With survival expectation that of age-matched controls and given excellent response and worldwide access to tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKI), family planning is increasingly important for a considerable fraction of patients with chronic myeloid leukemia (CML). The potential for therapy discontinuation (“treatment free remission”) can afford the opportunity for a CML patient in deep response to plan and carry a pregnancy to full term without any therapeutic interventions. However, the reality of pregnancy desired or occurring when patients are not eligible for treatment-free remission raises the discussion of therapy choices during pregnancy. To date there are no official guidelines available to assist patients and clinicians with these decisions. This first position paper aims to analyze information published and presented surrounding this challenging area, with focus on different scenarios of disease burden and time from CML diagnosis, including CML discovered during pregnancy and pregnancy during CML treatment. An updated review, supported by data and presented together with authors’ joint recommendations, is aimed to counsel the practical management of CML patients and pregnancy.