The early identification of responsive and resistant patients to androgen receptor-targeting agents (ARTA) in metastatic castration-resistant prostate cancer (mCRPC) is not completely possible with prostate-specific antigen (PSA) assessment and conventional imaging. Considering its ability to determine metabolic activity of lesions, positron emission tomography (PET) assessment might be a promising tool. We carried out a monocentric prospective study in patients with mCRPC treated with ARTA to evaluate the role of different PET radiotracers: 49 patients were randomized to receive 11C-Choline, Fluorine 18 fluciclovine (anti-1-amino-3-18F-fluorocyclobutane-1-carboxylic acid - FACBC) (18F-FACBC), or Gallium-68-prostate-specific-membrane-antigen (68Ga-PSMA) PET, one scan before therapy and one 2 months later. The primary aim was to investigate the performance of three novel PET radiotracers for the early evaluation of response to ARTA in metastatic CRPC patients; the outcome evaluated was biochemical response (PSA reduction ≥50%). The secondary aim was to investigate the prognostic role of several semiquantitative PET parameters and their variations with the different radiotracers in terms of biochemical progression-free survival (bPFS) and overall survival (OS). The study was promoted by the Italian Department of Health (code RF-2016-02364809). Regarding the primary endpoint, at log-rank test a statistically significant correlation was found between metabolic tumor volume (MTV) (P = 0.018) and total lesion activity (TLA) (P = 0.025) percentage variation among the two scans with 68Ga-PSMA PET and biochemical response. As for the secondary endpoints, significant correlations with bPFS were found for 68Ga-PSMA total MTV and TLA at the first scan (P = 0.001 and P = 0.025, respectively), and MTV percentage variation (P = 0.031). For OS, statistically significant correlations were found for different 68Ga-PSMA and 18F-FACBC parameters and for major maximum standardized uptake value at the first 11C-Choline PET scan. Our study highlighted that 11C-Choline, 68Ga-PSMA, and 18F-FACBC semiquantitative PET parameters and their variations present a prognostic value in terms of OS and bPFS, and MTV and TLA variations with 68Ga-PSMA PET a correlation with biochemical response, which could help to assess the response to ARTA. •An unmet need in mCRPC is the early evaluation of response to ARTA.•We evaluated ARTA response with three different PET radiotracers, before therapy onset and after 2 months.•We analyzed PET-derived parameters to explore their prognostic value in terms of bPFS and OS.•68Ga-PSMA is the most reliable tracers to evaluate ARTA response, in view of the correlation with biochemical response.•Several PET-derived parameters could represent an effective prognostic factor.