Formation of aberrant protein conformers is a common pathological denominator of different neurodegenerative disorders, such as Alzheimer's disease or prion diseases. Moreover, increasing evidence indicates that soluble oligomers are associated with early pathological alterations and that oligomeric assemblies of different disease‐associated proteins may share common structural features. Previous studies revealed that toxic effects of the scrapie prion protein (PrPSc), a β‐sheet‐rich isoform of the cellular PrP (PrPC), are dependent on neuronal expression of PrPC. In this study, we demonstrate that PrPC has a more general effect in mediating neurotoxic signalling by sensitizing cells to toxic effects of various β‐sheet‐rich (β) conformers of completely different origins, formed by (i) heterologous PrP, (ii) amyloid β‐peptide, (iii) yeast prion proteins or (iv) designed β‐peptides. Toxic signalling via PrPC requires the intrinsically disordered N‐terminal domain (N‐PrP) and the GPI anchor of PrP. We found that the N‐terminal domain is important for mediating the interaction of PrPC with β‐conformers. Interestingly, a secreted version of N‐PrP associated with β‐conformers and antagonized their toxic signalling via PrPC. Moreover, PrPC‐mediated toxic signalling could be blocked by an NMDA receptor antagonist or an oligomer‐specific antibody. Our study indicates that PrPC can mediate toxic signalling of various β‐sheet‐rich conformers independent of infectious prion propagation, suggesting a pathophysiological role of the prion protein beyond of prion diseases. PrPC can interact with and mediate toxic signalling of misfolded β‐sheet‐rich oligomers of different origin.