: This article critically examines Kadri Vihvelin's proposal that to have free will is to have the ability to make choices on the basis of reasons, and to have this ability is to have a bundle of ...dispositions that can be exercised in more than one way. It is argued that partisans of Frankfurt examples can still make a powerful case for the view that being able to do otherwise, even on Vihvelin's compatibilist explication of ‘could have done otherwise,’ is not required for moral responsibility.
Özet: Yakup Kadri'nin (Karaosmanoğlu) Nur Baba romanının
1921'de Akşam gazetesinde tefrikasına başlanmış, fakat toplumun bazı
kesimlerinden gelen tepkiler üzerine tefrika yarıda kalmıştır. 1922'de
...kitap hâlinde yayımlanan roman, yine tepkilerle karşılaşmıştır. Hakkında
olumlu ve olumsuz görüşler ileri sürülen Nur Baba romanı sinema
filmine çekilmek istenmiş, bu defa da film seti basılarak filmin çekilmesine
engel olunmak istenmiştir. Toplumun değişik kesimlerinde ve
edebiyat adamlarında akis uyandıran roman, sonunda Mustafa Kemal
Atatürk'ün de dikkatini çeken bir eser olmuştur. Nur Baba, aynı zamanda
yurt dışında da akis yaratmıştır. Bu makalede Nur Baba romanının
yayımlanışıyla ortaya çıkan akisler araştırma ve inceleme konusu
yapılacaktır.
Abstract: In 1921 the Akşam newspaper began to publish Yakup
Kadri (Karaosmanoğlu)'s novel Nur Baba (Father Nimbus) in the form
of installments, but publication was discontinued shortly after because
of a variety of reactions that the installments received from certain
fractions in society. The work received similar reactions when it was
published in book form in 1922. Later on when a film adaptation of
Nur Baba was being made, the film set was attacked to prevent the
shooting of the film. This novel, which caused a variety of reactions in
different sections of society, eventually drew the attention of Mustafa
Kemal Atatürk as well. The novel also engaged some attention abroad.
This article looks into the variety of reactions caused by the publication
of Nur Baba.
