Abstract
The fractal dust particles observed by Rosetta cannot form in the physical conditions observed today in comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko (67P hereinafter), being instead consistent with ...models of the pristine dust aggregates coagulated in the solar nebula. Since bouncing collisions in the protoplanetary disc restructure fractals into compact aggregates (pebbles), the only way to preserve fractals in a comet is the gentle gravitational collapse of a mixture of pebbles and fractals, which must occur before their mutual collision speeds overcome ≈1 m s−1. This condition fixes the pebble radius to ≲1 cm, as confirmed by Comet Nucleus Infrared and Visible Analyser onboard Philae. Here, we show that the flux of fractal particles measured by Rosetta constrains the 67P nucleus in a random packing of cm-sized pebbles, with all the voids among them filled by fractal particles. This structure is inconsistent with any catastrophic collision, which would have compacted or dispersed most fractals, thus leaving empty most voids in the reassembled nucleus. Comets are less numerous than current estimates, as confirmed by lacking small craters on Pluto and Charon. Bilobate comets accreted at speeds <1 m s−1 from cometesimals born in the same disc stream.
ABSTRACT
When comets approach the Sun, their surface is heated and the volatile species start to sublimate. Due to the increasing gas pressure, dust is ejected off the surface, which can be observed ...as cometary coma, dust tail, and trail. However, the underlying physical processes are not fully understood. Using state-of-the-art results for the transport of heat and gas as well as of the mechanical properties of cometary matter, we intend to describe the activity pattern of comets when they approach the Sun. We developed a novel thermophysical model to simulate the dust ejection from comet 67/Churyumov–Gerasimenko’s south-pole region at perihelion. Based on the input parameters, this model computes the sub-surface temperature profile, the pressure build-up, and the redistribution of volatiles inside the cometary sub-surface region and provides mass-loss rates of dust and gas as well as typical sizes and ice content of the ejected dust chunks. Our thermophysical model allows for continuous gas and dust ejection from the Southern hemisphere of comet 67/Churyumov–Gerasimenko at perihelion. We find that the model output is in general agreement with the observed Rosetta data. The sublimation of CO2 ice drives the ejection of very large ($\gtrsim 10\, \mathrm{cm}$) chunks, which contain $10\, {{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ to $90 \, {{\ \rm per\ cent}}$ of the initial water–ice content. In contrast, the outgassing of H2O ice causes the lift-off of small clusters of dust aggregates, which contain no ice.
Abstract
Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko (67P hereinafter) is characterized by a dust transfer from the southern hemi-nucleus to the night-side northern dust deposits, which constrains the ...dust-to-ices mass ratio inside the nucleus to values a factor of 2 larger than that provided by the lost mass of gas and non-volatiles. This applies to all comets because the gas density in all night comae cannot prevent the dust fallback. Taking into account Grain Impact Analyser and Dust Accumulator (GIADA) data collected during the entire Rosetta mission, we update the average dust bulk density to $\rho {}{}_{\rm D} = 785_{-115}^{+520}$ kg m−3 that, coupled to the 67P nucleus bulk density, confirms an average dust-to-ices mass ratio δ = 7.5 inside 67P. The improved dust densities are consistent with a mixture of (20 ± 8) per cent of ices, (4 ± 1) per cent of Fe sulphides, (22 ± 2) per cent of silicates and (54 ± 5) per cent of hydrocarbons, on average volume abundances. These values correspond to solar chemical abundances, as suggested by the elemental C/Fe ratio observed in 67P. The ice content in 67P matches that inferred in Kuiper belt objects, (20 ± 12) per cent on average volume abundance and suggests a water content in all trans-Neptunian objects lower than in CI chondrites. The 67P icy pebbles and the dust collected by GIADA have a microporosity of (49 ± 5) and (59 ± 8) per cent, respectively.
Context.
An open question in the study of comets is the so-called cohesion bottleneck, that is, how dust particles detach from the nucleus.
Aims.
We test whether the CO pressure buildup inside the ...pebbles of which cometary nuclei consist can overcome this cohesion bottleneck.
Methods.
A recently developed pebble-diffusion model was applied here to comet C/2017K2 PANSTARRS, assuming a CO-driven activity.
Results.
(i) The CO-gas pressure inside the pebbles erodes the nucleus into the observed dust, which is composed of refractories, H
2
O ice and CO
2
ice. (ii) The CO-driven activity onset occurs up to heliocentric distances of 85 au, depending on the spin orientation of the comet nucleus. (iii) The activity onset observed at ≈26 au suggests a low obliquity of the nucleus spin axis with activity in a polar summer. (iv) At 14 au, the smallest size of the ejected dust is ≈0.1 mm, consistent with observations. (v) The observed dust-loss rate of ≈200 kg s
−1
implies a fallout ≥30%, a nucleus surface active area ≥10 km
2
, a CO-gas loss rate ≥10 kg s
−1
, and a dust-to-gas ratio ≤20. (vi) The CO-driven activity never stops if the average refractory-to-all-ices mass ratio in the nucleus is ≤4.5 for a nucleus all-ices-to-CO mass ratio ≈4, as observed in comets Hale–Bopp and Hyakutake. These results make comet C/2017K2 similar to the Rosetta target comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko. (vii) The erosion lifetime of cometary planetesimals is a factor 10
3
shorter than the timescale of catastrophic collisions. This means that the comets we observe today cannot be products of catastrophic collisions.
How Comets Work Fulle, M.; Blum, J.; Rotundi, A.
Astrophysical journal. Letters,
07/2019, Volume:
879, Issue:
1
Journal Article
Peer reviewed
Open access
Two major questions regarding comets have been up to now far from any solution. (i) How is it possible that water-ice sublimation from the nucleus surface does not lead to an insulating crust, ...stopping every gas and dust ejection within a few days? (ii) How is it possible that the gas flow crossing the refractory surface crust ejects dust particles bonded by tensile strengths larger than tens of Pa when the perihelion gas pressure at the nucleus-coma interface is less than one Pa? We have developed a simple but rigorous analytical model, assuming that the cometary nucleus consists of agglomerates of ice and dust ("clusters"). As soon as the clusters become exposed to sunlight, gas diffusion from their inside leads to their dehydration. We find that (i) the gas diffusing from the interior to the surface of a sunlit cluster has a steep density gradient at the cluster surface, which blasts the cluster into particles of sizes larger than or equal to those actually observed by Rosetta dust instruments; (ii) the heat-conduction and diffusion timescales are much shorter than the dehydration timescale, ensuring that the described process prevents any dumping of the nucleus activity driven by water-ice sublimation from 4 au inbound to 4 au outbound; and (iii) the clusters are in fact cm-sized pebbles, so that a cometary nucleus made of pebbles is confirmed to be the only one consistent with cometary gas and dust activity, a process unexplained until now.
Before Rosetta, the space missions Giotto and Stardust shaped our view on cometary dust, supported by plentiful data from Earth based observations and interplanetary dust particles collected in the ...Earth’s atmosphere. The Rosetta mission at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko was equipped with a multitude of instruments designed to study cometary dust. While an abundant amount of data was presented in several individual papers, many focused on a dedicated measurement or topic. Different instruments, methods, and data sources provide different measurement parameters and potentially introduce different biases. This can be an advantage if the complementary aspect of such a complex data set can be exploited. However, it also poses a challenge in the comparison of results in the first place. The aim of this work therefore is to summarize dust results from Rosetta and before. We establish a simple classification as a common framework for intercomparison. This classification is based on the dust particle structure, porosity, and strength and also on its size. Depending on the instrumentation, these are not direct measurement parameters, but we chose them because they were the most reliable for deriving our model. The proposed classification has proved helpful in the Rosetta dust community, and we offer it here also for a broader context. In this manner, we hope to better identify synergies between different instruments and methods in the future.
We performed a stereo-photogrammetric (SPG) analysis of more than 1500 Rosetta/OSIRIS NAC images of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko (67P). The images with pixel scales in the range 0.2−3.0 m/pixel ...were acquired between August 2014 and February 2016. We finally derived a global high-resolution 3D description of 67P’s surface, the SPG SHAP7 shape model. It consists of about 44 million facets (1−1.5 m horizontal sampling) and a typical vertical accuracy at the decimeter scale. Although some images were taken after perihelion, the SPG SHAP7 shape model can be considered a pre-periheliondescription and replaces the previous SPG SHAP4S shape model. From the new shape model, some measures for 67P with very low 3σ uncertainties can be retrieved: 18.56 km3 ± 0.02 km3 for the volume and 537.8 kg/m3 ± 0.7 kg/m3 for the mean density assuming a mass value of 9.982 × 1012 kg.
•We derived a global 3D shape model and the rotational parameters of comet 67P/C-G from high-resolution visible images collected aboard the Rosetta spacecraft.•Using this model, we could calculate ...accurate nucleus parameters including a volume of 18.8 ± 0.3 km3 and a density of 532 ± 7 kg m−3.•We could also retrieve the shape and the geometry of the two lobes using computer graphics tools.•A slight excitation of the spin state was detected, with a precession period of 11.5 ± 0.5 day.•The coordinates of the spin axis indicates a slight inhomogeneity of the density distribution.
The Rosetta spacecraft reached Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko (hereafter 67P/C-G) in August 2014 at an heliocentric distance of 3.6 a.u. and was then put in orbit around its nucleus to perform detailed observations. Among the collected data are the images acquired by the OSIRIS instrument up to the perihelion passage of the comet in August 2015, which allowed us to map the entire nucleus surface at high-resolution in the visible. Stereophotoclinometry methods have been used to reconstruct a global high-resolution shape model and to monitor its rotational parameters using data collected up to perihelion.
The nucleus has a conspicuous bilobate shape with overall dimensions along its principal axes of (4.34 ± 0.02) × (2.60 ± 0.02) × (2.12 ± 0.06) km. The best-fit ellipsoid dimensions of the individual lobes along their principal axes of inertia are found to be 4.10 × 3.52 × 1.63 km and 2.50 × 2.14 × 1.64 km. Their volume amounts to 66% and 27% of the total volume of the nucleus. The two lobes are connected by a “neck” whose volume has been estimated to represent ∼7% of the total volume of the comet. Combining the derived volume of 18.8 ± 0.3 km3 with the mass of 9.982 ± 0.003 × 1012 kg determined by the Rosetta/RSI experiment, we obtained a bulk density of the nucleus of 532±7kgm−3. Together with the companion value of 535±35kgm−3 deduced from the stereophotogrammetry shape model of the nucleus (Preusker et al. 2015 Astron. Astrophys. 583, A33), these constitute the first reliable and most accurate determination of the density of a cometary nucleus to date. The calculated porosity is quite large, ranging approximately from 70% to 75% depending upon the assumed density of the dust grains and the dust-to-ice mass ratio. The nature of the porosity, either micro or macro or both, remains unconstrained. The coordinates of the center of gravity are not compatible with a uniform nucleus density. The direction of the offset between the center of gravity and the center of figure suggests that the big lobe has a slightly higher bulk density compared to the small one. the center of mass position cannot be explained by different, but homogenous densities in the two lobes.
The initial rotational period of 12.4041 ± 0.0001 h of the nucleus persisted until October 2014. It then slightly increased to a maximum of 12.4304 h reached on 19 May 2015 and finally dropped to 12.305 h just before perihelion on August 10, 2015. A periodogram analysis of the (RA, Dec) direction of the Z-axis of the comet obtained in parallel with the shape reconstruction exhibits a highly significant minima at 11.5 ± 0.5 day clearly indicating an excited rotational state with an amplitude of 0.15 ± 0.03°.
•The spherical particles have the smallest maximum liftable size and therefore a model based on this approximation should under-populate the large size bins of the dust size distribution.•The ...difference in grain shape leads to velocity dispersion in space.•The difference in initial grain orientation, even for grains of the same shape, leads to velocity dispersion in space.•The aspherical particles make periodic motion which may change the observable cross-section of the grains.
In-situ measurements of individual dust grain parameters in the immediate vicinity of a cometary nucleus are being carried by the Rosetta spacecraft at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko. For the interpretations of these observational data, a model of dust grain motion as realistic as possible is requested. In particular, the results of the Stardust mission and analysis of samples of interplanetary dust have shown that these particles are highly aspherical, which should be taken into account in any credible model. The aim of the present work is to study the dynamics of ellipsoidal shape particles with various aspect ratios introduced in a spherically symmetric expanding gas flow and to reveal the possible differences in dynamics between spherical and aspherical particles. Their translational and rotational motion under influence of the gravity and of the aerodynamic force and torque is numerically integrated in a wide range of physical parameters values including those of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko. The main distinctions of the dynamics of spherical and ellipsoidal particles are discussed. The aerodynamic characteristics of the ellipsoidal particles, and examples of their translational and rotational motion in the postulated gas flow are presented.
Aims.
Comet C/2020 F3 (NEOWISE) is considered to be the brightest comet observed in the northern hemisphere since the passage of comet C/1995 O1 (Hale-Bopp) in 1997. Since the study of comets offers ...a unique opportunity to investigate the early stages of the formation and evolution of our Sun and the Solar System, we obtained high-resolution optical spectra (
R
=
λ
/Δ
λ
= 11 5000) of comet NEOWISE. The unique passage and its brightness yielded spectra with a large number of emission lines, providing information on the coma composition and the physical and chemical processes occurring in the nucleus. The spectra have been used to generate a catalog of emission lines to be used for future studies of comets since there are no catalogs in the literature with such a high spectral resolution.
Methods.
Two high-resolution spectra of comet NEOWISE were obtained, on 26 July 2020 (geocentric distance of 0.7 AU) and 5 August 2020 (geocentric distance of 0.89 AU), with the High Accuracy Radial velocity Planet Searcher for the Northern hemisphere (HARPS-N) echelle spectrograph installed on the 360 cm Telescopio Nazionale
Galileo
. The spectra cover the range between 383 and 693 nm, and have been extracted using the HARPS-N Data Reduction Pipeline. To analyze the spectra and compile the high-resolution catalog, we collected several laboratory molecular line lists that cover the same wavelength range as that of our spectra. To validate the final identification, we compared our catalog with other atlases that resulted from the spectral analysis of other comets.
Results.
We generate a high-spectral-resolution catalog of emission lines observed in comet NEOWISE, providing the identification for 4488 lines. We found cometary lines due to CN, CH, C
2
, C
3
, and NH
2
and atomic lines due to NaI and OI.
PDF
