The fraction of inspired oxygen (FiO2) administered during general anaesthesia varies widely despite international recommendations to administer FiO2 0.8 to all anaesthetised patients to reduce ...surgical site infections (SSIs). Anaesthetists remain concerned that high FiO2 administration intraoperatively may increase harm, possibly through increased oxidative damage and inflammation, resulting in more complications and worse outcomes. In previous systematic reviews associations between FiO2 and SSIs have been inconsistent, but none have examined how FiO2 affects perioperative oxidative stress. We aimed to address this uncertainty by reviewing the available literature.
EMBASE, MEDLINE, and Cochrane databases were searched from inception to March 9, 2020 for RCTs comparing higher with lower perioperative FiO2 and quantifying oxidative stress in adults undergoing noncardiac surgery. Candidate studies were independently screened by two reviewers and references hand-searched. Methodological quality was assessed using the Cochrane Collaboration Risk of Bias tool.
From 19 438 initial results, seven trials (n=422) were included. Four studies reported markers of oxidative stress during Caesarean section (n=328) and three reported oxidative stress during elective colon surgery (n=94). Risk of bias was low (four studies) to moderate (three studies). Pooled results suggested high FiO2 was associated with greater malondialdehyde, protein-carbonyl concentrations and reduced xanthine oxidase concentrations, together with reduced antioxidant markers such as superoxide dismutase and total sulfhydryl levels although total antioxidant status was unchanged.
Higher FiO2 may be associated with elevated oxidative stress during surgery. However, limited studies have specifically reported biomarkers of oxidation. Given the current clinical controversy concerning perioperative oxygen therapy, further research is urgently needed in this area.
Supplemental oxygen is frequently administered to patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), including ARDS secondary to viral illness such as coronavirus disease 19 (COVID-19). An ...up-to-date understanding of how best to target this therapy (e.g. arterial partial pressure of oxygen (PaO
) or peripheral oxygen saturation (SpO
) aim) in these patients is urgently required.
To address how oxygen therapy should be targeted in adults with ARDS (particularly ARDS secondary to COVID-19 or other respiratory viruses) and requiring mechanical ventilation in an intensive care unit, and the impact oxygen therapy has on mortality, days ventilated, days of catecholamine use, requirement for renal replacement therapy, and quality of life.
We searched the Cochrane COVID-19 Study Register, CENTRAL, MEDLINE, and Embase from inception to 15 May 2020 for ongoing or completed randomized controlled trials (RCTs).
Two review authors independently assessed all records in accordance with standard Cochrane methodology for study selection. We included RCTs comparing supplemental oxygen administration (i.e. different target PaO
or SpO
ranges) in adults with ARDS and receiving mechanical ventilation in an intensive care setting. We excluded studies exploring oxygen administration in patients with different underlying diagnoses or those receiving non-invasive ventilation, high-flow nasal oxygen, or oxygen via facemask.
One review author performed data extraction, which a second review author checked. We assessed risk of bias in included studies using the Cochrane 'Risk of bias' tool. We used the GRADE approach to judge the certainty of the evidence for the following outcomes; mortality at longest follow-up, days ventilated, days of catecholamine use, and requirement for renal replacement therapy.
We identified one completed RCT evaluating oxygen targets in patients with ARDS receiving mechanical ventilation in an intensive care setting. The study randomized 205 mechanically ventilated patients with ARDS to either conservative (PaO
55 to 70 mmHg, or SpO
88% to 92%) or liberal (PaO
90 to 105 mmHg, or SpO
≥ 96%) oxygen therapy for seven days. Overall risk of bias was high (due to lack of blinding, small numbers of participants, and the trial stopping prematurely), and we assessed the certainty of the evidence as very low. The available data suggested that mortality at 90 days may be higher in those participants receiving a lower oxygen target (odds ratio (OR) 1.83, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.03 to 3.27). There was no evidence of a difference between the lower and higher target groups in mean number of days ventilated (14.0, 95% CI 10.0 to 18.0 versus 14.5, 95% CI 11.8 to 17.1); number of days of catecholamine use (8.0, 95% CI 5.5 to 10.5 versus 7.2, 95% CI 5.9 to 8.4); or participants receiving renal replacement therapy (13.7%, 95% CI 5.8% to 21.6% versus 12.0%, 95% CI 5.0% to 19.1%). Quality of life was not reported.
We are very uncertain as to whether a higher or lower oxygen target is more beneficial in patients with ARDS and receiving mechanical ventilation in an intensive care setting. We identified only one RCT with a total of 205 participants exploring this question, and rated the risk of bias as high and the certainty of the findings as very low. Further well-conducted studies are urgently needed to increase the certainty of the findings reported here. This review should be updated when more evidence is available.
Diurnal and seasonal rhythmicity, entrained by environmental and nutritional cues, is a vital part of all life on Earth operating at every level of organization; from individual cells, to ...multicellular organisms, whole ecosystems and societies. Redox processes are intrinsic to physiological function and circadian regulation, but how they are integrated with other regulatory processes at the whole-body level is poorly understood. Circadian misalignment triggered by a major stressor (e.g. viral infection with SARS-CoV-2) or recurring stressors of lesser magnitude such as shift work elicit a complex stress response that leads to desynchronization of metabolic processes. This in turn challenges the system's ability to achieve redox balance due to alterations in metabolic fluxes (redox rewiring). We infer that the emerging ‘alternative redox states' do not always revert readily to their evolved natural states; ‘Long COVID’ and other complex disorders of unknown aetiology are the clinical manifestations of such rearrangements. To better support and successfully manage bodily resilience to major stress and other redox challenges needs a clear perspective on the pattern of the hysteretic response for the interaction between the redox system and the circadian clock. Characterization of this system requires repeated (ideally continuous) recording of relevant clinical measures of the stress responses and whole-body redox state (temporal redox phenotyping). The human/animal body is a complex ‘system of systems’ with multi-level buffering capabilities, and it requires consideration of the wider dynamic context to identify a limited number of stress-markers suitable for routine clinical decision making. Systematically mapping the patterns and dynamics of redox biomarkers along the stressor/disease trajectory will provide an operational model of whole-body redox regulation/balance that can serve as basis for the identification of effective interventions which promote health by enhancing resilience.
Patients admitted to intensive care often require treatment with invasive mechanical ventilation and high concentrations of oxygen. Mechanical ventilation can cause acute lung injury that may be ...exacerbated by oxygen therapy. Uncertainty remains about which oxygen therapy targets result in the best clinical outcomes for these patients. This review aims to determine whether higher or lower oxygenation targets are beneficial for mechanically ventilated adult patients.
Excerpta Medica dataBASE, Medical Literature Analysis and Retrieval System Online, and Cochrane medical databases were searched from inception through to February 28, 2021.
Randomized controlled trials comparing higher and lower oxygen targets in adult patients receiving invasive mechanical ventilation via an endotracheal tube or tracheostomy in an intensive care setting.
Study setting, participant type, participant numbers, and intervention targets were captured. Outcome measures included "mortality at longest follow-up" (primary), mechanical ventilator duration and free days, vasopressor-free days, patients on renal replacement therapy, renal replacement free days, cost benefit, and quality of life scores. Evidence certainty and risk of bias were evaluated using Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation and the Cochrane Risk of Bias tool. A random-effects models was used. Post hoc subgroup analysis looked separately at studies comparing hypoxemia versus normoxemia and normoxemia versus hyperoxemia.
Data from eight trials (4,415 participants) were analyzed. Comparing higher and lower oxygen targets, there was no difference in mortality (odds ratio, 0.95; 95% CI, 0.74-1.22), but heterogeneous and overlapping target ranges limit the validity and clinical relevance of this finding. Data from seven studies (
= 4,245) demonstrated targeting normoxemia compared with hyperoxemia may reduce mortality at longest follow-up (0.73 0.57-0.95) but this estimate had very low certainty. There was no difference in mortality between targeting relative hypoxemia or normoxemia (1.20 0.83-1.73).
This systematic review and meta-analysis identified possible increased mortality with liberal oxygen targeting strategies and no difference in morbidity between high or low oxygen targets in mechanically ventilated adults. Findings were limited by substantial heterogeneity in study methodology and further research is urgently required to define optimal oxygen therapy targets.
Oxygen is the most used drug in anaesthesia. Despite such widespread use, optimal perioperative oxygen administration remains highly controversial because of concerns about the competing harms of ...both hyperoxia and hypoxia.
Notwithstanding a Cochrane review concluding that routinely administering a fractional inspired oxygen concentration (FiO2) >0.6 intraoperatively might increase postoperative morbidity and mortality, the World Health Organization (WHO) currently recommends all anaesthetised patients receive 0.8 FiO2 during and immediately after surgery to reduce surgical site infections. Results from the largest trial available at the time of these two reviews (suggesting long-term survival may be worse with high FiO2, particularly in patients with malignant disease) were considered ‘biologically implausible’ by the WHO's Guideline Development Group. In addition, the integrity of some perioperative oxygen studies has been challenged. Resolving these controversies is of fundamental importance to all perioperative clinicians.
This narrative review is based on the inaugural BJA William Mapleson lecture delivered by the senior author (AC) at the 2023 annual meeting of the Royal College of Anaesthetists in Birmingham. We present the current evidence for perioperative oxygen administration and contrast this with how oxygen therapy is targeted in other specialties (e.g. intensive care medicine). We will explore whether anaesthetists follow the WHO recommendations and consider how oxygen administration affects the stress response to surgery. We reason that novel clinical trial designs in combination with targeted experimental medicine studies will be required to improve our understanding of how best to optimise individualised perioperative oxygenation—a cornerstone of anaesthesia.
The chemical and functional interactions between Reactive Oxygen (ROS), Nitrogen (RNS) and Sulfur (RSS) species allow organisms to detect and respond to metabolic and environmental stressors, such as ...exercise and altitude exposure. Whether redox markers and constituents of this 'Reactive Species Interactome' (RSI) differ in concentration between arterial and venous blood is unknown. We hypothesised that such measurements may provide useful insight into metabolic/redox regulation at the whole-body level and would be consistent between individuals exposed to identical challenges. An exploratory study was performed during the Xtreme Alps expedition in 2010 in which four healthy individuals (2 male, 2 female) underwent paired arterial and central venous blood sampling before, during and after performance of a constant-work-rate cardiopulmonary exercise test, at sea level and again at 4559 m. Unexpectedly, plasma total free thiol and free cysteine concentrations remained substantially elevated at altitude throughout exercise with minimal arteriovenous gradients. Free sulfide concentrations changed only modestly upon combined altitude/exercise stress, whereas bound sulfide levels were lower at altitude than sea-level. No consistent signal indicative of the expected increased oxidative stress and nitrate→nitrite→NO reduction was observed with 4-hydroxynonenal, isoprostanes, nitrate, nitrite, nitroso species and cylic guanosine monophosphate. However, the observed arteriovenous concentration differences revealed a dynamic pattern of response that was unique to each participant. This novel redox metabolomic approach of obtaining quantifiable 'metabolic signatures' to a defined physiological challenge could potentially offer new avenues for personalised medicine.
Acute hypoxic respiratory failure (AHRF) is a prominent feature of severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2) critical illness. The severity of gas exchange impairment correlates ...with worse prognosis, and AHRF requiring mechanical ventilation is associated with substantial mortality. Persistent impaired gas exchange leading to hypoxemia often warrants the prolonged administration of a high fraction of inspired oxygen (FiO
). In SARS-CoV-2 AHRF, systemic vasculopathy with lung microthrombosis and microangiopathy further exacerbates poor gas exchange due to alveolar inflammation and oedema. Capillary congestion with microthrombosis is a common autopsy finding in the lungs of patients who die with coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19)-associated acute respiratory distress syndrome. The need for a high FiO
to normalise arterial hypoxemia and tissue hypoxia can result in alveolar hyperoxia. This in turn can lead to local alveolar oxidative stress with associated inflammation, alveolar epithelial cell apoptosis, surfactant dysfunction, pulmonary vascular abnormalities, resorption atelectasis, and impairment of innate immunity predisposing to secondary bacterial infections. While oxygen is a life-saving treatment, alveolar hyperoxia may exacerbate pre-existing lung injury. In this review, we provide a summary of oxygen toxicity mechanisms, evaluating the consequences of alveolar hyperoxia in COVID-19 and propose established and potential exploratory treatment pathways to minimise alveolar hyperoxia.
Nitrate supplementation in the form of beetroot juice (BRJ) ingestion has been shown to improve exercise tolerance during acute hypoxia, but its effect on exercise physiology remains unstudied during ...sustained terrestrial high altitude exposure. We hypothesized that performing exercise at high altitude would lower circulating nitrate and nitrite levels and that BRJ ingestion would reverse this phenomenon while concomitantly improving key determinants of aerobic exercise performance.
Twenty seven healthy volunteers (21 male) underwent a series of exercise tests at sea level (SL, London, 75 m) and again after 5-8 days at high altitude (HA, Capanna Regina Margherita or "Margherita Hut," 4,559 m). Using a double-blind protocol, participants were randomized to consume a beetroot/fruit juice beverage (three doses per day) with high levels of nitrate (∼0.18 mmol/kg/day) or a nitrate-depleted placebo (∼11.5 μmoles/kg/day) control drink, from 3 days prior to the exercise trials until completion. Submaximal constant work rate cycle tests were performed to determine exercise efficiency and a maximal incremental ramp exercise test was undertaken to measure aerobic capacity, using breath-by-breath pulmonary gas exchange measurements throughout. Concentrations of nitrate, nitrite and nitrosation products were quantified in plasma samples collected at 5 timepoints during the constant work rate tests. Linear mixed modeling was used to analyze data.
At both SL and HA, plasma nitrate concentrations were elevated in the nitrate supplementation group compared to placebo (
< 0.001) but did not change throughout increasing exercise work rate. Delta exercise efficiency was not altered by altitude exposure (
= 0.072) or nitrate supplementation (
= 0.836). V̇O
peak decreased by 24% at high altitude (
< 0.001) and was lower in the nitrate-supplemented group at both sea level and high altitude compared to placebo (
= 0.041). Dietary nitrate supplementation did not alter other peak exercise variables or oxygen consumption at anaerobic threshold. Circulating nitrite and S-nitrosothiol levels unexpectedly rose in a few individuals right after cessation of exercise at high altitude.
Whilst regularly consumed during an 8 days expedition to terrestrial high altitude, nitrate supplementation did not alter exercise efficiency and other exercise physiological variables, except decreasing V̇O
peak. These results and those of others question the practical utility of BRJ consumption during prolonged altitude exposure.