This 3-year meso-scale greenhouse study used 55-gallon columns to evaluate the survival and growth of boreal wetland communities planted on centrifuge (CF) tailings and co-mixed (CM) tailings capped with different reclamation cover soil capping designs. The CF tailings were capped with a shallow layer (10 and 30 cm) of peat reclamation material (PRM) and the CM tailings were capped with a shallow layer (5 cm) of PRM above 15 or 35 cm of reclamation subsoil (till). After 3 years, plant survival and growth on CF tailings showed significant improvement with a 10 cm PRM cap compared to the uncapped tailings, and plants growing on a 30 cm PRM cap outperformed those on the 10 cm PRM cap. Plant growth on CM tailings was significantly improved with a soil cover containing 5 cm PRM and at least 15 cm till. Among the seven native wetland species included in this study, the top performing species in terms of survival and above-ground biomass were Salix bebbiana, Scirpus microcarpus, and Carex aquatilis.