. Display omitted ► Structural features of 2OG oxygenases involved in substrate recognition are analyzed. ► Crystallographic studies reveal the versatility of the jelly roll fold in substrate binding. ► Defined structural regions that interact with substrate(s) are biased by fold topology. ► The utility of the enzyme–substrate structures for engineering and selective inhibition are discussed. 2-Oxoglutarate (2OG) and ferrous iron dependent oxygenases catalyze two-electron oxidations of a range of small and large molecule substrates, including proteins/peptides/amino acids, nucleic acids/bases, and lipids, as well as natural products including antibiotics and signaling molecules. 2OG oxygenases employ variations of a core double-stranded β-helix (DSBH; a.k.a. jelly-roll, cupin or jumonji C (JmjC)) fold to enable binding of Fe(II) and 2OG in a subfamily conserved manner. The topology of the DSBH limits regions directly involved in substrate binding: commonly the first, second and eighth strands, loops between the second/third and fourth/fifth DSBH strands, and the N-terminal and C-terminal regions are involved in primary substrate, co-substrate and cofactor binding. Insights into substrate recognition by 2OG oxygenases will help to enable selective inhibition and bioengineering studies.