The need to identify a missing person (MP) through kinship analysis of DNA samples found at a crime scene has become increasingly prevalent. DNA samples from MPs can be severely degraded, contain ...little DNA and mixed with other contributors, which often makes it difficult to apply conventional methods in practice. This study developed a massively parallel sequencing-based panel that contains 1661 single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) with low minor allele frequencies (MAFs) (averaged at 0.0613) in the Chinese Han population, and the strategy for relationship inference from DNA mixtures comprising different numbers of contributors (NOCs) and of varying allele dropout probabilities. Based on the simulated dataset and genotyping results of 42 artificial DNA mixtures (NOC = 2-4), it was observed that the present SNP panel was sufficient for balanced mixtures when referenced to the closest relatives (parents/offspring and full siblings). When the mixture profiles suffered from dropout, incorrect assignments were markedly associated with relatedness, NOC and the dropout level. We, therefore, indicate that SNPs with low MAFs could be reliably interpreted for MP identification through the kinship analysis of complex DNA mixtures. Further studies should be extended to more possible scenarios to test the feasibility of this present approach.
•DNA quantity and STR typing success of 48 bone types in three WWII skeletons differed by anatomical region but not by skeleton.•Metatarsals, metacarpals, and petrous bones outperformed all other ...bone types in DNA quantity and quality.•The ten highest-yielding bone types differed from skeleton to skeleton.•The third metacarpal yielding the highest DNA concentration in all three skeletons.•The data obtained have implications for skeletal sampling from old and highly degraded skeletal remains.
DNA yield varies by anatomical region, and the selection of bone types that yield maximum recovery of DNA is important to maximize the success of human identification of skeletal remains. The goal of our study was to explore inter- and intra-individual variation in DNA content by measuring nuclear DNA quantity and quality and autosomal STR typing success to determine the most promising skeletal elements for bone sampling. To exclude the influence of taphonomic issues as much as possible, three complete male skeletons from a single Second World War mass grave were examined and all representative skeletal element types of the human body were analyzed. Forty-eight different types of bones from the head, torso, arm, leg, hand, and foot were sampled from each skeleton, 144 bones altogether. The samples were cleaned, and half a gram of bone powder was decalcified using a full demineralization extraction method. The DNA was purified in a Biorobot EZ1 (Qiagen). DNA content and rates of DNA degradation were determined with the PowerQuant (Promega), and the Investigator ESSplex SE QS (Qiagen) was used for STR typing. The highest-yielding bones mostly produced the most complete STR profiles. Among the skeletal elements containing on average the most DNA and producing the most complete profiles in all three skeletons examined were metacarpals, metatarsals, and the petrous portion of the temporal bone. Metatarsals and metacarpals can easily be sampled without using a saw, thus reducing potential DNA contamination. Skeletons from the Second World War can be used as a model for poorly preserved skeletal remains, and the results of the investigation can be applied for genetic identification of highly degraded skeletal remains in routine forensic casework. Although the research was limited to only three skeletons found in a unique mass grave, the data obtained could contribute to sampling strategies for identifying old skeletal remains. More Second World War skeletons will be analyzed in the future to investigate inter-bone variation in the preservation of DNA.
An efficient extraction method is important for obtaining high-quality DNA from degraded aged bone samples. An automated full-demineralization method using the EDTA and DNA Investigator Kit (Qiagen) ...combined with Qiagen’s biorobots was optimized in our laboratory in the past to extract the DNA from 500 mg of aged bone samples. The purpose of this research was to further improve the method with the aim of reducing the required sample material, shortening the extraction time, and achieving higher throughput. To process extremely small samples, the amount of bone powder was reduced to 75 mg, EDTA was replaced with reagents from the Bone DNA Extraction Kit (Promega), and decalcification was shortened from overnight to 2.5 h. Instead of 50 ml tubes, 2 ml tubes were used, which allows higher throughput. The DNA Investigator Kit (Qiagen) and EZ1 Advanced XL biorobot (Qiagen) was used for DNA purification. A comparison between both extraction methods was made on 29 Second World War bones and 22 archaeological bone samples. The differences between both methods were explored by measuring nuclear DNA yield and STR typing success. After cleaning the samples, 500 mg of bone powder was processed using EDTA, and 75 mg of powder from the same bone was processed using the Bone DNA Extraction Kit (Promega). DNA content and DNA degradation were determined using PowerQuant (Promega), and the PowerPlex ESI 17 Fast System (Promega) was used for STR typing. The results showed that the full-demineralization protocol using 500 mg of bone was efficient for Second World War and archaeological samples, and the partial-demineralization protocol using 75 mg of bone powder was only efficient for the Second World War bones. The improved extraction method—for which significantly lower amounts of bone powder can be used, the extraction process is faster, and higher throughput of bone samples is possible—is applicable for genetic identification of relatively well-preserved aged bone samples in routine forensic analyses.
•Identification of small bone samples requires an efficient DNA extraction method.•Full demineralization of 500 mg of bone and partial demineralization of 75 mg were compared.•WWII and archaeological bones were used for analysis.•The full-demineralization method was efficient for WWII and archaeological bones.•The partial-demineralization method was efficient only for WWII bones.
Missing person cases typically require a genetic kinship test to determine the relationship between an unidentified individual and the relatives of the missing person. When not enough genetic ...evidence has been collected the lack of statistical power of these tests might lead to unreliable results. This is particularly true when just a few distant relatives are available for genotyping. In this contribution, we considered a Bayesian network approach for kinship testing and proposed several information theoretic metrics in order to quantitatively evaluate the information content of pedigrees. We show how these statistics are related to the widely used likelihood ratio values and could be employed to efficiently prioritize family members in order to optimize the statistical power in missing person problems. Our methodology seamlessly integrates with Bayesian modeling approaches, like the GENis platform that we have recently developed for high-throughput missing person identification tasks. Furthermore, our approach can also be easily incorporated into Elston-Stewart forensic frameworks. To facilitate the application of our methodology, we have developed the forensIT package, freely available on CRAN repository, which implements all the methodologies described in our manuscript.
•We introduced IT metrics to quantify relationship informativeness in familial pedigrees.•IT metrics allow selection of key DNA contributors in missing person cases.•Our method uses advanced algorithms for fast, large-scale kinship analysis.•IT metrics aid to deal with null exclusion-power contributors, when usual methods fail.•Core functionality implemented in open source forensIT R package, available on CRAN.
•The identification of skeletal remains in mass graves is performed by STR typing.•Conventional PCR/CE analysis is limited by DNA degradation.•PCR/MPS of bone samples produces reliable molecular ...data.•PCR/MPS of bone samples allows genetic profiles.•The combined use of PCR/CE and PCR/MPS technologies improves results.
The genetic identification of skeletal remains found in Second World War mass graves is complicated because of the poor quality of the samples. The aim of this study was to set up a workflow for STR typing of such samples combining PCR/CE and PCR/NGS technologies. To this end, 57 DNA samples from an equal number of 75-year-old femurs were studied. After a first round of PCR typing using GlobalFiler CE, 42 samples yielded a full profile and were therefore submitted to our standard workflow. The 15 samples that yielded no or a limited number (2–17/21) of autosomal STR markers as well four bone control samples that provided a full profile with the conventional PCR/CE test were typed in duplicate by the GlobalFiler NGS kit. Despite the degradation of the samples, which resulted in lower coverage and a lower % of on-target reads, reliable sequencing data were obtained from 16/19 samples. The use of a threshold of 30× for the locus call led to a consensus profile (cp) of 20–31/31 STR autosomal loci in 10 samples and to a cp of 8–10/31 loci in two samples, whereas the four control samples yielded a cp of 26–31/31 loci. Finally, the data of the NGS typing were combined with those of the CE typing. This last task allowed us to recover (on average) three alleles per sample and to increase the number of the heterozygous patterns in 37 cases. In total, the combined approach proposed here made possible the genetic typing of 65–100% of the autosomal STR markers in 10/15 (66.6 %) skeletal remains that yielded no or very poor results with the conventional PCR/CE approach. However, because several artefacts (such as allelic drop-out and allelic drop-in) were scored, the risk of mistyping cannot be neglected.
Display omitted
•Methods for selecting relatives most informative for genotyping.•Estimates of inclusion and exclusion power are obtained by conditional simulation.•Tailor-made power plots aid ...interpretation and decision making.•Examples based on unsolved cases of “Missing grandchildren of Argentina”.•All methods are freely available in the R package forrel.
Missing person identification typically involves genetic matching of a person of interest against relatives of the missing person. In cases with few available relatives, exhumations or other substantial efforts may be necessary in order to secure adequate statistical power. We propose a simulation approach for solving prioritisation problems arising in such cases. Conditioning on the already typed individuals we estimate the power of each alternative, both to detect the true person, and to exclude false candidates. Graphical summaries of the simulations are given in complementary power plots, facilitating interpretation and decision making. Through a series of examples originating from the well-known Missing grandchildren of Argentina we demonstrate that our method may untangle complex prioritisation problems and other power-related questions. In particular we offer novel insights in recent cases where only children of the potential match are available for testing. We also show that X-chromosomal markers may give high statistical power in missing person identification, but that this requires careful selection of relatives for genotyping. All simulations, power calculations and plots are done with the R package forrel.
Studies evaluating DNA preservation in non-adults, or comparing preservation in adults and non-adults, are very rare. This study compares the preservation of DNA in the skeletal remains of adults and ...non-adults. It compares the quality and quantity of DNA recovered from different skeletal elements of adults and non-adults, and from non-adults of different age classes. In addition, the preservation of DNA in males and females is compared. Bone DNA preservation was estimated by measuring nuclear DNA concentration and its degradation, and through STR typing success. The study analyzed 29 adult skeletons and 23 non-adult skeletons from the Ljubljana–Polje archeological site, dating from the seventeenth to nineteenth century, and up to four skeletal elements (petrous bone, femur, calcaneus, and talus) were included. After full demineralization extraction, the PowerQuant System and the PowerPlex ESI 17 Fast System (Promega) were used for qPCR and STR typing, respectively. The results showed that, among the four bone types analyzed, only the petrous bone proved to be a suitable source of DNA for STR typing of non-adult skeletal remains, and DNA yield is even higher than in the adult petrous bone, which can be attributed to the higher DNA degradation observed in the adult petrous bone. In adult skeletons, petrous bones and tali produced high STR amplification success and low DNA yield was observed in adult femurs. The results of this study are applicable for the sampling strategy in routine forensic genetics cases for solving identification cases, including badly preserved non-adult and also adult skeletons.
Highlights
• Comparison between adult and non-adult skeletons is poorly researched.
• Petrous bones, tali, calcanei, and femurs were analyzed.
• Petrous bones produced higher DNA yield in non-adult than adult skeletons.
• DNA degradation was higher in adult than non-adult petrous bones.
• Petrous bones are the most suitable skeletal element for sampling aged non-adult skeletons.
• In adult skeletons alongside the petrous bone the talus also produced high-quality STR profiles.
Display omitted
•Whole-genome sequencing was performed on human remains.•Genotypes for 1 million SNPs were established.•The SNP data was used for searching in a genealogy DNA database.•A list of ...possible relatives to the unknown individual was obtained from the search.
Recently a number of high profile crime cases (e.g. the “Golden State Killer”) have successfully been solved or given new leads with the use of genome wide DNA data in combination with pairwise matching from individuals present in genealogy DNA databases. Such databases will primarily involve distant relatives which in turn require a large amount of genetic information, in the range of several hundred thousand to millions of SNPs, to be genotyped. While it nowadays is fairly straightforward to obtain such as data from high quality and high quantity DNA, it is still a challenge for degraded DNA of low quantity such in the case of forensic samples. Here we present a successful effort in obtaining genome-wide genotype data from human remains. The goal was to get investigative leads in order to identify the remains of an unknown male (“the Ekeby man”) that was found murdered in the south of Sweden in 2003. Whole-genome sequencing was performed on DNA originating from a bone sample. Three replicates of libraries were prepared using ThruPLEX DNA-seq Kit (Takara) which were sequenced on a HiSeq X instrument (Illumina). A mean coverage of 30X was obtained when the sequencing reads were mapped to a human reference genome. Following further bioinformatic processing, allele calling, quality checks and filtering to match the genealogy DNA database SNPs, genotypes for approximately one million SNPs were established. The resulting SNP genotypes were then used to search for relatives in the genealogy DNA database GEDmatch (www.gedmatch.com). A candidate list of relatives was obtained which was further processed using traditional genealogy methods in order to get leads about the identity of the unknown. In summary, this report shows how whole-genome sequencing successfully can be applied on forensic samples to create the SNP genotypes required for searches in genealogy DNA databases for the purpose of generating leads to identify missing or unknown persons, including perpetrators and victims.
DNA yield and STR typing success differ among skeletal element types and within individual bones. Consequently, it is necessary to identify the skeletal elements and their intra-skeletal parts that ...will most likely yield utilizable and informative endogenous DNA for human identification of skeletal remains. The petrous portion of the temporal bone has been shown to be the most suitable skeletal part for sampling archaeological skeletons, and it has also been used successfully in some forensic cases. When all representative bone types were analyzed for three complete Second World War skeletons, metatarsals and metacarpals yielded more DNA than petrous bones (which generated full profiles even if the DNA yield was lower) and, among almost 200 Second World War metatarsals and metacarpals analyzed, metacarpals III were found to be the highest-yielding bones. To further improve the sampling strategy in DNA analysis of aged skeletal remains, a comparison between 26 petrous bones and 30 metacarpals III from Second World War skeletons was made considering intra-bone DNA yield variability. In metacarpals III only epiphyses were sampled, and in petrous bones only the dense part within the otic capsule was used. To exclude the influence of taphonomic issues as much as possible, petrous bones and metacarpals III from a single Second World War mass grave were examined. The difference between petrous bones and metacarpals III was explored by measuring nuclear DNA yield and success of STR typing. After cleaning the samples, full demineralization extraction was used to decalcify 0.5 g of powdered bone. PowerQuant (Promega) was used to determine DNA content and DNA degradation rates, and STR typing was performed using the PowerPlex ESI 17 Fast System (Promega). Metacarpals III produced the same DNA yields and STR typing success as petrous bones with no intra-individual difference observed in concentration of DNA, degradation rate, percentage of successfully amplified alleles, and intensity of electrophoretic signals. Sampling and processing of metacarpal III epiphyses is consequently recommended for genetic identification of highly degraded skeletal remains in routine forensic casework and in buried non-commingled aged skeletal remains whenever metacarpals III are preserved. Metacarpals III are easy to sample and less prone to contamination with modern DNA because no saw is needed for sampling in comparison to the petrous portion of the temporal bone. The data obtained in this study further improve the sampling strategy for genetic identification of Second World War skeletal remains in Slovenia.
•Petrous bones are the most suitable skeletal part for sampling ancient skeletons.•Metacarpals III yielded the most DNA in Slovenian Second World War skeletons.•Second World War petrous bones were compared with metacarpals III, and intra-bone DNA variability was considered in sampling.•Metacarpals III produced the same DNA yields and STR typing success as petrous bones.•Whenever possible, metacarpals should be collected and epiphyses used for DNA identification.
In order to prioritize the exhumation of the most informative reference relatives to increase the statistical power of a reference group, a conditional simulation approach for missing person ...identification that combines both exclusion and inclusion power in reference families has been previously developed. The aim of this study is to empirically validate this approach by comparing its predicted theoretical prioritization model with the observed changes in statistical power in real cases of our laboratory, in which new relatives had already been added. We conclude that this approach is a reliable tool to choose the most appropriate reference relatives to complete a family group and improve the identification power of a Missing Person (MP).