UNI-MB - logo
UMNIK - logo
 
E-viri
Recenzirano Odprti dostop
  • The Aleph and Other Alleged...
    Smid, Jeroen

    Australasian journal of philosophy, 07/2023, Letnik: 101, Številka: 3
    Journal Article

    Standard principles of mereology, such as the transitivity and asymmetry of proper parthood, have been questioned, using various multi-location scenarios. The most famous of these is Borges's Aleph, although the literature is rife with other examples that allegedly show that some mereological principle is at odds with some form of multi-location. However, the scenarios only support this conclusion given various bridge principles that link location to parthood. I argue that the bridge principles that guarantee the desired conclusion are controversial partly because they give the wrong result in other situations, in particular cases of co-location. Moreover, less controversial bridge principles do not provide an incompatibility result between standard mereological principles and multi-location. Hence, multi-location does not threaten any standard mereological principles.