Surface pre-treatment of graphitic electrode materials for lithium ion cells has recently been shown to significantly reduce the irreversible consumption of material and charge due to the formation of the so-called solid electrolyte interphase (SEI) during battery charging. In this paper, we compare graphite powders and carbon fibres as model materials for X-ray photoemission spectroscopy (XPS) studies of the effects of surface pre-treatments. For carbon fibres, the surface carbon percentage was found to vary from 70–95% depending on the surface treatment, with corresponding changes in the relative proportion of graphitic compared to CO bonds, as determined from C 1s curve fits. In contrast, results from the graphite powders show very little change in surface chemical composition and an essentially constant C 1s lineshape dominated by graphitic carbon. SEM data show the carbon fibre cross-section to be composed of a radial array of layered graphite, leaving a surface consisting largely of prismatic planes, while the graphite powder consists of graphite platelets with the surface area predominantly of basal planes. We conclude that the chemical modification occurs at the prismatic planes, and that the powders are unsuitable as models for XPS studies of electrode surface modification, while the fibres are very well suited.