Digital computing is nearing its physical limits as computing needs and energy consumption rapidly increase. Analogue‐memory‐based neuromorphic computing can be orders of magnitude more energy efficient at data‐intensive tasks like deep neural networks, but has been limited by the inaccurate and unpredictable switching of analogue resistive memory. Filamentary resistive random access memory (RRAM) suffers from stochastic switching due to the random kinetic motion of discrete defects in the nanometer‐sized filament. In this work, this stochasticity is overcome by incorporating a solid electrolyte interlayer, in this case, yttria‐stabilized zirconia (YSZ), toward eliminating filaments. Filament‐free, bulk‐RRAM cells instead store analogue states using the bulk point defect concentration, yielding predictable switching because the statistical ensemble behavior of oxygen vacancy defects is deterministic even when individual defects are stochastic. Both experiments and modeling show bulk‐RRAM devices using TiO2‐X switching layers and YSZ electrolytes yield deterministic and linear analogue switching for efficient inference and training. Bulk‐RRAM solves many outstanding issues with memristor unpredictability that have inhibited commercialization, and can, therefore, enable unprecedented new applications for energy‐efficient neuromorphic computing. Beyond RRAM, this work shows how harnessing bulk point defects in ionic materials can be used to engineer deterministic nanoelectronic materials and devices. A resistive memory cell based on the electrochemical migration of oxygen vacancies for in‐memory neuromorphic computing is presented. By using the average statistical behavior of all oxygen vacancies to store analogue information states, this cell overcomes the stochastic and unpredictable switching plaguing filament‐forming memristors, and instead achieves linear, predictable, and deterministic switching.