This study aims to explore the moral identity profiles of inspiring social studies teachers. In the research conducted with the systematic grounded theory method, data were collected from 14 teachers using in-depth interviews. These data were analyzed with the technique of continuous comparative analysis. The results show the theoretical items that explain the theory to be gathered around the core category of moral identity and to be constituted of self traits; referenced worldview and beliefs; personality characteristics; ideals, and goals; past experiences; social influences; and educational approach. This study contributes to the explanation of moral identity of inspiring teachers. •This study aims to explore the moral identity profiles of inspiring social studies teachers.•The theoretical items to be gathered around the core category of moral identity.•Moral identity consists of various categories that emerge from the individual's experiences, and social environment.•Data were collected from 14 social studies teachers who were determined to be inspiring teachers.•This study conducted with the systematic grounded theory method.