Typical high-temperature, short-time (HTST) pasteurization encompasses a lower heat treatment and shorter refrigerated shelf life compared with ultra-pasteurization (UP) achieved by direct steam ...injection (DSI-UP) or indirect heat (IND-UP). A greater understanding of the effect of different heat treatments on flavor and flavor chemistry of milk is required to characterize, understand, and identify the sources of flavors. The objective of this study was to determine the differences in the flavor and volatile compound profiles of milk subjected to HTST, DSI-UP, or IND-UP using sensory and instrumental techniques. Raw skim and raw standardized 2% fat milks (50 L each) were processed in triplicate and pasteurized at 78°C for 15 s (HTST) or 140°C for 2.3 s by DSI-UP or IND-UP. Milks were cooled and stored at 4°C, then analyzed at d 0, 3, 7, and 14. Sensory attributes were determined using a trained panel, and aroma active compounds were evaluated by solid-phase micro-extraction or stir bar sorptive extraction followed by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry, gas chromatography-olfactometry, and gas chromatography-triple quad mass spectrometry. The UP milks had distinct cooked and sulfur flavors compared with HTST milks. The HTST milks had less diversity in aroma active compounds compared with UP milks. Flavor intensity of all milks decreased by d 14 of storage. Aroma active compound profiles were affected by heat treatment and storage time in both skim and 2% milk. High-impact aroma active compounds were hydrogen sulfide, dimethyl trisulfide, and methional in DSI-UP and 2 and 3-methylbutanal, furfural, 2-heptanone, 2-acetyl-1-pyrroline, 2-aminoacetophenone, benzaldehyde, and dimethyl sulfide in IND-UP. These results provide a foundation knowledge of the effect of heat treatments on flavor development and differences in sensory quality of UP milks.
Fluid milk is traditionally pasteurized by high temperature, short time (HTST) pasteurization, which requires heating to at least 72°C for 15 s. Ultra-pasteurization (UP) extends milk shelf life and ...is defined as heating to at least 138°C for 2 s. The UP process can be done by indirect heating (IND) or by direct steam injection (DSI). The influence of these 2 UP methods on milk flavor has not been widely investigated. The objective of this study was to compare the effect of HTST, IND-UP, and DSI-UP on sensory perception of fluid milk. Raw skim and standardized 2% milks were pasteurized at 140°C for 2.3 s by IND or DSI or by HTST (78°C, 15 s) and homogenized at 20.7 MPa. The processed milks were stored in light-shielded opaque high-density polyethylene containers at 4°C and examined by descriptive analysis and microbial analysis on d 3, 7, and 14. Furosine and serum protein denaturation analyses were performed on d 0 and 14 as an indicator of heat treatment. Last, consumer acceptance testing was conducted at d 10, with adults (n = 250) and children (ages 8 to13 y, n = 100) who were self-reported consumers of skim or 2% milk; consumers only received samples for either skim or 2% milk. The entire experiment was repeated in triplicate. Milks treated by HTST had lower cooked flavor than either UP milk. Milks heated by DSI-UP were characterized by sulfur or eggy and cooked flavors, whereas IND-UP milks had higher sweet aromatic and sweet taste compared with DSI-UP milk. Aromatic flavor intensities of all milks decreased across 14 d of storage. Furosine concentrations and serum protein denaturation were highest for the IND treatments, followed by DSI and HTST. Furosine content in both skim and 2% milk increased with time, but the increase was faster in IND-UP skim milk. Adult and child consumers preferred HTST milk over either UP milk, regardless of fat content. Ultra-pasteurization by IND or DSI did not affect consumer acceptance at 10 d postprocessing, but traditional HTST milks were preferred by consumers of all ages.
Our objectives were to determine the effect of fat (skim to whole milk) and protein (3.4%–10.5%) concentration on the sensory and physical properties of milk beverage base that had lactose and other ...low molecular components removed by ultrafiltration (UF). In experiment 1, a matrix of 16 treatments was produced to achieve 4 levels of lactose removal (0%, 30%, 70%, and 97%) at each of 4 fat levels (skim, 1%, 2%, and whole milk). In experiment 2, a matrix of 12 treatments was produced to achieve 4 levels of lactose removal (0%, 30%, 70%, and 97%) at each of 3 protein concentrations (3.4%, 6.5%, and 10.5% protein). Physical and sensory properties of these products were determined. Removal of >95% of milk lactose by UF required a diafiltration volume of approximately 3 times the milk volume. Lactose and low molecular weight solute removal increased whiteness across the range from skim to whole milk while decreasing viscosity and making milk flavor blander. In addition, lactose (and other low molecular weight solute) removal by UF decreased titratable acidity by more than 50% and increased milk pH at 20°C to >7.0. Future work on milk and milk-based beverages with lactose removed by UF needs to focus on interaction of the remaining milk solids with added flavorings, changing casein to whey protein ratio before removal of lactose by UF, and the effect of lactose and low molecular weight solute removal on heat stability, particularly for neutral-pH, shelf-stable milk-based beverages.
Volatile sulfur compounds in ultra-pasteurized (UP) milk are the major contributors to sulfur/burnt and eggy flavors, and these flavors are disliked by consumers. Previous research has established ...distinct differences in flavor profiles of fluid milk processed by high temperature, short time pasteurization (HTST) and UP by direct steam injection (DSI-UP) or indirect heat (IND-UP). An understanding of the contribution of the individual milk proteins to sulfur off-flavors would clarify the source of sulfur flavors in UP milks. The objective of this study was to determine the source of volatile sulfur compounds in fluid milk with a specific focus on the comparison of heat treatment effects on milks by HTST and UP. Formulated skim milks (FSM) were manufactured by blending micellar casein concentrate and serum protein isolate (SPI). Three different caseins as a percentage of true protein (FSM95, FSM80, and FSM60) were formulated to determine the source of sulfur/burnt and eggy flavors. Freshly processed micellar casein concentrate or SPI were blended to achieve a true protein content of about 3.2%. Raw skim milk served as a control. Skim milk and FSM were pasteurized at 78°C for 15 s (HTST) or 140°C for 2.3 s by IND-UP or DSI-UP. The experiment was replicated twice. Sensory properties of milks and FSM were documented by descriptive sensory analysis. Volatile sulfur compounds in milks and FSM were evaluated using solid-phase microextraction followed by gas chromatography-triple quadrupole mass spectrometry combined with a sulfur selective flame photometric detector. The FSM with higher SPI as a percent of true protein had higher sensory sulfur/burnt and eggy flavors along with elevated concentrations of hydrogen sulfide and carbon disulfide compared with skim milk or FSM with lower proportions of SPI. Sulfur compounds including dimethyl sulfide, dimethyl disulfide, dimethyl trisulfide, dimethyl sulfoxide, and methional were not associated with sulfur/burnt and eggy flavors, which suggests that these compounds may not specifically contribute to the sulfur/burnt and eggy off-flavors of UP milks. Sensory panelists found higher overall aroma impact, and cooked, sulfur/burnt, and eggy flavors for DSI-UP, followed by IND-UP and HTST. The combination of sensory and instrumental methods used in the current study effectively identified that milk serum proteins are the source of sulfur compounds in milk, and further confirmed the contribution of hydrogen sulfide and carbon disulfide to eggy and sulfur/burnt flavors, respectively.
Our objectives were to determine the level of milk-derived whey protein (MDWP) removal necessary to achieve no detectable sulfur/eggy flavor in ultrapasteurized fat-free micellar casein concentrate ...(MCC) beverages (6.5% protein) and in the same beverages containing 1 and 2% milk fat. Micellar casein concentrate with 95% MDWP removal was produced from skim milk (50°C) with a 3×, 3-stage ceramic microfiltration (MF) process using 0.1-µm pore size graded permeability membranes (n = 3). In experiment 1, MCC-based beverages at about 6.5% (wt/wt) true protein were formulated at a fat content of 0.15% fat (wt/wt) at 4 different levels of MDWP removal percentages (95.2%, 91.0%, 83.2%, and 69.3%). In experiment 2, a similar series of beverages at 3 MDWP removal percentages (95.2%, 83.2%, and 69.3%) with 0.1, 1, and 2% fat content were produced. The purity (or completeness of removal of whey protein by MF) of MCC was determined by the Kjeldahl method and sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)-PAGE. Sensory properties of beverages were documented by descriptive sensory analysis, and volatile sulfur compounds were evaluated using solid-phase microextraction followed by gas chromatography-triple quadrupole mass spectrometry. The purity of MCC measured by the Kjeldahl method (casein as a percentage of true protein) was higher after thermal treatment than before, whereas MCC purity evaluated by SDS-PAGE was unchanged by heat treatment. The purity of MCC had an effect on the flavor profile of thermally processed beverages at 6.5% protein made with fresh liquid MCC. No sulfur/eggy flavor was detected in MCC beverages when 95% of the MDWP was removed (MCC purity about 93 to 94%) from skim milk by microfiltration at 0.1, 1, and 2% fat. As the fat content of 6.5% protein beverages produced with MCC increased, sulfur/eggy flavor intensity and hydrogen sulfide concentration decreased. However, the effect of increasing milk fat on reducing sulfur/eggy flavor in MCC-based beverages at 6.5% protein was less than that of increasing MDWP removal from MCC. Sulfur off-flavors in neutral-pH dairy protein beverages can be mitigated by use of high-purity MCC or by incorporation of fat in the beverage, or both.
Schools participating in federal meal programs are limited to serving skim or low-fat (≤1%) flavored and unflavored milk. Few studies have directly addressed child perceptions and preferences for ...milk containing different amounts of milkfat. The objective of this study was to determine whether children can differentiate between flavored and unflavored fluid milk containing varying levels of milkfat and whether preferences for certain levels of milkfat exist. Flavored and unflavored milks containing 4 different percentages of milkfat (≤0.5, 1, 2, and 3.25%) were high-temperature, short-time processed, filled into half-gallon light-shielded milk jugs, and stored at 4°C in the dark. Milks were evaluated by children (ages 8–13 yr) following 7 d at 4°C. Acceptance testing and tetrad difference testing were conducted on flavored and unflavored milks with and without visual cues to determine if differences were driven by visual or flavor or mouthfeel cues. Child acceptance testing (n = 138 unflavored; n = 123 flavored) was conducted to evaluate liking and perception of selected attributes. Tetrad testing (n = 127 unflavored; n = 129 flavored) was conducted to determine if children could differentiate between different fat levels even in the absence of a difference in acceptance. The experiment was replicated twice. When visual cues were present, children had higher overall liking for 1% and 2% milks than skim for unflavored milk and higher liking for chocolate milks containing at least 1% milk fat than for skim. Differences in liking were driven by appearance, viscosity, and flavor. In the absence of visual cues, no differences were observed in liking or flavor or mouthfeel attributes for unflavored milk but higher liking for at least 1% milk fat in chocolate milk compared with skim was consistent with the presence of visual cues. From tetrad testing, children could visually tell a difference between all unflavored pairs except 2% versus whole milk and could not detect consistent differences between milkfat pairs in the absence of visual cues. For chocolate milk, children could tell a difference between all milk fat pairs with visual cues and could tell a difference between skim versus 2% and skim versus whole milk without visual cues. These results demonstrate that in the absence of package-related flavors, school-age children like unflavored skim milk as well as milk with higher fat content in the absence of visual cues. In contrast, appearance as well as flavor and mouthfeel attributes play a role in children's liking as well as their ability to discriminate between chocolate milks containing different amounts of fat, with chocolate milk containing at least 1% fat preferred. The sensory quality of school lunch milk is vital to child preference, and processing efforts are needed to maximize school milk sensory quality.
At the onset of lactation, calcium (Ca) homeostasis is challenged. For the transitioning dairy cow, inadequate responses to this challenge may result in subclinical hypocalcemia at some point in the ...postpartum period. It has been proposed that dynamics of blood Ca and the timing of subclinical hypocalcemia allow cows to be classified into 4 Ca dynamic groups by assessing serum total Ca concentrations (tCa) at 1 and 4 days in milk (DIM). These differing dynamics are associated with different risks of adverse health events and suboptimal production. Our prospective cohort study aimed to characterize the temporal patterns of milk constituents in cows with differing Ca dynamics to investigate the potential of Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopic (FTIR) analysis of milk as a diagnostic tool for identifying cows with unfavorable Ca dynamics. We sampled the blood of 343 multiparous Holsteins on a single dairy in Cayuga County, New York, at 1 and 4 DIM and classified these cows into Ca dynamic groups using threshold concentrations of tCa (1 DIM: tCa <1.98 mmol/L; 4 DIM: tCa <2.22 mmol/L) derived from receiver operating characteristic curve analysis based on epidemiologically relevant health and production outcomes. We also collected proportional milk samples from each of these cows from 3 to 10 DIM for FTIR analysis of milk constituents. Through this analysis we estimated the milk constituent levels of anhydrous lactose (g/100 g of milk and g/milking), true protein (g/100 g of milk and g/milking), fat (g/100 g of milk and g/milking), milk urea nitrogen (mg/100 g of milk), fatty acid (FA) groups including de novo, mixed origin, and preformed FA measured in grams/100 g of milk, by relative percentage, and grams/milking, as well as energy-related metabolites including ketone bodies and milk-predicted blood nonesterified FA. Individual milk constituents were compared among groups at each time point and over the entire sample period using linear regression models. Overall, we found differences among the constituent profiles of Ca dynamic groups at approximately every time point and over the entire sample period. The 2 at-risk groups of cows did not differ from each other at more than one time point for any constituent, however prominent differences existed between the milk of normocalcemic cows and the milk of the other Ca dynamic groups with respect to FA. Over the entire sample period, lactose and protein yield (g/milking) were lower in the milk of at-risk cows than in the milk of the other Ca dynamic groups. In addition, milk yield per milking followed patterns consistent with previous Ca dynamic group research. Though our use of a single farm does limit the general applicability of these findings, our conclusions provide evidence that FTIR may be a useful method for discriminating between cows with different Ca dynamics at time points that may be relevant in the optimization of management or development of clinical intervention strategies.
Display omitted
Cows undergo immense physiological stress to produce milk during early lactation. Monitoring early lactation milk through Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy might offer an ...understanding of which cows transition successfully. Daily patterns of milk constituents in early lactation have yet to be reported continuously, and the study objective was to initially describe these patterns for cows of varying parity groups from 3 through 10 d postpartum, piloted on a single dairy. We enrolled 1,024 Holstein cows from a commercial dairy farm in Cayuga County, New York, in an observational study, with a total of 306 parity 1 cows, 274 parity 2 cows, and 444 parity ≥3 cows. Cows were sampled once daily, Monday through Friday, via proportional milk samplers, and milk was stored at 4°C until analysis using FTIR. Estimated constituents included anhydrous lactose, true protein, and fat (g/100 g of milk); relative % (rel%) of total fatty acids (FA) and concentration (g/100 g of milk) of de novo, mixed, and preformed FA; individual fatty acids C16:0, C18:0, and C18:1 cis-9 (g/100 g of milk); milk urea nitrogen (MUN; mg/100 g of milk); and milk acetone (mACE), milk β-hydroxybutyrate (mBHB), and milk-predicted blood nonesterified fatty acids (mpbNEFA) (all expressed in mmol/L). Differences between parity groups were assessed using repeated-measures ANOVA. Milk yield per milking differed over time between 3 and 10 DIM and averaged 8.7, 13.3, and 13.3 kg for parity 1, 2, and ≥3 cows, respectively. Parity differences were found for % anhydrous lactose, % fat, and preformed FA (g/100 g of milk). Parity differed across DIM for % true protein, de novo FA (rel% and g/100 g of milk), mixed FA (rel% and g/100 g of milk), preformed FA rel%, C16:0, C18:0, C18:1 cis-9, MUN, mACE, mBHB, and mpbNEFA. Parity 1 cows had less true protein and greater fat percentages than parity 2 and ≥3 cows (% true protein: 3.52, 3.76, 3.81; % fat: 5.55, 4.69, 4.95, for parity 1, 2, ≥3, respectively). De novo and mixed FA rel% were reduced and preformed FA rel% were increased in primiparous compared with parity 2 and ≥3 cows. The increase in preformed FA rel% in primiparous cows agreed with milk markers of energy deficit, such that mpbNEFA, mBHB, and mACE were greatest in parity 1 cows followed by parity ≥3 cows, with parity 2 cows having the lowest concentrations. When measuring milk constituents with FTIR, these results suggest it is critical to account for parity for the majority of estimated milk constituents. We acknowledge the limitation that this study was conducted on a single farm; however, if FTIR technology is to be used as a method of identifying cows maladapted to lactation, understanding variations in early lactation milk constituents is a crucial first step in the practical adoption of this technology.
This study evaluated the role of protein concentration and milk protein ingredient serum protein isolate (SPI), micellar casein concentrate (MCC), or milk protein concentrate (MPC) on sensory ...properties of vanilla ready-to-drink (RTD) protein beverages. The RTD beverages were manufactured from 5 different liquid milk protein blends: 100% MCC, 100% MPC, 18:82 SPI:MCC, 50:50 SPI:MCC, and 50:50 SPI:MPC, at 2 different protein concentrations: 6.3% and 10.5% (wt/wt) protein (15 or 25 g of protein per 237 mL) with 0.5% (wt/wt) fat and 0.7% (wt/wt) lactose. Dipotassium phosphate, carrageenan, cellulose gum, sucralose, and vanilla flavor were included. Blended beverages were preheated to 60°C, homogenized (20.7 MPa), and cooled to 8°C. The beverages were then preheated to 90°C and ultrapasteurized (141°C, 3 s) by direct steam injection followed by vacuum cooling to 86°C and homogenized again (17.2 MPa first stage, 3.5 MPa second stage). Beverages were cooled to 8°C, filled into sanitized bottles, and stored at 4°C. Initial testing of RTD beverages included proximate analyses and aerobic plate count and coliform count. Volatile sulfur compounds and sensory properties were evaluated through 8-wk storage at 4°C. Astringency and sensory viscosity were higher and vanillin flavor was lower in beverages containing 10.5% protein compared with 6.3% protein, and sulfur/eggy flavor, astringency, and viscosity were higher, and sweet aromatic/vanillin flavor was lower in beverages with higher serum protein as a percentage of true protein within each protein content. Volatile compound analysis of headspace vanillin and sulfur compounds was consistent with sensory results: beverages with 50% serum protein as a percentage of true protein and 10.5% protein had the highest concentrations of sulfur volatiles and lower vanillin compared with other beverages. Sulfur volatiles and vanillin, as well as sulfur/eggy and sweet aromatic/vanillin flavors, decreased in all beverages with storage time. These results will enable manufacturers to select or optimize protein blends to better formulate RTD beverages to provide consumers with a protein beverage with high protein content and desired flavor and functional properties.
Off-flavors in milk related to light oxidation form due to photoxidation of native riboflavin and tetrapyrroles, resulting in an array of lipid oxidation compounds. Recent work has established that ...fortification with water-dispersible vitamin A can result in off-flavors in fluid skim milk caused by vitamin A degradation products in the vitamin premix. The objective of this study was to determine the role of vitamin fortification on light oxidation of high temperature, short time pasteurized fluid skim milk. First, the aroma profiles and aroma-active volatile compounds in light-exposed vitamin premixes were determined by exposing the premixes to fluorescent (FL) or light-emitting diode (LED) light at 2,000 lx at 4°C for 0, 2, 4, 8, or 24 h. A trained panel (n = 6) documented aroma profiles of each vitamin premix at each time point. Headspace solid-phase microextraction followed by gas chromatography-olfactometry and gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) were performed to characterize aroma-active compounds in light-exposed vitamin premixes. In the second experiment, commercial vitamin premixes (vitamin A and vitamin D in oil and water matrices) were used to fortify skim milk (vitamin A: 3,000 IU/946 mL; vitamin D: 600 IU/946 mL). Skim milk was pasteurized, homogenized, and packaged in 946-mL high-density polyethylene jugs. Milks were exposed to FL or LED light at 2,000 lx at 4°C for 4, 12, 24, or 48 h. Controls with and without vitamins and light shielding were included. Riboflavin and vitamin A and D degradation were quantified via ultra-high-performance liquid chromatography. A trained panel (n = 8) documented sensory profiles of milks at each time point. Lipid oxidation volatile compounds were quantified via solid-phase microextraction with GC-MS. Vitamin degradation volatile compounds were quantified via solvent-assisted sorptive stir bar extraction with GC-MS. Riboflavin, vitamin A, and vitamin D degradation were consistent with that reported in previous studies. We found no effect of vitamin fortification on development of typical light oxidation–related off-flavors (cardboard and mushroom) or lipid oxidation–related volatiles (hexanal and heptanal). A perfumey/floral flavor was documented in the oil-based vitamin A-fortified milk, suggesting that light exposure affected the off-flavors contributed by water- versus oil-based vitamin fortification. These results show no evidence that vitamin fortification at current levels provides any protection against light oxidation–related off-flavors in fluid milk.
PDF
