalyzed using NGS via a commercial panel of 94 hereditary cancer genes by hybrid capture. The American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics criteria were used to classify the clinical significance of the variants. The findings of NGS were confirmed by Sanger sequencing. When possible, genetic analyses of the new findings in the proband's relatives were also performed by Sanger sequencing. Results We identified five families (6%), out of 84, with at least two germline pathogenic variants conferring to high or moderate risk in different dominant cancer‐predisposing genes: MLH1‐BRCA2‐NBN, MLH1‐BRCA1, MSH2‐ATM, MSH6‐NF1, and MLH1‐FANCA. Interestingly, only one out of these five families exhibited a clinical phenotype associated with the new pathogenic variants. The family with three pathogenic variants of the MLH1‐BRCA2‐NBN genes showed a high aggregation of tumors associated with LS and breast and ovarian cancer syndrome. Conclusions Our results showed that the co‐occurrence of more than one pathogenic variant in cancer‐predisposing genes was remarkable among cases of LS. In most cases, no clinicial manifestations were associated with the secondary pathogenic variants. Further studies are needed to confirm these findings and elucidate their clinical impact. Reanalysis of LS families should be considered only in families with mixed clinical phenotypes. We aimed to explore whether other pathogenic variants for hereditary cancer genes are present in Lynch syndrome patients, to have a more comprehensive view of the genetic architecture for cancer risk. We found five families (6%) with at least two pathogenic variant in high‐ and/or moderate‐risk‐associated cancer genes. However, in most cases, no clinical manifestations associated with the secondary pathogenic variants were evidenced.