To evaluate Compass, a new instrument for glaucoma screening and diagnosis that combines scanning ophthalmoscopy, automated perimetry, and eye tracking.
A total of 320 human subjects (200 normal, 120 ...with glaucoma) underwent full ophthalmological evaluation and perimetric evaluation using the Humphrey SITA standard 24° test (HFA), and the Compass test that consisted of a full-threshold program on the central 24° with a photograph of the central 30° of the retina. A subgroup of normal subjects and glaucoma patients underwent a second Compass test during the same day in order to study test-retest variability. After exclusion of 30 patients due to protocol rules, a database was created to compare the Compass to the HFA, and to evaluate retinal image quality and fixation stability.
The difference in mean sensitivity between Compass and HFA was -1.02 ± 1.55 dB in normal subjects (p<0.001) and -1.01 ± 2.81 dB in glaucoma (p<0.001). Repeatability SD for the average sensitivity was 1.53 for normal subjects and 1.84 for glaucoma. Test time with the Compass was 634±96 s (607±78 for normals, 678±108 for glaucoma). Compass analysis showed the percentage of fixation within the central 1° was 86.6% in normal subjects, and 79.3% in glaucoma patients. Color image quality was sufficient for diagnostic use in >65% of cases; Image-based diagnosis was in accordance with the initial diagnosis in 85% of the subjects.
Based on preliminary results, Compass showed useful diagnostic characteristics for the study of glaucoma, and combined morphological information with functional data.
To evaluate if retinal sensitivity values obtained with a dedicated (screening) device can be used to functionally identify early and intermediate age-related macular degeneration (ARMD).
A fully ...automatic fundus perimeter combined with an image-stabilized scanning laser ophthalmoscope was used in 200 ARMD patients (319 eyes) in 5 study sites. The age-matched control group consisted of 200 normals. Sensitivity point values (S values), mean retinal sensitivity, number of points below 24 dB (K value, cutoff for normal values) and fixation stability were recorded.
Of 319 eyes, 164 were classified as early (AREDS 2) and 155 as intermediate (AREDS 3) ARMD. Mean retinal sensitivity was significantly reduced in ARMD patients versus normals (p < 0.001). K values were different between normals and ARMD patients (p < 0.001). Fixation stability did not differ between early and intermediate ARMD patients.
Macular sensitivity is reduced in patients with early and intermediate ARMD when compared to age-matched normals. These changes may be detected with a screening device.
To determine the goodness-of-prediction of the fitting routine by measuring the difference between topographic corneal surfaces and their Zernike reconstructions as a function of polynomial order and ...optical zone size for various corneal conditions.
Corneal research laboratory in a university eye center.
Corneal topography maps (N = 253) were obtained from the Louisiana State University Eye Center. A variety of corneal conditions were used: normals; astigmatism; laser in situ keratomileusis, photorefractive keratoplasty (PRK), and radial keratotomy (RK) postoperative cases (myopic spherical corrections); keratoconus suspect; mild, moderate, and severe keratoconus; pellucid marginal degeneration; contact lens-induced corneal warpage; and penetrating keratoplasty. The root-mean-square (RMS) error of the goodness-of-prediction of the Zernike representation of corneal surface elevation was extracted for 4, 6, and 10 mm optical zones, whereas Zernike radial orders were varied from 3 to 14 in 1-order steps. The mean +/- SEM of the RMS error was plotted as a function of Zernike order and compared with criteria for normal surface fits.
Fitting accuracy improved as more Zernike terms were included, but some conditions showed significant errors (when compared with normal surfaces), even with many added terms. For a 6 mm optical zone, the normal cornea group had the lowest RMS error and did not require terms above the 4th order to achieve <0.25 microm RMS error. Astigmatism met the 0.25 microm threshold at the 5th order, whereas keratoconus suspect required 7 orders. Laser in situ keratomileusis and PRK met the 0.25 microm threshold at the 8th order, whereas RK required 10 orders. Contact lens-induced corneal warpage and mild keratoconus needed 12 orders to meet the 0.25 microm threshold, whereas pellucid marginal degeneration, moderate and severe keratoconus, and keratoplasty categories were not well fitted even at 14 orders.
A 4th-order Zernike polynomial appeared reliable for modeling the normal cornea, but using a 4th-order fitting routine with an abnormal corneal surface caused a loss of fine-detail shape information. As more Zernike terms were added, the accuracy of the fit improved, and the result approached the minimum error found with normal corneas. Unless sufficient higher-order Zernike terms are included when analyzing irregular surfaces, some diagnostic applications of Zernike coefficients may not be rigorous. This conclusion also suggests that wavefront shape analysis is similarly dependent on the number of orders used. Current surgical corrections based on normal-eye wavefronts may fail to capture all visually relevant aberrations in abnormal eyes, such as those having laser retreatments or experiencing corneal warpage from contact lens wear. A clinical goodness-of-fit or goodness-of-prediction index would indicate whether the number of terms in use has fully accounted for all of the visually significant aberrations present in the eye.
To evaluate the variability of subjective corneal topography map classification between different experienced examiners and the impact of changing from an absolute to a normative scale on the ...classifications.
Preoperative axial curvature maps using Scheimpflug imaging obtained with the Pentacam HR (Oculus Optikgeräte, Wetzlar, Germany) and clinical parameters were sent to 11 corneal topography specialists for subjective classification according to the Ectasia Risk Scoring System. The study population included two groups: 11 eyes that developed ectasia after LASIK and 14 eyes that had successful and stable LASIK outcomes. Each case was first reviewed using the absolute scale masked to the patient group. After 3 months, the same cases were represented using a normative scale and reviewed again by the same examiners for new classifications masked to the patient group.
Using the absolute scale, 17 of 25 (68%) cases had variations on the classifications from 0 to 4 for the same eye across examiners, and the overall agreement with the mode was 60%. Using the normative scale, the classifications from 11 of 25 (44%) cases varied from 0 to 4 for the same eye across examiners, and the overall agreement with the mode was 61%. Eight examiners (73%) reported statistically higher scores (P < .05) when using the normative scale. Considering all 550 topographic analyses (25 cases, 11 examiners, and two scales), the same classification from the two scales was reported for 121 case pairs (44%).
There was significant inter-observer variability in the subjective classifications using the same scale, and significant intra-observer variability between scales. Changing from an absolute to a normative scale increased the scores on the classifications by the same examiner, but significant inter-observer variability in the subjective interpretation of the maps still persisted.
Four videokeratographic methods for keratoconus detection were compared with a neural network approach.
A classification neural network for keratoconus screening was designed to detect the presence ...of keratoconus (KC) or keratoconus suspects (KCS); a separate cone severity network graded the severity of conelike topography patterns consistent with KC or KCS. Three hundred TMS-1 examinations (Tomey) were randomly divided into training and test sets. Ten topographic indexes were network inputs. Nine categories were used: normal, astigmatism, KC, KCS, contact lens-induced warpage, pellucid marginal degeneration, photorefractive keratectomy, radial keratotomy, and penetrating keratoplasty. KC was subdivided into KC1 (mild), KC2 (moderate), and KC3 (advanced). There were three outputs for the classification network (KC, KCS, and OTHER); target output values of 0 = OTHER, 0.25 = KCS, 0.5 = KC1, 0.75 = KC2, and 1.0 = KC3 were used for the severity network.
The best-trained classification network had 100% accuracy, specificity, and sensitivity for the test set. The severity network had mean outputs (+/-standard deviation) of OTHER = 0.02+/-0.02, KCS = 0.21+/-0.05, KC1 = 0.52+/-0.17, KC2 = 0.74+/-0.12, and KC3 = 0.91+/-0.15. The severity network output for all categories was well correlated to the keratoconus prediction index (R = 0.892, P < 0.0001). The classification network had an overall accuracy and specificity significantly better (P < or = 0.005) than the Klyce/Maeda keratoconus index (KCI) test, the Rabinowitz test (K & I-S), and simulated keratometry (average Sim K). However, there were no significant differences in keratoconus sensitivity between the classification network, KCI, and K & I-S. The sensitivity and specificity of average Sim K were significantly worse than those of the other tests. The classification network had significantly better sensitivity (P < 0.001) and specificity (P = 0.025) for KCS detection than the K & I-S.
The neural networks completely distinguished KC from KCS and from topographies that resembled KC. The network approach equaled the sensitivity of currently used tests for keratoconus detection and outperformed them in terms of accuracy and specificity.
Zernike expansion has been selected for use in describing wavefront aberrations in the human eye. The advantages and limitations of this approach are assessed for eyes with varying degrees of ...aberration.
Corneal topography examinations were taken with the Nidek OPD-Scan topographer/aberrometer. These higher data density corneal topography examinations were converted to height data and subsequently to wavefront representations. System noise was evaluated with a 2D frequency analysis of 43-D test balls. Both Zernike polynomials and 2D Fourier transforms were used to evaluate fidelity in the presentation of the point spread function. A display format for potential clinical use was developed based upon Zernike decomposition.
Systematic noise from the corneal topographer was found to be minimal and, when eliminated, produced small changes in the point spread function. Using Zernike decomposition up to the 30th order failed to preserve the higher frequency aberrations present in aberrated eyes. Use of a Zernike decomposition display with a fixed micron scale presented only clinically significant details of spherical aberration, coma, trefoil, irregular components above third order and total higher-order aberrations (above second order).
Zernike polynomials excel in extracting the low-order optical characteristics of visual optics. Zernikes accurately represent both low- and high-order aberrations in normal eyes where high-order aberrations are clinically insignificant. For eyes after corneal surgery or eyes with corneal pathology such as keratoconus that have significant higher-order aberrations, the Zernike method fails to capture all clinically significant higher-order aberrations.
The significance of ocular or corneal aberrations may be subject to misinterpretation whenever eyes with different pupil sizes or the application of different Zernike expansion orders are compared. A ...method is shown that uses simple mathematical interpolation techniques based on normal data to rapidly determine the clinical significance of aberrations, without concern for pupil and expansion order.
Corneal topography maps (TOMEY, Inc, Nagoya, Japan) from 30 normal corneas were collected, and the corneal wave front error was analyzed by Zernike polynomial decomposition into specific aberration types for pupil diameters of 3, 5, 7, and 10 mm and Zernike expansion orders of 6, 8, 10, and 12. Using this 4 × 4 matrix of pupil sizes and fitting orders, the best-fitting 3-dimensional functions were determined for the mean and standard deviation of the root-mean-square error for specific aberrations. The functions were encoded into a software application to determine the significance of data acquired from nonnormal cases.
The best-fitting functions for 6 types of aberrations were determined: defocus, astigmatism, prism, coma, spherical aberration, and all higher-order aberrations. A clinical screening method of color coding the significance of aberrations in normal, postoperative laser in situ keratomileusis, and keratoconus cases having different pupil sizes and different expansion orders is demonstrated.
A method to calibrate wave front aberrometry devices using a standard sample of normal cases was devised. This method could be potentially useful in clinical studies involving patients with uncontrolled pupil sizes or in studies that compare data from aberrometers that use different Zernike fitting-order algorithms.
The purpose of this study was to determine whether a combination of vitamins B6, B9, and B12 is an effective intervention for reducing the signs and symptoms of nonproliferative diabetic retinopathy.
...Ten subjects with type 2 diabetes mellitus (n = 20 eyes) with clinically diagnosed mild to moderate nonproliferative diabetic retinopathy were recruited from a private practice ophthalmology clinic for this open-label, uncontrolled, prospective six-month study. Metanx® vitamin tablets (containing 3 mg L-methylfolate calcium, 35 mg pyridoxal-5'-phosphate, and 2 mg methylcobalamin) were administered at a dosage of two tablets daily. Primary outcome indicators were the percent change in mean retinal sensitivity threshold measured by macular microperimetry and the percent change in mean central retinal thickness measured by spectral-domain optical coherence tomography.
Three subjects were lost to follow-up. In the remaining seven subjects, two of 14 eyes had foveal edema that prevented microperimetry measurements due to poor fixation. The remaining 12 eyes showed a nonlinear improvement in mean threshold retinal sensitivity (P < 0.001). Overall change in mean central retinal thickness in 14 eyes was linear (R(2) = 0.625; P = 0.034), with a significant reduction between one and six months (P = 0.012).
In this pilot study, the Metanx intervention appeared to have some beneficial effects with respect to reducing retinal edema and increasing light sensitivity in subjects with nonproliferative diabetic retinopathy.