In most cell signaling experiments, analytes are measured one Western blot lane at a time in a semiquantitative and often poorly specific manner, limiting our understanding of network biology and ...hindering the translation of novel therapeutics and diagnostics. We show the feasibility of using multiplex immuno-MRM for phospho-pharmacodynamic measurements, establishing the potential for rapid and precise quantification of cell signaling networks. A 69-plex immuno-MRM assay targeting the DNA damage response network was developed and characterized by response curves and determinations of intra- and inter-assay repeatability. The linear range was ≥3 orders of magnitude, the median limit of quantification was 2.0 fmol/mg, the median intra-assay variability was 10% CV, and the median interassay variability was 16% CV. The assay was applied in proof-of-concept studies to immortalized and primary human cells and surgically excised cancer tissues to quantify exposure–response relationships and the effects of a genomic variant (ATM kinase mutation) or pharmacologic (kinase) inhibitor. The study shows the utility of multiplex immuno-MRM for simultaneous quantification of phosphorylated and nonmodified peptides, showing feasibility for development of targeted assay panels to cell signaling networks.
Immunoaffinity enrichment of peptides coupled to targeted, multiple reaction monitoring-mass spectrometry (immuno-MRM) has recently been developed for quantitative analysis of peptide and protein ...expression. As part of this technology, antibodies are generated to short, linear, tryptic peptides that are well-suited for detection by mass spectrometry. Despite its favorable analytical performance, a major obstacle to widespread adoption of immuno-MRM is a lack of validated affinity reagents because commercial antibody suppliers are reluctant to commit resources to producing anti-peptide antibodies for immuno-MRM while the market is much larger for conventional technologies, especially Western blotting and ELISA. Part of this reluctance has been the concern that affinity reagents generated to short, linear, tryptic peptide sequences may not perform well in traditional assays that detect full-length proteins. In this study, we test the feasibility and success rates of generating immuno-MRM monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) (targeting tryptic peptide antigens) that are also compatible with conventional, protein-based immuno-affinity technologies. We generated 40 novel, peptide immuno-MRM assays and determined that the cross-over success rates for using immuno-MRM monoclonals for Western blotting is 58% and for ELISA is 43%, which compare favorably to cross-over success rates amongst conventional immunoassay technologies. These success rates could most likely be increased if conventional and immuno-MRM antigen design strategies were combined, and we suggest a workflow for such a comprehensive approach. Additionally, the 40 novel immuno-MRM assays underwent fit-for-purpose analytical validation, and all mAbs and assays have been made available as a resource to the community via the Clinical Proteomic Tumor Analysis Consortium's (CPTAC) Antibody (http://antibodies.cancer.gov) and Assay Portals (http://assays.cancer.gov), respectively. This study also represents the first determination of the success rate (92%) for generating mAbs for immuno-MRM using a recombinant B cell cloning approach, which is considerably faster than the traditional hybridoma approach.
Peptide immunoaffinity enrichment coupled to selected reaction monitoring (SRM) mass spectrometry (immuno-SRM) has emerged as a technology with great potential for quantitative proteomic assays. One ...advantage over traditional immunoassays is the tremendous potential for concurrent quantification of multiple analytes from a given sample (i.e. multiplex analysis). We sought to explore the capacity of the immuno-SRM technique for analyzing large numbers of analytes by evaluating the multiplex capabilities and demonstrating the sequential analysis of groups of peptides from a single sample. To evaluate multiplex analysis, immuno-SRM assays were arranged in groups of 10, 20, 30, 40, and 50 peptides using a common set of reagents. The multiplex immuno-SRM assays were used to measure synthetic peptides added to plasma covering several orders of magnitude concentration. Measurements made in large multiplex groups were highly correlated (r2 ≥ 0.98) and featured good agreement (bias ≤ 1%) compared with single-plex assays or a 10-plex configuration. The ability to sequentially enrich sets of analyte peptides was demonstrated by enriching groups of 10 peptides from a plasma sample in a sequential fashion. The data show good agreement (bias ≤ 1.5%) and similar reproducibility regardless of enrichment order. These significant advancements demonstrate the utility of immuno-SRM for analyzing large numbers of analytes, such as in large biomarker verification experiments or in pathway-based targeted analysis.
Targeted mass spectrometry (MS)-based proteomic assays, such as multiplexed multiple reaction monitoring (MRM)-MS assays, enable sensitive and specific quantification of proteotypic peptides as ...stoichiometric surrogates for proteins. Efforts are underway to expand the use of MRM-MS assays in clinical environments, which requires a reliable strategy to monitor proteolytic digestion efficiency within individual samples. Towards this goal, extended stable isotope-labeled standard (SIS) peptides (hE), which incorporate native proteolytic cleavage sites, can be spiked into protein lysates prior to proteolytic (trypsin) digestion, and release of the tryptic SIS peptide (hT) can be monitored. However, hT measurements alone cannot monitor the extent of digestion and may be confounded by matrix effects specific to individual patient samples; therefore, they are not sufficient to monitor sample-to-sample digestion variability. We hypothesized that measuring undigested hE, along with its paired hT, would improve detection of digestion issues compared to only measuring hT. We tested the ratio of the SIS pair measurements, or hE/hT, as a quality control (QC) metric of trypsin digestion for two MRM assays: a direct-MRM (398 targets) and an immuno-MRM (126 targets requiring immunoaffinity peptide enrichment) assay, with extended SIS peptides observable for 54% (216) and 62% (78) of the targets, respectively. We evaluated the quantitative bias for each target in a series of experiments that adversely affected proteolytic digestion (e.g., variable digestion times, pH, and temperature). We identified a subset of SIS pairs (36 for the direct-MRM, 7 for the immuno-MRM assay) for which the hE/hT ratio reliably detected inefficient digestion that resulted in decreased assay sensitivity and unreliable endogenous quantification. The hE/hT ratio was more responsive to a decrease in digestion efficiency than a metric based on hT measurements alone. For clinical-grade MRM-MS assays, this study describes a ready-to-use QC panel and also provides a road map for designing custom QC panels.
Display omitted
•Extended SIS peptides can control for trypsin digestion in targeted MS-based assays.•Monitoring extended SIS along with tryptic SIS peptides is the basis of a QC metric.•The ratio of extended to tryptic SIS is a useful in-sample QC metric for digestion.•The QC metric also correlates with assay sensitivity and quantification fidelity.•Additional assays can apply this ready-to-use QC panel or identify custom panels.
Extended stable isotope-labeled standard (SIS) peptides (hE), proteolytically digested to release the targeted tryptic SIS peptide (hT) form, have been shown to control for trypsin. We found that by monitoring hE along with hT, the resulting hE/hT ratio is a useful in-sample QC metric for digestion efficiency that correlates with endogenous measurement sensitivity and quantification fidelity. This study describes a ready-to-use QC panel as well as a path for identifying custom QC panels that can be applied to additional mass spectrometry-based assays.
A wealth of proteogenomic data has been generated using cancer samples to deepen our understanding of the mechanisms of cancer and how biological networks are altered in association with somatic ...mutation of tumor suppressor genes, such as TP53 and PTEN. To generate functional signatures of TP53 or PTEN loss, we profiled the RNA and phosphoproteomes of the MCF10A epithelial cell line, along with its congenic TP53- or PTEN-knockout derivatives, upon perturbation with the monofunctional DNA alkylating agent methyl methanesulfonate (MMS) vs. mock treatment. To enable quantitative and reproducible mass spectrometry data generation, the cell lines were SILAC-labeled (stable isotope labeling with amino acids in cell culture), and the experimental design included label swapping and biological replicates. All data are publicly available and may be used to advance our understanding of the TP53 and PTEN tumor suppressor genes and to provide functional signatures for bioinformatic analyses of proteogenomic datasets.
To improve the understanding of chemo-refractory high-grade serous ovarian cancers (HGSOCs), we characterized the proteogenomic landscape of 242 (refractory and sensitive) HGSOCs, representing one ...discovery and two validation cohorts across two biospecimen types (formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded and frozen). We identified a 64-protein signature that predicts with high specificity a subset of HGSOCs refractory to initial platinum-based therapy and is validated in two independent patient cohorts. We detected significant association between lack of Ch17 loss of heterozygosity (LOH) and chemo-refractoriness. Based on pathway protein expression, we identified 5 clusters of HGSOC, which validated across two independent patient cohorts and patient-derived xenograft (PDX) models. These clusters may represent different mechanisms of refractoriness and implicate putative therapeutic vulnerabilities.
Display omitted
•A comprehensive proteogenomic analysis of 242 HGSOC tumors was performed•A lack of Chr17-LOH was observed to be associated with refractoriness•A 64-protein signature predicts refractoriness in multiple tumor cohorts•Pathway-based clustering reveals 5 subtypes validated in independent cohorts
Patients with high-grade serous ovarian cancers (HGSOCs) have a poor outcome, with the standard of care not having changed over the decades. A detailed characterization of the proteogenomic landscape of HGSOCs across multiple cohorts and validation studies identifies a distinct signature that predicts with high specificity a subset of patients with chemotherapy-refractory cancers and implicates potential therapeutic vulnerabilities.
A major bottleneck for validation of new clinical diagnostics is the development of highly sensitive and specific assays for quantifying proteins. We previously described a method, stable isotope ...standards with capture by antipeptide antibodies, wherein a specific tryptic peptide is selected as a stoichiometric representative of the protein from which it is cleaved, is enriched from biological samples using immobilized antibodies, and is quantitated using mass spectrometry against a spiked internal standard to yield a measure of protein concentration. In this study, we optimized a magnetic-bead-based platform amenable to high-throughput peptide capture and demonstrated that antibody capture followed by mass spectrometry can achieve ion signal enhancements on the order of 10
3, with precision (CVs <10%) and accuracy (relative error ∼20%) sufficient for quantifying biomarkers in the physiologically relevant ng/mL range. These methods are generally applicable to any protein or biological fluid of interest and hold great potential for providing a desperately needed bridging technology between biomarker discovery and clinical application.
Despite advances in proteomic technologies, clinical translation of plasma biomarkers remains low, partly due to a major bottleneck between the discovery of candidate biomarkers and costly clinical ...validation studies. Due to a dearth of multiplexable assays, generally only a few candidate biomarkers are tested, and the validation success rate is accordingly low. Previously, mass spectrometry-based approaches have been used to fill this gap but feature poor quantitative performance and were generally limited to hundreds of proteins. Here, we demonstrate the capability of an internal standard triggered-parallel reaction monitoring (IS-PRM) assay to greatly expand the numbers of candidates that can be tested with improved quantitative performance. The assay couples immunodepletion and fractionation with IS-PRM and was developed and implemented in human plasma to quantify 5176 peptides representing 1314 breast cancer biomarker candidates. Characterization of the IS-PRM assay demonstrated the precision (median % CV of 7.7%), linearity (median
> 0.999 over 4 orders of magnitude), and sensitivity (median LLOQ < 1 fmol, approximately) to enable rank-ordering of candidate biomarkers for validation studies. Using three plasma pools from breast cancer patients and three control pools, 893 proteins were quantified, of which 162 candidate biomarkers were verified in at least one of the cancer pools and 22 were verified in all three cancer pools. The assay greatly expands capabilities for quantification of large numbers of proteins and is well suited for prioritization of viable candidate biomarkers.
PDF
