Capillary hemangiomas are space-occupying lesions that rarely affect the central nervous system. When they present within the spinal canal, they can cause insidious symptoms and threaten neurological function. In this study, we present a case of an intradural extramedullary capillary hemangioma of the lumbar spine, discuss our management strategy, and review the current literature. For the first time for this diagnosis, we also provide an operative video. The patient is a previously healthy 40-year-old man who presented with complaints of progressive low back and leg pain, numbness, and intermittent subjective urinary incontinence. MRI revealed a discrete, homogenously enhancing intradural extramedullary lesion at L4. This lesion was resected by performing an L4 laminoplasty, which entails en bloc removal of the L4 lamina and then securing it back into place once the intradural resection and dural closure are completed. Histological analysis revealed a diagnosis of capillary hemangioma. The patient had full resolution of his symptoms postoperatively. Definitive management of spinal capillary hemangiomas involves gross total resection and can be accomplished with laminoplasty. Because these benign tumors can be adherent to adjacent structures, intraoperative neuromonitoring is helpful adjunct to preserve neurological function for a good outcome. Capillary hemangiomas rarely affect the spine but should be considered on the list of differential diagnoses of intradural lesions.