•FLASH radiation dose-rates consume all the local tissue O2 to form reactive organic hydroperoxides.•Fenton type reactions will be limited in normal vs. cancer tissues due to lower levels of labile ...Fe.•Normal tissues are expected to remove organic hydroperoxides more effectively relative to tumor tissues.•Since tumor tissue cannot remove hydroperoxides as effectively, FLASH and conventional dose rate irradiation are more isoefficient at killing tumor cells compared to normal cells.
For decades the field of radiation oncology has sought to improve the therapeutic ratio through innovations in physics, chemistry, and biology. To date, technological advancements in image guided beam delivery techniques have provided clinicians with their best options for improving this critical tool in cancer care. Medical physics has focused on the preferential targeting of tumors while minimizing the collateral dose to the surrounding normal tissues, yielding only incremental progress. However, recent developments involving ultra-high dose rate irradiation termed FLASH radiotherapy (FLASH-RT), that were initiated nearly 50 years ago, have stimulated a renaissance in the field of radiotherapy, long awaiting a breakthrough modality able to enhance therapeutic responses and limit normal tissue injury. Compared to conventional dose rates used clinically (0.1–0.2 Gy/s), FLASH can implement dose rates of electrons or X-rays in excess of 100 Gy/s. The implications of this ultra-fast delivery of dose are significant and need to be re-evaluated to appreciate the fundamental aspects underlying this seemingly unique radiobiology. The capability of FLASH to significantly spare normal tissue complications in multiple animal models, when compared to conventional rates of dose-delivery, while maintaining persistent growth inhibition of select tumor models has generated considerable excitement, as well as skepticism. Based on fundamental principles of radiation physics, radio-chemistry, and tumor vs. normal cell redox metabolism, this article presents a series of testable, biologically relevant hypotheses, which may help rationalize the differential effects of FLASH irradiation observed between normal tissue and tumors.
Iron (Fe) is an essential element that plays a fundamental role in a wide range of cellular functions, including cellular proliferation, DNA synthesis, as well as DNA damage and repair. Because of ...these connections, iron has been strongly implicated in cancer development. Cancer cells frequently have changes in the expression of iron regulatory proteins. For example, cancer cells frequently upregulate transferrin (increasing uptake of iron) and down regulate ferroportin (decreasing efflux of intracellular iron). These changes increase the steady-state level of intracellular redox active iron, known as the labile iron pool (LIP). The LIP typically contains approximately 2% intracellular iron, which primarily exists as ferrous iron (Fe
). The LIP can readily contribute to oxidative distress within the cell through Fe
-dioxygen and Fenton chemistries, generating the highly reactive hydroxyl radical (HO
). Due to the reactive nature of the LIP, it can contribute to increased DNA damage. Mitochondrial dysfunction in cancer cells results in increased steady-state levels of hydrogen peroxide and superoxide along with other downstream reactive oxygen species. The increased presence of H
O
and O
can increase the LIP, contributing to increased mitochondrial uptake of iron as well as genetic instability. Thus, iron metabolism and labile iron pools may play a central role connecting the genetic mutational theories of cancer to the metabolic theories of cancer.
Polyoxometalate nanoparticles (POMs) are a class of compounds made up of multiple transition metals linked together using oxygen atoms. POMs commonly include group 6 transition metals, with two of ...the most common forms using molybdenum and tungsten. POMs are suggested to exhibit antimicrobial effects. In this study, we developed two POM preparations to study anti-cancer activity. We found that Mo-POM (NH
)Mo
O
) and W-POM (H
PW
O
) have anti-cancer effects on glioblastoma cells. Both POMs induced morphological changes marked by membrane swelling and the presence of multinucleated cells that may indicate apoptosis induction along with impaired cell division. We also observed significant increases in lipid oxidation events, suggesting that POMs are redox-active and can catalyze detrimental oxidation events in glioblastoma cells. Here, we present preliminary indications that molybdenum polyoxometalate nanoparticles may act like ferrous iron to catalyze the oxidation of phospholipids. These preliminary results suggest that Mo-POMs (NH
)Mo
O
) and W-POMs (H
PW
O
) may warrant further investigation into their utility as adjunct cancer therapies.
Glioblastoma (GBM), a highly lethal and aggressive central nervous system malignancy, presents a critical need for targeted therapeutic approaches to improve patient outcomes in conjunction with ...standard-of-care (SOC) treatment. Molecular subtyping based on genetic profiles and metabolic characteristics has advanced our understanding of GBM to better predict its evolution, mechanisms, and treatment regimens. Pharmacological ascorbate (P-AscH−) has emerged as a promising supplementary cancer therapy, leveraging its pro-oxidant properties to selectively kill malignant cells when combined with SOC. Given the clinical challenges posed by the heterogeneity and resistance of various GBM subtypes to conventional SOC, our study assessed the response of classical, mesenchymal, and proneural GBM to P-AscH−. P-AscH− (20 pmol/cell) combined with SOC (5 µM temozolomide and 4 Gy of radiation) enhanced clonogenic cell killing in classical and mesenchymal GBM subtypes, with limited effects in the proneural subtype. Similarly, following exposure to P-AscH− (20 pmol/cell), single-strand DNA damage significantly increased in classical and mesenchymal but not proneural GBM. Moreover, proneural GBM exhibited increased hydrogen peroxide removal rates, along with increased catalase and glutathione peroxidase activities compared to mesenchymal and classical GBM, demonstrating an altered H2O2 metabolism that potentially drives differential P-AscH− toxicity. Taken together, these data suggest that P-AscH− may hold promise as an approach to improve SOC responsiveness in mesenchymal GBMs that are known for their resistance to SOC.
Abstract
Ferumoxytol (FMX) is an iron oxide nanoparticle that is FDA approved for the treatment of iron deficiency anemia. FMX contains an Fe3O4 core. Currently, the redox chemistry of Fe3O4 ...nanoparticles remains relatively unexplored. FMX has recently gained interest as an anti-cancer agent. Ionizing radiation (IR) is a treatment modality employed to treat several types of cancer. Utilizing electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy, we found that the products produced from the radiolysis of water can oxidize the Fe3O4 core of FMX. Because of the limited diffusion of the HO2• and HO• produced, these highly oxidizing species have little direct effect on FMX oxidation. We have determined that H2O2 is the primary oxidant of FMX. In the presence of labile Fe2+, we found that reducing species generated from the radiolysis of H2O are able to reduce the Fe3+ sites of the Fe3O4 core. Importantly, we also have shown that IR stimulates the release of ferric iron from FMX. Because of its release of iron, FMX may serve as an adjuvant to enhance radiotherapy.
Cancer cells preferentially accumulate iron (Fe) relative to non-malignant cells; however, the underlying rationale remains elusive. Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) clusters are critical cofactors that aid in a ...wide variety of cellular functions (e.g., DNA metabolism and electron transport). In this article, we theorize that a differential need for Fe-S biogenesis in tumor versus non-malignant cells underlies the Fe-dependent cell growth demand of cancer cells to promote cell division and survival by promoting genomic stability via Fe-S containing DNA metabolic enzymes. In this review, we outline the complex Fe-S biogenesis process and its potential upregulation in cancer. We also discuss three therapeutic strategies to target Fe-S biogenesis: (i) redox manipulation, (ii) Fe chelation, and (iii) Fe mimicry.
Cancer cells frequently present elevated intracellular iron levels, which are thought to facilitate an enhanced proliferative capacity. Targeting iron metabolism within cancer cells presents an ...avenue to enhance therapeutic responses, necessitating the use of non-invasive models to modulate iron manipulation to predict responses. Moreover, the ubiquitous nature of iron necessitates the development of unique, non-invasive markers of metabolic disruptions to develop more personalized approaches and enhance the clinical utility of these approaches. Ferritin, an iron storage enzyme that is often upregulated as a response to iron accumulation, plays a central role in iron metabolism and has been frequently associated with unfavorable clinical outcomes in cancer. Herein, we demonstrate the successful utility, validation, and functionality of a doxycycline-inducible ferritin heavy chain (FtH) overexpression model in H1299T non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) cells. Treatment with doxycycline increased the protein expression of FtH with a corresponding decrease in labile iron in vitro and in vivo, as determined by calcein-AM staining and EPR, respectively. Moreover, a subsequent increase in TfR expression was observed. Furthermore, T
* MR mapping effectively detected FtH expression in our in vivo model. These results demonstrate that T
* relaxation times can be used to monitor changes in FtH expression in tumors with bidirectional correlations depending on the model system. Overall, this study describes the development of an FtH overexpression NSCLC model and its correlation with T
* mapping for potential use in patients to interrogate iron metabolic alterations and predict clinical outcomes.
The majority of colorectal cancers are resistant to cancer immune checkpoint inhibitors. Ionizing radiation (IR) and several radiosensitizers, including PARP inhibitors, can enhance responsiveness to ...immune checkpoint inhibitors by potentially complementary mechanisms of action. We assessed the ability of radiation and PARP inhibition to induce proimmunogenic changes in tumor cells and enhance their in vivo responsiveness to anti-PD-1 antibodies.
We performed a candidate drug screen and used flow cytometry to assess effects of the PARP inhibitor veliparib on IR-mediated changes in MHC-1 antigen presentation and surface localization of immune-modulating proteins including PD-L1 and calreticulin in colorectal cancer tumor models. Reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction was used to assess the effects of veliparib and radiation on the expression of proinflammatory and immunosuppressive cytokines. The ability of concurrent PARP inhibition and subablative doses of radiation therapy to enhance in vivo responsiveness to anti-PD-1 antibodies was assessed using unilateral flank-tumor models with or without T-cell depletion.
Veliparib was a potent radiosensitizer in both cell lines. Radiation increased surface localization of MHC-1 and PD-L1 in a dose-dependent manner, and veliparib pretreatment significantly enhanced these effects with high (8 Gy) but not with lower radiation doses. Enhancement of MHC-1 and PD-L1 surface localization by IR and IR+ veliparib remained significant 1, 3, and 7 days after treatment. IR significantly increased delayed tumoral expression of proinflammatory cytokines interferon-Ƴ and CXCL10 but had no significant effect on the expression of IL-6 or TGF-β. Concurrent administration of veliparib and subablative radiation therapy (8 Gy × 2) significantly prolonged anti-PD-1-mediated in vivo tumor growth delay and survival in both tumor models. Moreover, these effects were more pronounced in the microsatellite instability-mutated MC38 tumor model. Enhancement of anti-PD-1 mediated tumor growth delay with veliparib and IR was attenuated by CD8+ T-cell depletion.
We provide preclinical evidence for a novel therapeutic strategy to enhance responsiveness of colorectal tumors to immune checkpoint inhibitors.
Interest in the use of pharmacological ascorbate as a treatment for cancer has increased considerably since it was introduced by Cameron and Pauling in the 1970s. Recently, pharmacological ascorbate ...has been used in preclinical and early-phase clinical trials as a selective radiation sensitizer in cancer. The results of these studies are promising. This review summarizes data on pharmacological ascorbate (1) as a safe and efficacious adjuvant to cancer therapy; (2) as a selective radiosensitizer of cancer via a mechanism involving hydrogen peroxide; and (3) as a radioprotector in normal tissues. Additionally, we present new data demonstrating the ability of pharmacological ascorbate to enhance radiation-induced DNA damage in glioblastoma cells, facilitating cancer cell death. We propose that pharmacological ascorbate may be a general radiosensitizer in cancer therapy and simultaneously a radioprotector of normal tissue.
A distinctive feature of cancer is the upregulation of sirtuin proteins. Sirtuins are class III NAD+-dependent deacetylases involved in cellular processes such as proliferation and protection against ...oxidative stress. SIRTs 1 and 2 are also overexpressed in several types of cancers including non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). Sirtinol, a sirtuin (SIRT) 1 and 2 specific inhibitor, is a recent anti-cancer agent that is cytotoxic against several types of cancers including NSCLC. Thus, sirtuins 1 and 2 represent valuable targets for cancer therapy. Recent studies show that sirtinol functions as a tridentate iron chelator by binding Fe3+ with 3:1 stoichiometry. However, the biological consequences of this function remain unexplored. Consistent with preliminary literature, we show that sirtinol can deplete intracellular labile iron pools in both A549 and H1299 non-small cell lung cancer cells acutely. Interestingly, a temporal adaptive response occurs in A549 cells as sirtinol enhances transferrin receptor stability and represses ferritin heavy chain translation through impaired aconitase activity and apparent IRP1 activation. This effect was not observed in H1299 cells. Holo-transferrin supplementation significantly enhanced colony formation in A549 cells while increasing sirtinol toxicity. This effect was not observed in H1299 cells. The results highlight the fundamental genetic differences that may exist between H1299 and A549 cells and offer a novel mechanism of how sirtinol kills NSCLC cells.
PDF
